3 ms·
The guys should dig up an old copy of "Chaos" and read it. Their simulations exhibit sensitive dependence on initial conditions. The predicted orbits will diver
by phkahler 7y ago
The guys should dig up an old copy of "Chaos" and read it. Their simulations exhibit sensitive dependence on initial conditions. The predicted orbits will diverge similarly in the forward-time direction if tiny perturbations are made to the initial conditions. They're also subject to rounding errors.
Nothing to see here about time reversal, its just chaos.
- plafl 7y agoYour comment sounds quite disrespectful. I would say that they are perfectly aware of what chaotic behavior is.
- phkahler 7y agoAs others have pointed out, I was basing that not on the paper, but the summary linked here. It sounds like some new fundamental physics insight about time reversibility, when in fact it's just the old chaos stuff. Given that impression, it deserved a little snark and should not even be here. But apparently that's actually a lot of what it's about, in which case the authors are well aware - but it's still not very interesting then. The Lorenz attractor is is simpler than a 3-body system and will exhibit similar divergence.
- tom-thistime 7y agoThe technical content of your comment looks correct, but "Chaos" is the first word in the abstract of the paper: https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article-abstract/493/3/3932/5736044?redirectedFrom=fulltext https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article-abstract/493/3/3932/5... The blurb that's linked to HN is not very lucid, but the scientists who wrote the paper make it very clear that they're just talking about deterministic chaos.
- sarah180 7y agoThis is all correct—but you should always look at the actual paper and not the summary article that some journalist wrote. The authors are pretty clear about what they've shown and how it fits into ideas about chaos.
- scottlocklin 7y agoI disagree: the paper wasn't linked -the dumb summary of it was. The paper itself is a trivial result of chaotic dynamics rather than "muh mind bending woo headline." Newsflash: a simple double pendulum also requires Planck length precision in initial conditions (or would if it weren't for, like, friction) for reversibility if you sit around and watch it for long enough and excite it properly.