3 ms·
I've had third party cookies blocked for years in Firefox. It doesn't break much.
by Animats 7y ago
I've had third party cookies blocked for years in Firefox. It doesn't break much.
- distances 7y agoExactly. I don't see why they should be allowed in the first place. I also block first-party cookies and while that does break more sites, it's still pretty manageable.
- chance_state 7y ago>I also block first-party cookies This is the front loaded approach which can cause breakage. I prefer the back loaded approach of using an extension like Cookie Auto Delete or similar that deletes cookies once you're away from a domain for a set amount of time (I think mine is set to 2 minutes).
- recursive 7y agoDo you use any sites which require any kind of authentication?
- distances 7y agoBy "manageable" I mean I'll allow them for the sites that need them. So yes, I do use sites with login.
- bradly 7y agoFirefox users can turn on privacy.firstparty.isolate which I believe will scope third party cookies to the top level domain you are on. It is off by default, but I've been using it for sometime without issue (except very persistent re-captcha).
- JeremyNT 7y agoThis is one approach, but you can avoid breakage by accepting cookies initially while enabling "clear cookies on exit." Combined with Firefox containers this works pretty well.
- distances 7y agoIndeed, this is what I use on Firefox Android as uMatrix would be way too cumbersome. Still have to remember to exit through the menu though, just killing the app won't do it.
- abrowne 7y agoIt breaks Duo 2fa's "remember me for a week"... Which makes it very annoying, at least at work.
- driverdan 7y agoBrowsers should deprecate third party cookies and remove support entirely.
- cglong 7y agoChromium has announced their intentions to do just this in two years! https://blog.chromium.org/2020/01/building-more-private-web-path-towards.html https://blog.chromium.org/2020/01/building-more-private-web-...
- idoubtit 7y agoI've been blocking third party cookies since my Opera days. I can't remember exactly when, but at least Opera 9 (2006). Recently, I use the same capability of Vivaldi (Chromium based). The problem is that this blocking induces some failures which are hard to diagnose. For instance, on the official site of my city I can't use some pages because they loop on requiring my authentication, since they use iframes with shared cookies. On other sites, submitting a form will fail with no error messages. I also remember a Python MOOC that failed with a blank page because of this blocking. Fortunately, all of these errors are uncommon.
- function_seven 7y agoThis is why I'm glad Safari is doing this. Up until now, you were just a weird nerd user, and they could ignore you. Now some huge double-digit share of traffic is going to encounter these issues, and force sites that depend on 3rd party cookies to re-architect themselves to support "normal" people on their iPhones.
- 72deluxe 7y agoI use a pihole at home to block various tracking and advert domains and it is astounding how many big shops or sites that will break when you block them, mainly at checkout. They fail silently. My wife finds that various sites just don't work so I have to disable it whilst she checks out. If these 3rd party cookies and domains are highlighted and force people's practices to change a bit, I will be happy. I just don't understand people that run a site that relies on so many third-party sources to actually function. Since the site owner is not in control of the third-party reliability or uptime, it is essentially handing control/resiliance of the original site to the third-party (and putting the fate of their shop in it too). Absolutely baffling.
- speleding 7y agoMy site offers appointment scheduling, my customers like to put our site inside an iframe on their site so their users don't get sent off to a domain they don't know. Our site needs cookies for sessions, no tracking is involved, I would say that's a perfectly legitimate use of third party cookies. I just tried the new Safari Preview and this indeed stopped our framed web app from working. I managed to get it somewhat working again by asking permission via the new Storage Access API. Yet another popup users need to click through, ugh. I also managed to get one Safari Preview in a state where it would consistently deny access, without prompting the user again. This is going to make for painful support tickets. I guess a more permanent solution would to ask my customers to put a piece of JavaScript on their page so we can set first party cookies but that seems a support nightmare as well. Any other suggestions to work around this would be most welcome.