7 ms·
> Some industry insiders have suggested that Dyson's approach to create a new model will take too long. You don't say. You can't just turn a vacuum cleaner int
by arcticbull 7y ago
> Some industry insiders have suggested that Dyson's approach to create a new model will take too long.
You don't say. You can't just turn a vacuum cleaner into a ventilator by setting it to Blow instead of Suck. Medical devices take a very long time to develop, certify, build, release and develop training for because they're medical devices. The rule of thumb for consumer-grade hardware is it takes a minimum of one year from ideation to first delivery.
You want new ones fast, you get the manufacturers who make existing ones make more of them. The problem isn't that we're out of ventilator designs, it's that we're out of physical ventilators.
This feels like Elon's child-rescue submarine, and at least as far as COVID-19 it's likely to save exactly the same number of people.
- cbhl 7y agoI was under the impression that the NHS had been sourcing ventilators from a French manufacturer, but France decided to nationalize that manufacturer and stop exports. Although I do wonder how much of a home-built solution will be "designed" versus, say "jury-rigged".
- freepor 7y agoWhen you need more than the existing manufacturers can produce, and the alternative (Italy) is to let them die in a hallway, then you might be willing to try anything. If it was my life I’d prefer the Dyson over nothing.
- 7thaccount 7y agoYes. This. Incredibly desperate times here.
- arcticbull 7y agoIf it's that desperate force companies to make them. Don't pin your hopes and dreams on a fantasy that you can build a large-scale medical device in two weeks.
- 7thaccount 7y agoHow can you expect that if they're at max capacity? I guess the government could throw major bucks at it.
- arcticbull 7y agoThe problem isn't that there is a lack of ventilator designs it's that there's a lack of physical ventilators which means it's a manufacturing/supply chain/logistics problem not an R&D problem. That won't be solved with yet another design.
- freepor 7y agoRamping up a vacuum cleaner factory to produce ventilators will take much longer than trying to find a design that can turn a vacuum cleaner into a ventilator. What is solved with a novel design is the repurposing of a product that a factory already has the ability to produce.
- roywiggins 7y agoWell, you might have nothing anyway, if it takes twice as long for Dyson to produce anything by starting from scratch rather than using an existing design. I guess nobody should stop him trying to make some of these at a crash pace, because there's a nonzero chance they might work out, but it does seem unlikely.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- djsjejjdi324 7y agoThat would be Spain, not Italy.
- arcticbull 7y agoSo take the design from one existing company and ramp the manufacture. The alternative isn't sit down with a blank sheet of paper and some pencils and see what you can knock out in a couple of weeks and shove into people without going through the appropriate testing and certification procedures. The problem isn't a lack of ventilator designs.
- nitrogen 7y agoIs that not what all of the non-ventilator companies are doing? I mean that seems like the obvious choice.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- freepor 7y agoHow can Dyson ramp up ventilator production? Their factories are not set up to manufacture ventilators with completely different materials or tooling. Dyson not only has production capacity for hundreds of thousands of vacuum cleaners, but probably has tens of thousands already in stock in warehouses and at retailers. If they can find a way to use them to help patients, those patients can get that help TOMORROW. They absolutely cannot do that with ventilators.
- arcticbull 7y agoMy lord, you can't use a vacuum cleaner to help patients that need ventilators except by removing dirt from their floors.
- freepor 7y agoWell then Dyson can't help, that's fine. But it doesn't harm anyone but them to try, so they seem to be doing the right thing in trying.
- travisporter 7y ago> Dyson said it had been working with The Technology Partnership, a medical company based in Cambridge, to develop a "meaningful and timely response". Maybe a new design can be built faster if it’s from the ground up. This can happen concurrently with ramping up existing manufacturing of vents.
- flatiron 7y agoReinvent the ventilator and have one sitting in a hospital in 14 days with no teething issues on production, training, deployment, maintenance?
- Cerium 7y agoExactly. Anyone who has worked in medical devices knows this is impossible. Saying that you will prepare one as part of a timely response is such nonsense that I don't know what part to start looking at.
- ineedasername 7y agoIt only would make sense if we're still facing these issues in, say, 8 months. Which is still wildly optimistic for proper design etc of such a device, and even if possible that same time frame should absolutely allow existing manufacturers to scale production.
- wbl 7y agoThe original ventilator was very janky. It did work!
- arcticbull 7y agoFor polio. That's a very different problem.
- wbl 7y agoThe positive pressure ones anesticists developed were also really janky. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(56)90597-9/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
- dheera 7y agoThe child rescue submarine was not used for the rescue, but it wasn't a bad thing that it could have served as a backup plan. Elon Musk's comments were unforgivable, though.
- roywiggins 7y agoThe descriptions I've read of the cave suggest that it wouldn't have worked as a backup anyway- a human can wriggle or be pulled through, but a pod large enough to hold a human would be too big and inflexible. It would have snagged on something, and then what?
- arcticbull 7y ago> ...and then what? Send in more and more subs. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5JiPj9c98Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5JiPj9c98Y
- erikpukinskis 7y agoWhat comments?
- arcticbull 7y agoLook up “pedo guy” the story is too long and crazy to get into here haha
- tcbawo 7y agoThere is a growing consensus that constant positive pressure is what many patients need: https://emcrit.org/ibcc/covid19/ https://emcrit.org/ibcc/covid19/ Developing a closed mask that doesn't contaminate everyone around them might do much good.
