10 ms·
> I really wish Apple would put an end to this. This is what really gives lie to the whole walled garden thing. Its selling point is supposed to be in Apple pr
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> I really wish Apple would put an end to this.
This is what really gives lie to the whole walled garden thing. Its selling point is supposed to be in Apple preventing things like this, but here we are in reality and they don't. Meanwhile they do e.g. prevent Signal from replacing Apple's default app for SMS, which has no purpose other than to create barriers for cross-platform competitors to the default apps.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoIts incredible how blocking changing the default app on iOS isn't illegal. Its obviously insanely anti competitive.
- Phlarp 7y agoIt's like people forget "the bar" for anti-trust action used to be bundling the default app (web browser) with the OS (windows)
- yborg 7y agoYou're forgetting the 90% market share part.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoApple doesn't have >90% market share for iOS app stores? Who is their competition? You can't run an Android app on iOS. There are no iOS apps on Amazon or Google Play. That makes it a separate market.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- madeofpalk 7y ago100% market share of your own market doesn't really count.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoSaying "your own market" doesn't mean anything. Every monopolist has 100% of their own market. On the other hand, Clorox has 100% of the "Clorox bleach" market. The question is whether your products and your supposed competitor's products are really the same market. In other words, are your customers the same individuals? Are the products substitutes for one another? For Clorox bleach and other bleach they are. All bleach is the same, they're perfect substitutes, if the store is out of Clorox bleach and you buy some other bleach you'll never even know the difference. For iOS app stores and Android app stores, they're completely different markets. The customers for iOS apps are people with iOS devices and the customers for Android apps are people with Android devices -- almost completely disjoint sets of people. If the iOS app store is down, it's infeasible for the average user to get an app from Google Play instead -- they would have to spend hundreds of dollars to buy an Android phone, then replace all of their other apps, just to substitute one app. It would be like saying AT&T didn't have a monopoly in 1970 because you could change carriers by moving to Canada. They're completely different markets.
- cageface 7y agoApple has more than enough market share, especially in the US, to dictate what the market does. If it doesn't technically have a monopoly in raw numbers that doesn't mean it should be allowed to get away with some of this shit.
- nabnob 7y agoThere are horizontal monopolies and vertical monopolies, there is no law saying that a monopoly needs to have 90% market share.
- wilg 7y agoHelp change the law!
- joelhaasnoot 7y agoDidn't they just get a huge fine for this behaviour? https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/16/apple-fined-1point2-billion-by-french-competition-authorities.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/16/apple-fined-1point2-billion-...
- theNarrative24 7y agoI wish everyone could take a marketing class. Apple, Nintendo, and half the car companies would be out of business.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wilg 7y agoTerrible take. They use it to apply many security and privacy policies! Just not the one we're talking about now. Difficult to figure out how to actually do this, especially so without a crazy UX. They should figure out the default apps thing. Though I don't know what you'd need for SMS, there's not much system integration there besides Siri (which I think supports plugins) and maybe sms: links?
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> They use it to apply many security and privacy policies! Have you read the guidelines? Many words requiring you to use and not discourage users from using Apple's in-app purchasing system (which they get a large cut of), prohibiting you from trying to compete with the App Store or similar, prohibiting app-alternatives they don't control (like remote desktop into a cloud server), requiring "Sign in with Apple" if you use another third party sign in service and that sort of thing. There is a privacy section, but the dirty secret is that they have very little power to enforce it against premeditated abuses. Companies add a feature to their app that gives them a pretext for uploading your data to their servers, and then there is no way for the user or Apple to verify what happens to it from there or determine actual compliance with the privacy policy. So the policies with a compliance enforcement mechanism are the ones that benefit Apple and the ones that are supposed to benefit users in practice don't have one. > Difficult to figure out how to actually do this, especially so without a crazy UX. Actually not so hard in that specific case. They could run the app and not sign in with a Facebook account, and if it tries to contact Facebook servers anyway, reject it. > They should figure out the default apps thing. Though I don't know what you'd need for SMS, there's not much system integration there besides Siri (which I think supports plugins) and maybe sms: links? They prohibit it on purpose. Signal isn't allowed to send and receive SMS on iOS: https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007321171-Can-I-send-SMS-MMS-with-Signal-#ios_sms https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007321171-Ca... > Apple does not allow other apps to replace the default SMS/messaging app. The "Firefox" on iOS isn't even actually Firefox, it's required to use Apple's browser engine.
- ddrt 7y agoInteresting. That clearly violates GDPR and CCPA if it extended to all digital options rather than just websites.
- gnicholas 7y agoWell, the issue isn't just that Apple doesn't put an end to it, it's that Apple doesn't let users toggle this sort of thing off. I think most HNers would say the best solution is for Apple to require apps get permission to do this sort of thing, and let the user decide if they want to have data sent back to FB. There needs to be transparency and a chance to opt in or or at the least to opt out.