3 ms·
Unfortunately this article doesn't get at any actual "why". The author blames just-in-time supply chains, but for me the crucial part is: > In 2006, Congress a
by crazygringo 7y ago
Unfortunately this article doesn't get at any actual "why". The author blames just-in-time supply chains, but for me the crucial part is:
> In 2006, Congress approved funds to add protective gear to a national strategic stockpile — among other things, the stockpile collected 52 million surgical face masks and 104 million N95 respirator masks. But about 100 million masks in the stockpile were deployed in 2009 in the fight against the H1N1 flu pandemic, and the government never bothered to replace them. This month, Alex Azar, secretary of health and human services, testified that there are only about 40 million masks in the stockpile — around 1 percent of the projected national need.
Stockpiles are clearly the answer, since supply chains are always going to fail in certain scenarios.
So the real questions here are, why didn't Congress create a bigger stockpile and why didn't it ensure it was maintained?
I genuinely want an in-depth answer to this question.
Is this some kind of problem with democratic government? Or are other democracies managinging responsible stockpiles just fine? Is it something unique to American politics? Do Americans somehow hold their representatives less accountable? Is it more the fault of one party over another? Is it leaving responsibilities to Congress that ought to be delegated to an agency? Is there are ideological or cultural component here, or just plain lack of accountability and people not doing their jobs?
Seriously. It's important we have a real in-depth analysis on this. Not knee-jerk opiniated answers, but what actually happened.
- kingaillas 7y ago>why didn't Congress create a bigger stockpile and why didn't it ensure it was maintained? You'd have to interview the responsible people at the time, which I doubt is going to happen right now. But the obvious answer is "nobody thought it was worth the money to do that." >Is it leaving responsibilities to Congress that ought to be delegated to an agency? It is definitely not only this. Even if responsibility were delegated, Congress (House of Representatives) has to allocate the money and is also where tax legislation originates. So a responsible agency can still be starved of funds to actually operate. Heck that is true even for executive-funded agencies like the CFPB, which the administration has tried to kill through zero funding, multiple times. >Is there are ideological I think this is vast majority of the problem. One party, without naming it, is basically only about two things: 1) tax cuts as a policy solution for all problems, and 2) thoughts and prayers when anything bad happens (mass shootings, etc.) and minimal willingness to enact any changes to stop it from happening again. That same political party is jammed to the gills with an anti-science, anti-expert, anti-vaccine, anti-government, etc attitude and will likely continue failing to take steps to address incoming issues, until they are on our doorstep already manifesting problems -and at that time the cost of dealing with it will be far higher in lives and money than it could have been. Just look at the chief executive, who wants the country "reopened by easter" despite all advice from medical experts. The ideology here is: lets sacrifice millions of people on the altar of the free market.
- sempron64 7y agoThe Congress that approved the stockpile in 2006 was Republican. The Congress which failed to renew the stockpile was Democratic. The failure to renew the stockpile is likely a result of the 2008 global recession and funds being prioritized differently, and subsequent partisan governmental meltdown rather than political ideology.
- masonic 7y agoThe Congress which failed to renew the stockpile was Democrat. And even if the 2009 H1N1 mask consumption had not occurred, the pre-Pelosi mask stockpile would all be expired now anyway.
- mistermann 7y ago> I genuinely want an in-depth answer to this question. Me too. Even some in-depth, evidence-based discussion would be an improvement over the current state of affairs. > In 2006, Congress approved funds to add protective gear to a national strategic stockpile — among other things, the stockpile collected 52 million surgical face masks and 104 million N95 respirator masks. But about 100 million masks in the stockpile were deployed in 2009 in the fight against the H1N1 flu pandemic, and the government never bothered to replace them. Ok, let's think about this: According to Google, Donald Trump was elected on January 20, 2017. According to Google, Barack Obama was elected on January 20, 2009, which would imply he was the sitting President in 2009 (matching your reference above). To me, this strongly implies that Barack Obama would have more influence over this specific policy than Donald Trump. And yet, in all the reading I've done on this specific attribute of the crisis (and I've done a lot), there seems to be nearly unanimous consensus that it was Donald Trump's "firing" of the head of the pandemic response team that was(!) the(!) root cause of a lack of masks in stockpile. Full stop. Now, there's no doubt at all in my mind that Trump has utterly botched this response, I would even confidently speculate that he may be the worst President in the history of the United States that could have been in charge during this crisis. But this isn't only what is being claimed - rather, something very specific is also being claimed, and assuming I haven't made any mistakes in my dates above, I simply am unable to see how that makes sense. Your quotation seems to completely contradict this claim. What in tarnation is going on here? This situation feels surreal to me. Like, how is a person supposed to sort out fact from fiction in this information environment? I feel like I am unable to discern what is actually true.
- DuskStar 7y ago> What in tarnation is going on here? This situation feels surreal to me. Like, how is a person supposed to sort out fact from fiction in this information environment? I feel like I am unable to discern what is actually true. When Donald Trump complains about "fake news", this is what he's talking about. He's genuinely incompetent, but that doesn't stop the press from twisting things to make him look worse.
- mistermann 7y ago