3 ms·
~15 years ago my "daily driver" had 256MB of RAM and it was perfectly usable for development (native, none of this new bloated web stuff) as well as lots of mul
by userbinator 7y ago
~15 years ago my "daily driver" had 256MB of RAM and it was perfectly usable for development (native, none of this new bloated web stuff) as well as lots of multitasking. There was rarely a time when I ran out of RAM or had the CPU at full usage for extended periods.
Now it seems even the most trivial of apps needs more than that just to start running, and on a workstation, less than a year old with 4 cores of i7 and 32GB of RAM, I still experience lots of lag and swapping (fast SSD helps, althougn not much) doing simple things like reading an email.
- smabie 7y agoAre you sure? I've been running Linux for a long time with no page file. From 4gb to 32gb (The amount of RAM I have now) and have literally only ran out of RAM once (and that was because of a bug in a ML program I was developing). I find it very hard to believe that you experience any swapping at all with 32gb, much less "lots".
- kjs3 7y agoYou said yourself you managed to find a case where you ran out of memory. Why do you find it "very hard to believe", knowing nothing about his use cases, that his job doesn't involve exactly the sort of situations that consume vast amounts of RAM. Why do people insist with such conviction that "it doesn't happen to me, therefore it's inconceivable that it happens to someone else, doing something totally different than what I'm doing, into which I have no insight". Baffling.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> Why do you find it "very hard to believe", knowing nothing about his use cases, that his job doesn't involve exactly the sort of situations that consume vast amounts of RAM. Probably the GGP said they experience lag while "doing simple things like reading an email." Now, maybe GGP meant to add "while I'm sequencing genes in the background", but since that was left out I can see how it would be confusing! :)
- kjs3 7y agoThat's fair. Good point.
- userbinator 7y agoYou've likely not experienced the amazing monstrosity that is Microsoft Teams: https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/msoffice/forum/all/teams-hogging-memory-running-slowly/3a5ddd1a-e4b0-41be-881d-c0d46b9abe23 https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/msoffice/forum/all/teams... There's a screenshot in there showing it taking 22GB of RAM. I've personally never seen it go that high, but the 10-12GB of RAM that I have seen is absolutely ludicrous for a chat app. Even when it's initially started it takes over 600MB. Combine that with a few VMs that also need a few GB of RAM each, as well as another equally-bloated Electron app or two, and you can quickly get into the swapping zone.
- smabie 7y agoHow is that possible, 22GB? Fucking electron. You would think, at least, that Microsoft would code a fucking real desktop app.. I hate web browsers.
- syockit 7y agoI also experience the same thing with Mattermost (the client also being an Electron app). The memory bloat usually comes from switching back and forth from so many channels, scrolling up to load more chat history, and lots and lots of image attachments (and of course, the emoticons).
- userbinator 7y agoscrolling up to load more chat history, and lots and lots of image attachments (and of course, the emoticons). I remember comfortably browsing webpages with lots of large images and animated GIFs in the early 2000s, with a fraction of the computing power I have today. Something has become seriously inefficient with browser-based apps.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI'm on a Mac with 32 GB of Ram. According to Activity Monitor, right now: • 4.26 GB are being used by apps • 19.52 GB are cached files • 8.22 GB are just sitting idle (!) Now, I'm not running anything particularly intensive at the moment, and I make a point of avoiding Electron apps. I also rebooted just a few hours ago for an unrelated reason. But the fact is that I've monitored this before—I very rarely manage to use all my RAM. The OS mostly just uses it to cache files, which I suppose is as good a use as any.
- userbinator 7y agoand I make a point of avoiding Electron apps I do that personally too, but in a work environment that is unfortunately not always possible --- and also responsible for much of the RAM usage too.
- umvi 7y ago> ~15 years ago my "daily driver" had 256MB of RAM and it was perfectly usable for development What I failed to mention was that the rootfs is also eating into that (ramdisk). In your case I'm guessing your rootfs was on disk.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoOh my god, just try running a modern OS on a spinning rust drive. It's ridiculous how slow it is. It's obvious that modern developers assume everything is running on SSD.