3 ms·
Imagine this happening under normal circumstances. Now that they did it, the threshold will be lower to do it again next time, when they see it fit. The future
by zelphirkalt 7y ago
Imagine this happening under normal circumstances. Now that they did it, the threshold will be lower to do it again next time, when they see it fit.
The future will show, whether it will be appropriate, when they do it next time.
- BitwiseFool 7y agoPeople might accuse you of using a Slippery Slope fallacy, but in reality they're just establishing a precedent. And the justification will get weaker each time.
- zelphirkalt 7y agoYou are right, not water tight argumenting on my part. I wonder, whether slippery slope is OK, if the action in reality can be seen as a slippery slope that society is probably sliding down.
- usr01398132 7y agoUsing cell phone location data to track users isn't at all new in North America & Europe. Adtech companies have been doing since the 2000s. Having worked at a digital signage company I can tell you that all digital out of home advertising companies use cell phone tower location data to calculate impressions (views) for their billboards. Note this isn't limited to digital outdoor ads, static (posters) ads also use the same location data to determine the amount of impressions they get. This metric is usually required so that the Advertising companies can bill their customers. It amazes me that so many HN commenters think this type of tracking is new. What you people should be concerned about are the adtech companies that have been doing this with little oversight for at least a decade.
- zelphirkalt 7y agoHehe, well, perhaps it's not really new, but the justification and doing it in broad daylight might be new. The attempt to get rid of the shadiness factor of such practice. Also perhaps not by the government or Canadian government. I'd guess that most of HN knows, that this has been done before. Outrage or indignation does not require thinking, that something is a new practice.
- Traster 7y agoYeah the obvious comparison to point to is that the US patriot act massively expanded the powers of the US intelligence agencies in response to 9/11, and now, despite the threat being nothing like what it used to be the intelligence services have just steadily pushed that power further and further.