7 ms·
Did PWA's take off? What are some famous/big PWA's now? I can't remember ever "installing" anything in a browser as an app, or even being asked if I wanted to
by alkonaut 7y ago
Did PWA's take off? What are some famous/big PWA's now? I can't remember ever "installing" anything in a browser as an app, or even being asked if I wanted to do it. Am I misunderstanding what they are?
- Macha 7y agodevdocs.io is the most successful example I'm aware of. I've never "installed" it as an app, as I don't use a browser that supports that (basically Edge, Safari or Android Chrome), but I've certainly relied on its ability to load without an internet connection for train/plane journeys.
- theturtletalks 7y agohttps://appsco.pe/ https://appsco.pe/ has popular PWAs. They don't need to be installed, they just look and work like an app on the browser.
- lucasmontano 7y agothey really “look” like an app
- arendtio 7y agoThe look depends on how much effort the developer invests. If you take Bootstrap, the resulting PWA looks like a website. If you take Framework7 the resulting PWA looks more like a native App (including animations and the like).
- shawnz 7y agoThe key is the 'P': Progressive. A PWA is just a web app, but one that takes advantage of features you'd typically see in a locally installed application like local storage, notifications, etc. This might mean it has metadata to make it "installable" in browsers that support that, but I wouldn't say that's a requirement to be considered a PWA.
- soapdog 7y agoI'm the OP, I use a lot of PWAs. My main machine is a Surface Pro X and I don't have native apps (as in native aarch64 binaries) for many of the things I'd like to use. So, I'm using PWAs for Instagram, Twitter, Kindle, Pinafore (mastodon client), Spotify, and some of my own. I was developing a feed reader that was supposed to be a client-side-only PWA but that's tricky.
- alkonaut 7y agoWhat is spotify pwa offering that is an improvement over their regular web app? Is it offline streaming (downloaded playlists)?
- soapdog 7y agoTheir regular web app is a pwa... thats the beauty of it. PWAs are not different offer, they are just enhancement on top of web apps. Good PWAs are invisible.
- andrewrothman 7y agoOff topic, but how is this experience using the Surface Pro X as a PWA machine? Does Windows / PWAs work well in tablet form? I was thinking of switching to a similar setup and using it essentially as you describe. Seems like it could be a really lightweight and simple computing environment similar to Chromebooks but still allows you to run traditional Windows apps as well if you need.
- soapdog 7y agoI really like it but I wish Microsoft would support FOSS developers better and provide more support and incentive for them to port more developer tools. There are almost no native aarch64 programming languages for Windows 10. If you keep yourself inside WSL then you're good to go because Linux under aarch64 is quite complete. On the windows side of things you'll probably running a lot of 32bits x86 apps. Which is one of the reasons I like PWAs, they are ISA independent and are working pretty well here. Unfortunately Firefox doesn't support an add to homescreen feature on the desktop, so I used Edge to do it for the apps I want to have a nice icon for (such as spotify). If you're going to use it much like a chromebook then it might be a tad too expensive to be justifiable. I don't regret buying mine at all, I really like it, but I'm sure they'll release cheaper ARM64 Surfaces soon, I'm betting on a Surface Go with ARM64 at some point.
- seanabrahams 7y agoPWAs haven't taken off because Apple won't implement full Push API support in Safari thus forcing you to go through the App Store if your web site or application needs push notifications. The App Store then complains if you try to publish an app that just wraps your web site so that you can have push notifications. It's... infuriating.
- seanabrahams 7y agoFurther, if Apple were truly concerned with the quality of the apps in their store they would free developers from having to submit apps just to support push notifications. Less time reviewing and rejecting apps, less "low quality" apps in the store, happier developers, happier users.
- asadlionpk 7y agoSeeing all the "enable notifications" popups on every site I visit, I am happy that Apple doesn't allow this for websites.
- seanabrahams 7y agoSites could easily only prompt this after you've added them to the home screen. Browsers could, do?, also allow users to set a default of deny all notification requests. The problem is that developers have to spend a significant amount of time and money to get on iPhones because of Apple's policy here. If browsers and devices fully supported PWAs developers could "write once, run everywhere". Instead we have to build separate apps and deal with separate release processes. It's a huge productivity cost.
- p1necone 7y agohttps://www.ghacks.net/2016/02/19/disable-show-notifications-prompts-in-google-chrome/ https://www.ghacks.net/2016/02/19/disable-show-notifications... https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1208251 https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1208251
- pgt 7y agoThe only long-term solution I can think of is to build a competing hardware company, and that’s really hard. But I’m willing to do it.
- StephenCanis 7y agoPWAs are also useful where you want visitors to be able to access a portion of a website while offline. I run a site that hosts audio tours[1] for museums and walking tours. I use PWAs to allow visitors to quickly download the tour onto their phone in case they don't have a data plan or a portion of the tour will not have cell service. Apple definitely makes it difficult to use them effectively. For example you need to use Safari on iOS in order to download the PWA - it won't work if you're on chrome or another third party browser. [1]https://www.youraudiotour.com https://www.youraudiotour.com
- arendtio 7y agoHow should PWA take off, when Apple with a high mobile market share refuses to implement basic APIs like the Push API and other browsers can't run their own engine on iOS? It is abusive, but who cares.
- untog 7y agoThere's a chicken/egg issue here. Apple's support for progressive web apps has been subpar, so it's difficult to justify the extra effort in making a PWA when a major platform doesn't fully support it. Which, in turn, means people turn around and say "why should Apple support PWAs? No-one uses them!"
- woodson 7y agoTwitter’s web client is a PWA
- judah 7y agoMicrosoft will be releasing PWA versions of the Office suite. Twitter, Instagram, Starbucks, Pinterest and more have PWAs as well.
- tsimionescu 7y agoGiven that the OneNote web and Windows 10 apps don't implement Find&Replace (just Find), 5-10 years after their first release, I wouldn't hold my breath for usable Office PWAs. Edit: the official help page on how to do Find&Replace reads like a joke until you realize it is very real: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/find-and-replace-text-in-notes-34b1f7f8-d327-40c5-8b0c-8419425ed68b?ui=en-us&rs=en-us&ad=us https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/find-and-replace-...
- koonsolo 7y agoTwitter client is a PWA.
- alkonaut 7y agoOk I think I'll have to rephrase the question: are there many widely used PWAs that actually go one step further than being a web app using a few of these APIs (spotify, twitter), and actually try to "mimic" desktop apps more (installation, icons, fully offline etc)?
- koonsolo 7y agoI think you should ask the reverse question: are there many apps out there that are not just a frontend to a web service?
- drkstr 7y agoDevDocs is great for offline documentation, and is entirely a PWA. You just preload the doc sets you're interested while online, and they will always be there for you when you need them. Automatic updates can be enabled for when you come back online.