5 ms·
Compaq and Coronavirus
- brian_herman 7y agoI don't see the argument here. It is too disjoint.
- lstamour 7y agoI tried to summarize but when it took me two minutes and I was still struggling, I had to give in and agree it’s tenuous. There are probably other points, but the primary one seems to be “put in the effort to solve problems and find unique solutions that work for your country, or follow the herd without effort and die/become marginalized,” but not quite in those terms?
- agumonkey 7y agomy best attempt: - too much compromising and not enough dynamic effort leads to death
- mcguire 7y ago"Taiwan is good in the same way that Compaq was good"?
- hacknat 7y agoOutsourcing.
- Sileni 7y agoIn tech-world speak, he's basically saying innovate or die. On a long enough timeline, the entities that do the work to understand the problem and respond to it are rewarded, the entities which try to coast by on their past success and "brand" will be punished.
- Insanity 7y agoI feel like this would have been perfectly suitable as two posts. (Taiwan and the coronavirus, and the analogy with compaq). But the latter part, about how Taiwan is handling the situation, I thought was pretty interesting.
- greendave 7y agoI also found it difficult to suss out the general point connecting the two events, but I suppose broadly speaking the outsized role of largely unspoken (and undiscussed) choices in both seems significant.
- hacknat 7y agoThe point is that we outsourced everything. Being on the top of a hollowed out value chain, while efficient, is a precarious place to be, because the bottom of the chain can just flip you on your head. A good brand will allow you to release one flop, but not three. The name of Compaq’s supplier in Taiwan? Asus.
- jdswain 7y agoThe article does have two good topics, and I can see the connection, but it does detract from the message. There are some very important things said about Coronavirus, and USA should be taking notice of this right now, but unfortunately if I forward the article on to someone, the first thing they will read will be some PC industry history.
- btilly 7y agoThe underlying message is simple. Willingness to do the work, make hard decisions, and be productive, leads to success. A history of success without that underlying willingness, leads to failure. The West got where it was by being on the winning side of that equation, but has lost it. Taiwan is on the winning side of that equation. The first example was the rise of Compaq (in the West) when it had that willingness, followed by its fall when it didn't. And the rise of other companies in Taiwan that were willing to do the actual work. The second example is coronavirus, where Taiwan's current success stands in stark contrast with the unwillingness of western countries to even consider taking effective action. Taiwan shows what it is possible. The USA can only consider which tragedy to choose. And has gone about it so badly that it is effectively choosing both.
- rob74 7y agoI guess Taiwan's inherent mistrust of China helped in making the right decisions - while the thoughts of politicians in the West were something along the lines of "China is saying it has things under control, the WHO is saying the same, so there is no need for drastic actions right now - and if it turns out later that we were wrong, we can shift the blame to China and the WHO".
- robocat 7y agoEven after China’s (self?)deception became uncovered, most countries still didn’t act effectively, or (even more bizarre) performed their own form of denial. Wasting many weeks of runway, then suddenly discovering an emergency due to lack of foresight. Many citizens knew what was happening, yet somehow our political organisations failed us.
- rjzzleep 7y agoPeople still blame their own failures on China? In January China was already pumping out article after article on what to do what's happening, who gets sick etc. And the US and Europe were still twiddling their thumbs, the only two countries that reacted right away were Taiwan and Russia. China enacted an export ban on surgical masks and Europeans and Americans were still busy exporting masks to China for a profit. End of January all the pharmacies in Berlin were already out of mask supplies and so were the wholesalers. Yet the German health ministry went on TV saying that all this shows how well Germany is prepared. Go on and keep blaming China for this clusterfuck, but the reality is that the the thing that made this situation explode were the illusions of grandure most governments have. The Iranian health ministry went on TV to tell everyone how great they are. Trump was telling people to go work to become healthy. The severity of the outbreak is directly correlated to the level of narcicism of the countries leaders.
