3 ms·
Darwin is open source. AMD Hackintosh users frequently compile custom Darwin kernels in order for macOS to run (although within the past year or so, this has fa
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
Darwin is open source. AMD Hackintosh users frequently compile custom Darwin kernels in order for macOS to run (although within the past year or so, this has fallen out of favor compared to binary patches).
Many kernel extensions are closed source, but that's not relevant here. What matters are Hackintosh kernel extensions like FakeSMC, which could absolutely be integrated into the kernel if necessary.
Edit: I just realized who I was talking too, you're more knowledgeable about iOS and macOS internals than I am! Are you referring to something different? I know absolutely that you can compile custom versions of Darwin, because as I mentioned it's done frequently for Hackintosh stuff.
- saagarjha 7y ago> Darwin is open source. This is why I specifically said that macOS is closed source. Darwin is kinda open source, but it becomes less and less relevant as Apple fails to update it and leaves parts out. > Many kernel extensions are closed source, but that's not relevant here. Of course it's relevant: if you don't have those extensions, your custom compiled kernel isn't booting on your genuine Mac hardware. You can try to rip the binary extensions from the OS, but no guarantees on how well that's going to work.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago...are we talking about different things? I don't understand why that matters. The question was: in a world where kexts don't exist, could Hackintosh still work? I'm saying, yes, as long as it's still possible to compile custom versions of the kernel, because you could just make whatever adjustments you wanted to the kernel directly. As of today, it is absolutely possible to compile your own version of Darwin and use it to boot up a Hackintosh, or a real Mac. Perhaps in this theoretical world where kexts don't exist, this would cease to be true, but that would be a separate change, no?
- saagarjha 7y ago> ...are we talking about different things? Yes, we are, I lost track of the argument. Sorry about that: you're right.
- adtac 7y ago>I specifically said that macOS is closed source But you said: >macOS's kernel, and especially its kernel extensions, are closed source
- saagarjha 7y agoYes, I forgot the "kernel" part there. But I don't think that changes my point?