5 ms·
This terrifies me more than just about anything they're doing. I think a lot of people just don't see the danger in the total lack of financial/transaction pri
by sneak 7y ago
This terrifies me more than just about anything they're doing. I think a lot of people just don't see the danger in the total lack of financial/transaction privacy that most cashless Americans live under. This threatens to extend that even further.
If this goes through, then your options for receiving money from the government you might well need to not starve are just two: accept a payment to your 100% surveillance bank account, or accept a 100% surveillance "digital cash" payment if you're unbanked.
In all cases the state will receive detailed permanent records of when, where, and how you spent the money.
- mycall 7y agoWhy can't you have separate accounts, one for Fed dollars, one for checking? One is receive-only public, the other is private.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SllX 7y agoWhy can’t we just keep cash and when we issue cash, we issue cash whether that’s an envelope of bills, or a direct deposit?
- warent 7y agoAgree with this. Humans/civilians are not government employees or public entities just by being alive. I'm probably not as big of an advocate for privacy as many of my peers, but trying to keep a public spending ledger of individual people is crossing a line.
- mycall 7y agoThere isn't enough cash to do that.
- wideasleep1 7y agoThat's what I'll do...simply cash out the Fed account, and pay cash as I go.
- sneak 7y agoOnce fed "digital cash" dollars exist and can be used by everyone, including the unbanked, they have a plausible reason for discontinuing the use of "inconvenient" paper cash. After all, it's only used for money laundering, drugs, criminals, gambling, and prostitution. Who wants that stuff?! Once that happens, there is no option whatsoever for trading with everyday people that does not involve complete surveillance, recorded and saved for all time. Your movement at all times will then be reported in realtime to the federal police, provided you eat or buy fuel or water at any point during your travels (just as it is today if you use a payment card or contactless payment). From 2010: https://www.wired.com/2010/12/realtime/ https://www.wired.com/2010/12/realtime/
- pdkl95 7y ago> they have a plausible reason for discontinuing the use of "inconvenient" paper cash. After all, it's only used for money laundering, drugs, criminals, gambling, and prostitution. This excuse is already being used against the £50 note: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/consumer-affairs/bothering-reinvent-50-note-no-one-uses-except-criminals/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/consumer-affairs/bothering... https://www.bbc.com/news/business-48993008 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-48993008
- wideasleep1 7y agoI won't disagree with any of that..but, for example, if I pay rent in cash, I will cash out the Fed account to pay rent. The Fed account is simply a mechanism for me to cash out. But yeah, someday the bills themsleves will have RFID-like strands, and monetary privacy lost.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI have always been a huge fan of the idea of the Fed providing deposit accounts directly to citizens, at no cost. Banking should be a utility, not a for profit business (you can carve off lending and investments to for profit entities that do this, separate form traditional banks), and you suddenly make the unbanked the banked (and nuke alternative finance providers that charge for services that should be free, check cashing and the like; "its expensive to be poor"). Your credit card data is already sold [1]. Your banking data is already sold [2]. Read the privacy notices you receive from your banks and credit cards to see when and to whom (these notices are required by law). Any transaction over $10k generates a CTR [3]. Any transactions that appear to be structuring are going to generate a SAR [4]. The solution, as always, is regulation, governance, and oversight, not outright turning down the idea. At the same time, the ability to turn your fiat into physical currency must always be preserved for privacy reasons; require the Fed issue debit cards and all ATMs accept them for dispensing hard currency. [1] https://www.aclu.org/blog/privacy-technology/consumer-privacy/why-dont-we-have-more-privacy-when-we-use-credit-card https://www.aclu.org/blog/privacy-technology/consumer-privac... [2] https://www.courthousenews.com/banks-profit-from-selling-your-spending-data/ https://www.courthousenews.com/banks-profit-from-selling-you... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_transaction_report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_transaction_report [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspicious_activity_report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspicious_activity_report
- chrisco255 7y agoThe Fed was never designed to be a retail bank. And so you know, the Fed is a for-profit business.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 7y agoChange is inevitable. How many governments were designed to support providing healthcare to their citizens but do so today? (Over 30)
- 7y ago
- systemvoltage 7y agoSurveillance accounts are already the case. And, we already conduct "Digital Cash" payments every day - Credit cards, ACH and Wire transfers and many other means where physical paper bundles of cash aren't literally shipped when you send money to another country. I guess, can you exemplify what exactly the government would be able to do with this bill vs. what it can already do? If they send you a check, that's not helping you much. It goes through the bank and there is 100% traceability of the $$$ from the Fed to your bank account which is already very much "Digital".
- sneak 7y ago> Surveillance accounts are already the case. Not quite. I can spend cash and nobody knows when or where I did so. > If they send you a check, that's not helping you much. It goes through the bank and there is 100% traceability of the $$$ from the Fed to your bank account Many, many Americans receive checks as payment which they then take to a service which will exchange the check for cash in hand, no bank account required. The check issuer has no idea where or how the money gets spent.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago> Many, many Americans receive checks as payment which they then take to a service which will exchange the check for cash in hand, no bank account required. The check issuer has no idea where or how the money gets spent. And they pay dearly for the privilege. I imagine the number of Americans who use check cashing for privacy is extremely small compared to the number who use it because they're in poverty and unbanked.
- chrisco255 7y agoYou're talking about payday loans versus cashing paychecks. It's usually a token fee to cash a check at a grocery store or free if you go to the bank that issued the check. Some people live by cash. Some businesses still operate on cash only basis.
- 7y ago
- rattlesnakedave 7y agoNot just surveillance, it would be much easier for the government to restrict where you can spend your money, place a time limit / expiration on when the money can be spent, and inject cash into the economy much more quickly (no overhead) than they can now. All of these are nightmarish.
- dzhiurgis 7y ago> free money > nightmarish Okay...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rattlesnakedave 7y ago“Free”
- basch 7y agoYour premise is that a person needing money not to starve is worried if the government knows their money is going to food? Or rent? Or a student loan? Or a hospital bill? I'll take at face value that this person does exist. They should take the digital payment and use it for a single or two lump sum payments they don't care about being tracked, like rent. Is this really a Binary situation, where as soon as one or two not so private payments are trackable, now you can't use cash for the rest anymore? Maybe just don't use government stimulus for private things? I'll buy this, if you're making a slippery slope argument about cash being completely obsoleted.