3 ms·
While I'm genuinely thrilled to see this on the front page, this article is incomplete and inaccurate. First, mucus is protective of the lungs. Personally, I d
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
While I'm genuinely thrilled to see this on the front page, this article is incomplete and inaccurate.
First, mucus is protective of the lungs. Personally, I don't believe there really is such a thing as "too much mucus."
As someone with chronic lung problems, I cough up less crap when I can keep mucus production up. So I think that if you have junk in your lungs, it's phlegm, not mucus.
They can be hard to tell apart. The difference is phlegm is basically infected drainage, sort of like the lung equivalent of pus.
Salt and fluids are the two main components of mucus. To support mucus production, you should stay hydrated and get enough salt.
Second, there are other ways to improve lung function in the face of pneumonia and inflammation. Many of these methods are medically prescribed and used daily by people with serious, chronic, incurable lung conditions, such as cystic fibrosis.
I have talked about this before. I don't really want to harp on it or argue with people.
I'm not a doctor. I'm just someone who has a form of cystic fibrosis, so management of serious lung issues is a daily part of my life.
Please see some of my previous comments for additional info:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22651884 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22651884
- dsl 7y agoCOVID kills by drastically reducing the surface area that can be used for oxygen exchange in the lungs. The successful protocols are more in line with dealing with a drowning victim than long term maintenance of someone with reduced lung function.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe official explanation for cystic fibrosis touted by the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation is that people with CF are "drowning in their own mucus." Airway clearance is medically prescribed and it's not because we tend to have big holes in our lungs from repeated infections. It's because we tend to have too much gunk in our lungs. Reduced lung function per se for people with CF is typically due to the lungs being eaten away by infection. The end game for medical treatment of that issue is typically lung transplant. People with CF account for about a third of all adult and half of all pediatric lung transplants in the US, or did the last time I looked up such stats.
- abbirdboy 7y agoI would hesitate to write that "too mucus" is not an issue, because too mucus can cause a lot of problems for your lungs. For example, individuals with chronic bronchitis have hypertrophy of the mucus glands relative to the bronchial wall (look up Reid's index). This leads to mucus plugging within smaller alveoli and subsequent cyanosis and hypoxemia. Moreover, the obstruction due to the stasis of mucus can lead to the formation of purulent material/inflammatory necrosis (bronchiectasis) as well as damage to the mucociliary escalator. In fact, this mucus trapping is an underlying cause of the respiratory symptoms you see in cystic fibrosis and several other respiratory diseases. *I would add that in CF, the formation of the mucus is fundamentally impaired, causing it to be less effectively cleared.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI've stated as clearly as I can that this is my personal opinion and what that personal opinion is based on. I am aware of the official explanation for CF and have noted what it is in another comment of mine in this same discussion. I am not actually looking to get into some long tangent concerning my opinion about how CF really works. It's irrelevant to this discussion. If you don't care for my personal opinions about how this works, please just focus on the takeaway that "non mechanical air clearance methods exist and are medically prescribed" and please seek out official medical sources of information on airway clearance, which Italian doctors are apparently using in cases not serious enough for a ventilator.
- systemvoltage 7y agoIf you’re not a doctor, you should really stop providing medical advice to others. You’ve been aggressively pushing this whole home remedy thing. Stop saying things with authority, you can suggest things with “This is my personal advice but talk to your doctor”. I’m flagging your comments.