4 ms·
I think that the idea of private property as an inalienable right is rooted in the enlightenment and on the same level as human rights. It is to protect indivi
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
I think that the idea of private property as an inalienable right is rooted in the enlightenment and on the same level as human rights.
It is to protect individuals against spoliation by the state or powerful, and even to assert an even more basic right to own property at all. It obviously does not mean that property cannot be taken away from its owner but that this must follow a fair and lawful process.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThe Enlightenment never really worked this through. In fact modern economics hijacks a lot of humanist rhetoric (including the idea of rationality and human rights) and glues it rather awkwardly onto concepts that are actually derived from monarchy - specifically individual sovereignty, and a kind of individualised version of divine right which elevates unlimited individual economic freedom-to-profit as the highest possible good. It's actually a bit of a mess, conceptually and practically. Property is really not a simple concept. Most people think of it as "Stuff I own" which reduces the argument to "I don't want the government stealing my house or my furniture," which sounds trivially obvious. In fact all claims on property are complex - see also IP, stocks, and so on - and personal ownership is always a trade-off between individual benefits and socialised/externalised costs. This doesn't just apply to extreme situations like a war economy, or impounding the proceeds of crime - it's inherent in the practice itself. You won't find much about that in orthodox economics.
- atlih 7y agoTaxes are derived from monarchy as well.