5 ms·
Only tangentially related but I have to get it out of my system anyway: I watched the latest season of the F1 documentary on Netflix, and what stood out beyond
by kqr 7y ago
Only tangentially related but I have to get it out of my system anyway:
I watched the latest season of the F1 documentary on Netflix, and what stood out beyond anything else to me was that every team pitted their own drivers against each other, had a "you win or you lose" mentality, screamed at people for messing up, and so on.
All teams except one. One team iterated how they "win as a team and make mistakes as a team", mistakes are an opportunity to learn, and so on. One team showed pretty clearly how they had a good culture surrounding failures.
I'm not at all surprised that this one team is the team that has consistently won the last 6 years in a row.
Why aren't more teams copying this? Why is this one team not more secretive about their recipe to success?
- op03 7y agoBoth strategies are known to work - Carrot and Stick. Why? Because the psychological Traits and Needs of all humans are not the same. Most people who build teams have a sense of their own Needs and Traits and pick strategies/team members that align/compensate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revised_NEO_Personality_Inventory#Personality_dimensions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revised_NEO_Personality_Invent... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs There is a distribution of Traits/Needs that you need to be aware of within any population, group, team etc. If you are not aware of those variations and randomly create groups and try to impose strategy, what works and fails will always remain mysterious.
- MikeAmelung 7y agoAs the other reply kind of hints at, it's a lot easier to do this if you have the absolutely dominant driver on your team. If I was the technical director and we were losing, I'd certainly be like "Lewis, pal, we lose as a team, right?" And then Lewis would be gone and we would just be losers.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoThere’s so many reasons for Mercedes success, that the parent comment comes of as being a bit silly. As you mentioned, they have Lewis Hamilton, who a lot of people would argue is the greatest driver of all time. They also have a very clear pecking order, team orders for Bottas to lose to Hamilton are a meme in F1 (“Valtteri, it’s James”). After the season was underway, they really only let them race after Hamilton had secured the drivers championship. Toto’s leadership is certainly very good (which the parent poster is referencing one particular part of), but you also have to remember, that Mercedes have only been dominant for one particular generation of F1 cars (the turbo-hybrid era). The sample size is absurdly small, and if you ask most commentators who’s going to dominate next, most of the would guess Verstappen (or LeClerc), not another Mercedes driver.
- kqr 7y ago> team orders for Bottas to lose to Hamilton are a meme in F1 (“Valtteri, it’s James”). After the season was underway, they really only let them race after Hamilton had secured the drivers championship. Is this not an extension of "we win as a team, we lose as a team"? Would this be possible with the same consistency in teams where both drivers are in clear competition with each other for the seat next season?
- AmericanChopper 7y agoWell I think this is a bad example in general, because unlike most businesses, success is actually a zero sum game in top flight sports. If somebody does good enough to earn a seat, it will always mean that somebody else did bad enough to lose theirs. It’s also not a very faithful characterization of Mercedes. They were seriously considering letting Bottas go last year, it was honestly a surprise that they kept him (and let Ocon go instead). If you want to see what the same management style looks like with competitive drivers, you can just look at the last time Mercedes had two competitive drivers. That would be in 2016, when Nico Rosberg won the drivers championship with Mercedes. The relationship between Hamilton and Rosberg had become so toxic, that Toto Wolf himself admitted he had no idea how he was going to solve it. It culminated with Hamilton trying his best to hold up Rosberg in traffic in the last race of 2016, because Hamilton needed to keep Rosberg of the Podium if he was going to get the title. You can watch the highlights on YouTube with the team telling him to speed up, while he more or less just refused. The only reason any of that was resolved, was because Rosberg retired after that season. This story is pretty much repeated in F1 history any time you have two people on the same team competing for the title. Last year LeClerc and Vettel fought so much, and so dangerously on track, that it actually led to both Ferrari drivers crashing into each other and retiring in one race (something which mirrors one of the most controversial crashes in F1 history, when one McLaren teammate crashed into the other at Suzuka in 1989). The entire season was also full of their drivers arguing on the radio about team orders. Then you have the other most dominant driver, Verstappen, who Redbull have been unable to find a suitable teammate for. To specifically answer your questions, at Mercedes “win as a team” clearly always means “help Hamilton win”. It’s not possible to operate a team where drivers are not fighting for their seat, and history has shown it’s not possible to have a good team culture when both drivers are actually competing with each other for the title.