- ipsum2 7y agoSo essentially a CPAP machine.
- robertfw 7y agoCPAPs i believe have been ruled out as they vent exhalations indiscriminately, spreading the virus throughout the space.
- ironmagma 7y agoShouldn’t that be fine for at-home recovery though?
- fsckboy 7y agothat doesn't sound like a terribly hard problem to solve.
- sjwright 7y agoOr at least useful in limited situations, e.g. at-home care where the carer has already been infected. Situations like that might not be common now, but give it a few months.
- tcbawo 7y agoNot in the health field, but the rapid innovation on the front lines is breathtaking. There are groups of doctors, nurses, and pharmacists communicating on Twitter solving these problems in real time. It's really inspiring!
- 7y ago
- glenneroo 7y ago> This feels like Elon's child-rescue submarine, and at least as far as COVID-19 it's likely to save exactly the same number of people. Speaking of Elon Musk, his initial plans from a few days ago to also produce some in-house has morphed into the saner goal of acquiring 1000+ units from China, which apparently have already arrived in LA: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-24/california-governor-says-elon-musk-delivered-1-000-ventilators https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-24/californi...
- brenden2 7y agoElon probably just went on Alibaba and bought some with his credit card.
- solveit 7y agoIt was probably a little more involved than that, but not by much. The real story is that asinine regulations and bureaucracy aren't letting hospital administrators do the same!
- ineedasername 7y agoAlthough buying existing ones is zero-sum: assuming the worldwide demand exceeds supply and, as such, those ventilators would have been sold anyway, his buying of those ventilators just swapped the shortage problem to a different group of patients.
- djtriptych 7y agoThis doesn't even pass the sniff test. If Dyson can produce an 80% effective version they obviously should.
- arcticbull 7y agoNo, they shouldn't because an 80% effective ventilator might kill someone when a company that knows how to make ventilators could just produce a 100% effective one.
- 55555 7y agoThis is the problem with treating everyone like a child. If I am dying of corona, and there are no more ventilators, I would like to be offered one that Dyson made out of cardboard, sticky tape, string, and wood glue so I can decide for myself if I want it. The potential risks of a medical device need to be weighed against the risks of not having it. Safety testing is less important when treating dying patients who have no other options.
- arcticbull 7y agoThat may be the least coherent plan I've ever heard. If I offered you a leaf blower taped to a sack, that would absolutely make the situation worse. If you need a ventilator you're not in a position to make decisions because you need a ventilator. Come on, this is a fantasy and I think you know that. If you're lying there, gasping for air, that's not the time for the nurse to wander by and ask if you liked the Dyson BlowMaster 8000 or the Siemens 300A Servo Ventilator, and to explain to you the pros and cons. What you need is a proper, certified ventilator you can get by ramping production of existing ventilators, not starting over with some bits of sticky tape and string. You can force companies, in an emergency to produce them [1]. That's the only sane plan in an actual emergency. Let's briefly break down the "treat like a child" bit. A child is someone who's not capable of making decisions. Neither is someone who needs a ventilator. > Safety testing is less important when treating dying patients who have no other options. Safety testing is more important because sometimes applying a useless device will do more harm than doing literally nothing. Something is not always better than nothing. How else can we, to your point, weigh the risks of having it vs not having it if we don't evaluate them? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_Production_Act_of_1950 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_Production_Act_of_1950
- robomartin 7y agoI have to say, one of the things that is driving me mad these days is the level of ignorance evidenced by both popular and media conversations about all of this stuff. I mean, are we watching too many science fiction movies? Have we lost any connection to what it actually takes to make things? With over thirty years in technology and manufacturing I would not touch the rapid development of a ventilator with a ten foot pole. As you correctly state, designing such devices takes years. And, beyond that, it takes decades of accumulated experience to inform the decisions and choices made during the design of any modern device. And then there's the years of testing, qualification and supply chain engineering. No, the only way to make ventilators is to make more of an already proven design under the supervision of the companies already making them. In other words, expand their production capacity by retooling already capable manufacturing environments. Watching the White House press briefings I can't help but feel that reporters must think Trump is Captain Picard who, armed with advanced replicators, can replicate mass quantities of anything within days. Oh, yes, and he must be Superman too. In real life things take time. And if your industrial base has been almost completely off-shored, it takes even longer. If it's even possible at all.
- MikeAmelung 7y agoI'm right there with you, probably has to do with many of them having never seen a manufacturing facility. But they do know how to write "Those jobs are never coming back!"
- robomartin 7y agoI had someone call me to ask if we could use our 3D print farm, industrial (not hobby) CNC equipment and surface mount line to make "a low cost ventilator they designed over the weekend". I pretty much read the guy the riot act and told him to stop fucking around with shit he isn't even remotely equipped to understand and go find some other way to help. Yeah, I've lost a lot of tolerance for this kind of stuff during the last few weeks. We are being treated to an amazing display of the Dunning-Kruger effect on a daily basis. I mean, I just heard the media is on a war path blaming Trump for some guy in Arizona who "died after taking Chloroquine, the drug the President is pushing". Turns out nobody did their research and this guy decided to take a chemical used to clean fish tanks. Never mind that there was no doctor involved at all. Fish tank cleaner...and somehow our President is culpable? We are witnessing ignorance being elevated to a virtue.