3 ms·
I feel the same way. My intuition tells me only some small percentage of HN readers have a NYT subscription, so these posts are of little use. Though the post
by tyingq 7y ago
I feel the same way. My intuition tells me only some small percentage of HN readers have a NYT subscription, so these posts are of little use. Though the posts keep appearing, so perhaps I'm wrong, and it's really substantial...like at least 25%? What's the threshold where it makes sense?
- tzs 7y agoThe value in HN is mostly in the comments, not in its role as a link aggregator. A good 90% of the time when the link is to something I cannot access I can still get all the salient points necessary to understand and benefit from the discussion just from reading the comments. (Also, if it is a story on some reasonably current event or some well known subject there is a good chance a quick visit to a search engine will find some other article that covers nearly everything in the submitted article but that I can read). I think of HN as like a social gathering. Each discussion thread is like a small group of people at a party standing around talking about some topic. It's a big party, and there are dozens of such small groups, constantly forming and breaking up, as people move from group to group. If I'm at a party, and I see a group discussing a book they have read and I have not, I'm either going to ignore their discussion completely if I'm not interested in the topic or am planning on reading the book later and want to avoid spoilers, or go ahead and join in if I'm interested in the topic and and not worried about spoilers and they are discussing it in general enough terms. I'm not going to try to tell everyone at the party that they should only talk about books that everyone there has read. If there is some particular site(s) that someone just does not want to see on HN at all, it's easy to address that with a couple bookmarklets. Here's one that will hide NY Times articles from the listings: javascript: (function () { var stories = document.getElementsByClassName('storylink'); for (var i = 0; i < stories.length; ++i) if (stories[i].href.includes('://www.nytimes')) stories[i].parentNode.parentNode.hidden = 'hidden'; })() It would be easy to expand it to cover multiple sites. Here's one to unhide them: javascript:(function () { var stories = document.getElementsByClassName('storylink'); for (var i = 0; i < stories.length; ++i) stories[i].parentNode.parentNode.hidden = ''; })() Stick those bookmarklets someplace easy to invoke, and then at the cost of one click per page of 30 links you don't have to see the site(s) again.