- di4na 7y agoToyota did the same thkng with NUMMI. More than 4 decades later, none of the other manufacturers come close to Toyota still. Why? Because the change is one in how you understand the world. This is really hard to do, particularly as an organisation. It needs to reinvent yourself from scratch. It means killing your org to live again. The org will fight it. People that were favored will lose power and standing. They will fight it. Things will get worse before getting better. They will fight it. It will need different way to count success. That will be used against it. It will need new way to trust. They will say it is laxist. Said otherwise: the current structure work good enough. There is not enough reward and competitive pressure to make the huge opportunity cost of change an accepted strategy. You can apply that model of change infinitely. Ask yourself why we have not seen huge swath of the web move into Elixir as an example.
- JackMcMack 7y agoIt means killing your org to live again. This resonates with me. I've experienced a few "agile transformations". They almost never stuck. The thing that mostly worked was creating teams with a majority of experienced agile devs, people willing to self improve and execute. And when the job is over, it all starts falling apart. Some team members might be believers now, they become disillusioned and leave. Some might have been good followers, but quickly conform to the old ways. You only have a temporary influence on a single team or project. You can't change a company's culture like that, without it hitting rock bottom first. This is very similar to overcoming addiction. I've long wondered why NUMMI worked where others failed, something I believe is largely ignored in most literature: the factory closed. All the workers were out of a job for several weeks. And in comes Toyota with jobs for many workers, with the hopes of giving every single worker their job back.
- williamdclt 7y agoI saw an interesting talk by Alistair Cockburn (one of the Agile Manifesto guys), where he said he never once saw a succesful "agile transformation". Just too much resistance to change to have any chance to succeed. What did succeed, is to create what he called a "new building", meaning a new subcompany (sometimes literally in a new building) with a different (agile) culture, and only letting in people that are interested in making it work. Slowly let the old company die, the new one grow. It takes years and years.
- wlesieutre 7y ago> I'm not at all surprised that this one team is the team that has consistently won the last 6 years in a row. They also have a budget of close to $500 million, which can't hurt. Ferrari and Red Bull are the only teams that come close to that. Fourth largest budget is Renault at almost $200 million less. We'll see if they continue to stack up with the $175 million budget cap that's coming in 2021.
- skrebbel 7y agoFor non-F1-followers like me: I spent 5 minutes on Wikipedia so you don't have to, and "they" is Mercedes, who re-entered Formula 1 in 2010 after a 55 year hiatus, and won every year since 2014. Pretty spectacular!
- aahortwwy 7y ago> Why is this one team not more secretive about their recipe to success? It's not a secret. Many other organizations (not in F1, by your description) operate this way. It's well understood, but... > Why aren't more teams copying this? ... everyone on the team needs to buy in to this approach. One selfish team member can slowly ruin the whole thing. The uncomfortable reality of these cultures is that when someone in the culture is not truly committed, or is putting their self-interest ahead of the team, they need to be removed. A lot of leaders are not strong enough to recognize that and take action.
- draw_down 7y agoStuff like this makes me wonder. How strong was the culture really, if it didn’t know how to handle having one errant member among its ranks? That is going to happen eventually, on a long enough timeline.
- bob33212 7y agoIt is similar to why organizations don't hire 10x engineers only. It is difficult, a lot of work and hiring just one bad manager could cause the 10x engineers to leave or become unproductive. It is far easier to treat engineers like cogs and hire people that check the right boxes and throw them into a standard scrum process.
- wmeredith 7y agoThe team in question is Mercedes for those who are curious.
- HappyRobot 7y agoI believe other teams do copy this, but not in driver pairings. A different F1 example are the pit crews. There's no time or space for blame if a pit stop is messed up. In the first season, Haas has pit stop issues twice in the same race. It wasn't the mechanics that were blamed, but the team principal took it upon himself to diffuse the scenario as the team's failing. This is likely similar across all the team as any doubt or the hesitation for the mechanics would only risk additional mistakes. Drivers will always be pitted against their teammate though. F1 is technically a team sport, but the real judgement for the drivers is how well they compare against their teammate. Each driver wants to win, that's why they compete.
- jiveturkey 7y agoyou are mistaking a drama-mentary as reality