3 ms·
> Modi has claimed that there are not yet signs of community spread Do they have any reason to believe that there's something special about the borders of Indi
by ryandrake 7y ago
> Modi has claimed that there are not yet signs of community spread
Do they have any reason to believe that there's something special about the borders of India that cause the virus not to spread inside it? If not, this is an irrelevant observation. It's like jumping off a cliff and saying "there are not yet signs of the ground."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- VWWHFSfQ 7y agothey've only tested 15,000 people.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoGiven the density in which people live and the lack of clean water and other resources for hundreds of millions of people, it’s probably exploding there.
- middleclick 7y agoThey are not doing enough testing, so of course they don't know and that's why the numbers are low.
- iamgopal 7y agoAnd they know it hence the reaction.
- yewenjie 7y agoAFAIK, there has been randomized testing of hospitalized respiratory patients from various parts of the country to determine community spread.
- petilon 7y ago> Do they have any reason to believe that there's something special about the borders of India that cause the virus not to spread inside it? Are you assuming there isn't? High temperatures and muggy weather might make the new coronavirus less contagious, a group of experts says. See: https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-cases-flu-like-drop-linked-with-high-heat-humidity-2020-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-cases-flu-like-d...
- blackoil 7y agoIndians are lot more paranoid in general, because they can't trust hospitals capacity and are risk averse. Schools and Colleges were closed about 20 days back. WFH started in most tech companies about 15 days back. Most are avoiding unnecessary travel and gatherings. There is no culture of pubs/bars, eating out is an occasional thing.
- quantummkv 7y agoEssentially, yes. With the past and current experiences with our neighbors, India can seal half it's borders quickly and effectively when required. The rest is surrounded by sea. And India also started with travel curbs and airport checks long before any western government did.
- smdz 7y agoThere is definite community spread in India. They are not saying the truth either to stop panic or because they have not tested or because they are misinformed (less likely) I am not sure why he said "no signs", because now the data available publicly proves that there is community spread. I do not mean to create panic - but I have strong reasons to correlate that the community spread cases that turned into severe respiratory problems started appearing on March 15, 2020. Based on contact tracing, the patients very likely contracted the virus between March3-March5. This was a likely time of the initial community spread and in fact super spread via weddings. Another timeline possibility is that the community spread started sometime in the last 5-10 days of February. It was also a time when many people were getting cough, cold and respiratory diseases because of a seasonal change. The OPDs were very busy and probably few of the patients were international travelers carrying Covid-19. In the first week of March, there were many cases where patients were seeing weird and elongated respiratory problems that normally do not occur seasonally. However, many of these cases in OPDs also reduced by the second week of March. The first lockdown address from the PM was on March 20. A better way to confirm is to see whether there is a spike in cases (and severe cases) by March 31 - even after the lockdown