4 ms·
Appears to be more of a dagger, but you can't fault the ergonomics. Beautifully designed, and I would guess not just for ceremonial use.
by tomcam 7y ago
Appears to be more of a dagger, but you can't fault the ergonomics. Beautifully designed, and I would guess not just for ceremonial use.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> I would guess not just for ceremonial use. The article has words to the effect that swords were "first forged[] both as weapons and as symbols of authority". Of course that can't possibly be true. They were weapons first. Without the use as weapons, there would be no reason to see them as symbols of authority.
- mehrdadn 7y agoIsn't that what a crown is, though? It's not a weapon but it's a symbol of authority.
- mirimir 7y agoWeapons come before crowns etc. Although crowns are presumably abstracted from helmets.
- mehrdadn 7y ago> Weapons come before crowns etc. I don't think anyone suggested weapons didn't exist before these swords either?
- thaumasiotes 7y agoIn the Iliad (much more recent than this sword, but nonetheless informative in some ways), swords are symbolic of nothing. The text is very clear on what the symbol of royal authority is -- it's a club. ("Scepter") I'd be pretty comfortable with the idea that clubs are no more recent than weapons in general.
- mirimir 7y agoSure, but didn't clubs become symbols because they were weapons?
- thaumasiotes 7y agoYes. One of the oldest Egyptian royal motifs is the king smiting a bound captive or a group of bound captives with a mace.
- inawarminister 7y agoYes, even until the Hellenistic era, the weapon of virtue and honour was... the spear. As exemplified by the poetic sense of a conqueror's demense: his spear-won land. However, other peoples from deep antiquity held sword to higher regard. Like the Celts and Germans. Especially the Germanic tribes, who couldn't make their own swords and need to win them in trade or raid.
- krapp 7y agoAlso IIRC, samurai initially prized archery and the spear over using a sword as marks of their noble status - melee combat with a blade for a samurai was a sign of desperation born of ineptitude with "proper" weapons and tactics. It wasn't until the Edo period when the samurai were relegated to a bureaucracy that the cult around the katana was formed, and sort of retroactively applied to the popular interpretation of history.
- macintux 7y agoUnless the only people who had the resources to control the forges were those in authority.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoGood point. That must be why swords and plows are both equally effective symbols of authority. Forges have always produced utilitarian items for the common man. If, hypothetically, the only thing you could make out of metal was useless, non-weapon swords... then once again there would be no reason to do it at all.
- qmmmur 7y agoJust because you control what comes out of the forge doesn't mean you there is material scarcity. What doesn't scream authority like making a sharp and regal piece of metal for no other reason than to display it. It's like you've never heard of jewellery.
- rsynnott 7y agoI'm not sure that follows. If a sword was totally economically impractical for use as a weapon, to the extent that only the king gets one, but was clearly better than the contemporary weapons, it's not a weapon, it's a symbol of authority.
- agumonkey 7y agosdaggering