2 ms·
> that was the question I had - clearly it's smaller than reals, but how and why is this field larger than rational numbers? As pdonis points out sidethread, t
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> that was the question I had - clearly it's smaller than reals, but how and why is this field larger than rational numbers?
As pdonis points out sidethread, this isn't really a valid question. (Or rather, the question is fine, but the answer to all questions of this form is already well-known, so there's no point in asking this specific question.)
It is not possible to prove that a set is both smaller than the reals and larger than the rationals, because such a set would disprove the continuum hypothesis. (And symmetrically, it isn't possible to prove that no such set exists, because that would be a proof of the continuum hypothesis.)
- perl4ever 7y ago"It is not possible to prove that a set is both smaller than the reals and larger than the rationals, because such a set would disprove the continuum hypothesis." Sure, even without much of a mathematical background, people generally take it for granted. Which is why it's disappointing that a suggestion of overturning it isn't fulfilled.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoSuggestion of overturning it? It's a proof. That article would be headlined "disproving the independence of the continuum hypothesis" or some such; it would be huge news, not somebody's fun blog post.
- perl4ever 7y agoSo, you know better than to be fooled by this clickbait. Noted. All I'm saying is that it was very effective on me, unlike a lot of things.
- lonelappde 7y agoAside, it's a shape that hypothesis in math (axiom) is the opposite of hypothesis in science (claim to test)
- thaumasiotes 7y agoNot really. The words are used in closely analogous ways. But the "hypothesis" in "continuum hypothesis" is part of the name of the continuum hypothesis, carried over from a time when we didn't know the answer. Names are just names. Euclid's Algorithm is an algorithm. The Division Algorithm is a theorem.