6 ms·
There could be some selection bias here. It's based on thermometer readings from Kinsa. And the articles states: Kinsa is receiving two to three times more the
by ineedasername 7y ago
There could be some selection bias here. It's based on thermometer readings from Kinsa. And the articles states:
Kinsa is receiving two to three times more thermometer readings per day than in previous flu seasons
Many more people may be taking thermometer reading that don't really need to, but are being cautious. That would cause the appearance of a proportional drop in high temp readings compared to prior years when really it's just that lots of not-so-sick people are taking their temp lots more.
- mrfusion 7y ago(Removed)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- logicallee 7y agoThis line: >Recent data clearly show the spread of Covid-19. On March 19, the share of Americans with temperatures indicating they had flu-like symptoms was about 4.9% when it typically would be expected to be about 4.0%. This was likely a result of the spread of Covid-19, according to Kinsa’s researchers. ... means that 1 week ago 2,964,898 Americans (0.9%) had Covid-19. Today there are 65,950 recorded cases in the United States: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/
- mrfusion 7y agoWow that’s pretty amazing. Really makes you wonder. And that would just be the people with symptoms right now. It wouldn’t include recovered, asymptomatic, nor people in the incubation period.
- logicallee 7y agoOr the data is invalid. We'll find out soon enough, there are millions of test kits being made available soon.
- o-__-o 7y agoI dont understand what millions of millions of test kits will do. I’m not going to get tested because I have no symptoms. If I had symptoms I would stay in lockdown until it got worse. I don’t see rationale for anyone going to get tested just because (and based on some of the photos from drive through testing, a very easy way to contract COVID yourself)
- ceejayoz 7y agoWhat if you're an asymptomatic carrier? The drive-through test sites are pretty well thought out. You're not likely to get the virus from the car in front of you.
- o-__-o 7y agothe human element will always be a failure mode. Every photo I have seen in my area has shown the testers either reaching into the car or having contact with the patient. So you may be asymptomatic or you may not, but then you possibly end up catching it at the test site but your test was negative so you continue about your routine and start spreading it for real. Not saying the above scenario is a reason not to get tested, I’m saying it’s an argument against getting tested for the sake of getting tested. I am safer and I am making the world safer by locking myself down until this passes. See China as example. I urge you to do the same..
- lukeschlather 7y agoThe error bars on that 4% number are huge, I imagine. Like 4% - 2% or +15%. It's entirely possible you could get 4.9% with zero Covid-19 infections, just from normal variation. Not only possible but I'm sure there's a month in the past decade which had more.
- onion2k 7y agoWhy would the error range be that high? We'd know about huge spikes like that through hospital data, insurance claims, and the sales of drugs, and there aren't spikes like that. The number of people who are ill is relatively stable year-on-year.
- lukeschlather 7y agoI'm not sure what you're basing your assertion on, but the estimated number of symptomatic flu illnesses ranges from 9.3 million to 45 million annually over the past decade, which as I said is roughly from between 3 and 15% of the US population. https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/past-seasons.html https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/past-seasons.html
- beamatronic 7y agoI am definitely buying one of these to support the company.
- robocat 7y agoGiven that US COVID19 fatalities are 1,031 today. Assuming 0.5% death rate after 3 weeks, then 3 weeks ago there were 200000 infected. Assuming cases double every 5 days, then multiply that by 2^4, therefore: The US has 3.2 million infected.
- lukevdp 7y agoHow did you come to the .5% death rate after 3 weeks assumption?
- sadfklsjlkjwt 7y agoIt is not an assumption just arithmetic. Median time to first symptom is 6 days. Median time from first symptom to hospitalization is 5-7 days. Median time to death is about 7 days. Add them up and the median time from contact to death is about 3 weeks.
- robocat 7y agoPick whatever numbers you think are reasonable based on the data you have read - I think you will end up with a worrying result. I use this analysis because the number of deaths is hard to fudge, and the fatality rate after x days, and the infection rate are somewhat measurable (I believe there are statistically valid measurements of those numbers). Any analysis based upon detected cases is deeply flawed IMHO, because detected cases can be anything (look at different countries with wildly different values with no basis in reality).
- logicallee 7y agoThe number of deaths is hard to judge but as for >Assuming cases double every 5 days, then multiply that by 2^4, therefore: ... you're not allowed to assume that. It means on April 26th two thirds of all Americans (204.8 million)will be infected.
- PeterisP 7y agoYou can assume that as long as you're far below saturation. Yes, the logistic curve comes to play at some point, slowing down the spread, stopping at some large proportion of the population - it's plausible that two thirds of Americans will be infected, but that will take longer. However, until the total number of infected is less than, say, 10% of total population, it certainly makes sense to just use the average doubling rate.
- lukevdp 7y agoThere is probably some selection bias - it’s 4.9% of people using the thermometers, which would skew towards people that are thinking they have a fever.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y ago> Due to the emergence of the coronavirus, Kinsa is receiving two to three times more thermometer readings per day than in previous flu seasons. Historically, Kinsa’s methods have been able to account for a sharp rise in the number of people taking tests, said Benjamin Dalziel, a professor at Oregon State University who studies infectious diseases. For his research, Dalziel has ensured that a spike in testing didn’t lead to inaccurate predictions, and so he believes the current decline in illness is a result of social distancing, and not a statistical anomaly. (Dalziel has had research funded by Kinsa in the past). It seems to be accounted for.
- ineedasername 7y agoThat'll teach me to rush to comment when I see something "off" instead of reading the whole thing. I'm tempted to delete a post that isn't useful now, but I should leave it as a minor embarrassing lesson to myself. I wish people would stop upvoting me though... Each one makes me cringe: another person who didn't read very carefully.
- d1str0 7y agoIt’s a reasonable question, and the reply to your OP suggests it was accounted for but I don’t know enough about stats to say that it fully accounts for it. I would say it’s still very reasonable to be skeptical and ask if it is still biased, or still partially biased.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoEh, the response isn't exactly a slam dunk. There's a difference between saying "I thought of that, and it's not a problem" and whatever it is actually not being a problem.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoThe reply doesn't necessarily have to be a slam dunk or complete rebuke. Quoting the single sentence, without the next 5, impartially paints the story. It's imbalanced. It denies the reader the level of nuance necessary to pass fair judgment.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- koheripbal 7y agoThe folks at TWIV (This Week In Virology) noted that regular influenza numbers were sharply down in Japan as a result of people's changing hygiene behaviors. Exactly what we'd expect. It's a silver lining on this whole mess.