The reply doesn't necessarily have to be a slam dunk or complete rebuke. Quoting the single sentence, without the next 5, impartially paints the story. It's imb

The reply doesn't necessarily have to be a slam dunk or complete rebuke. Quoting the single sentence, without the next 5, impartially paints the story. It's imbalanced. It denies the reader the level of nuance necessary to pass fair judgment.