- kbutler 7y agoTLDR: He advocates more government control to do what needs to be done. Unfortunately, the government doesn't always know what needs to be done, and some of his examples (e.g., response of local businesses) don't actually require government control, but a societal attitude shift. Add in the desire of some parties to use the crisis to further their agendas, and government control gets worrisome. Article summary: The analogy: "the West feels like Compaq in the 1990s, relying on its brand name and partnerships with other entities to do the actual work, forgetting that it was hard work and determination that made it great in the first place." Important points: """ look more closely at what Taiwan has done to contain SARS-CoV-2 to-date — you can reframe everything in a far more problematic way: Restrict international movement and close borders (including banning all non-resident foreigners this week) Integrate and share private data across government agencies and with hospitals. Track private individual movements via their smartphones. Even the mask production I praised required requisitioning private property by the government, and the refusal of local businesses to serve customers without masks or insist on taking their temperature """
- nategri 7y agoWhen all you have is a hammer everything looks like an IBM clone, I guess.
- endorphone 7y agoThis article feels like what you get when you feel obligated to write something, drawing grand meanings out of disjointed realities. Taiwan was relatively recently an autocracy. It still can resort to its historical behavior overnight. In the West the sort of actions that Taiwan took absent an emergency are politically unpalatable. This is a political/ideological reality. Comparing that with empires that have lost their way is intellectually devoid of any basis and just seems incredibly lazy. From a purely functional perspective it's worth noting that much of the West has a much closer intertwining with China than Taiwan does. This seems counter-intuitive -- China is right beside it, after all -- but multiples more Chinese nationals live in Canada than Taiwan. There were magnitudes more flights between the US and China (purely from a flight # perspective, and certainly much larger from a passenger perspective) than between China and Taiwan. That Taiwan has been somewhat spared thus far is partly explained by this reality.
- bitwize 7y agoI think that the coronavirus situation will teach liberal-minded folks that individual rights are always contingent on public health and public well-being, and it will teach Americans in particular the need for a notwithstanding clause in the Constitution so that the government can take action if necessary. We tend to interpret First Amendment rights as absolute, but only a Sith deals in absolutes.
- frenchy 7y agoI think many liberally minded people realize that (nothwithstanding a few libertarians). In the US then even have the concept of "The Constitution is not a suicide pact", and during WWII a lot of free speach was limited. I think the reality is that most people don't view COVID-19 as an existenial threat to the liberal regime the live in. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Constitution_is_not_a_suicide_pact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Constitution_is_not_a_suic...
- mcguire 7y agoRisks are ever-present. Choosing a liberal democracy involves accepting those risks, and not just in terms of public health and public well-being. A society that guarantees perfect public health and well-being would be unlivable. Various forms of authoritarian government are well known as being able to respond to crises quicker and more effectively. So, yes, being able to declare a state of emergency is an important ability, but living in a permanent state of emergency is to be avoided.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fatjokes 7y agoThis article feels like it was written out of panic and anxiety. The analogy feels pretty weak.
- c-smile 7y agoTL;DR: Korea, Taiwan, China are fighting COVID effectively avoiding country-locked-at-home mode. Major tool for that is the total control on population, e.g. using smartphones and other technical means. The fact: people and society in general there have different mentality historically. Population density was significantly more high there in thousands of years. And so, in these thousands of years, population agreed on far smaller "privacy radius" by giving up personal privacy, generation by generation. As of "privacy radius", consider population of Korea - 52 mln and population of Canada - 38 mln. While territory of Canada is 100,000 times larger. So in East Asia you can technically implement total control of each person. Countries have infrastructure and acceptance of population already. Therefore they can fight such problems effectively. But on other hand high density of the population is a breeding bullion for next such COVIDs ...
- glaive123 7y agoI was in S. Korea from around Feb 1 - 20. US and S. Korea had the first case of COVID at the same time, Jan 20. As of the first week of February, emergency SMS alerts in S. Korea were sent out daily, sometimes several times per day. These alerts told everyone to wear masks, stay inside, wash hands, and exercise caution. S. Korea was already mobilizing government resources when there were very few cases. I remember there were only 20 cases at this point and all the efforts seemed overkill, but now we know they were necessary. Meanwhile in the US none of this was taking place and the president is publicly saying everything is under control, when it was not. It's comically easy to see why the US is failing to contain COVID if you have been watching how governments in Asia have been handling the outbreak.
- mercer 7y agowe received one single sms in NL via our fancy alert system that gave a warning I don't even remember. we're definitely not doing all that much altogether, other than slowly ramping up the quarantining as things get worse (with a 2+ week lag that we don't seem to take into account, I guess?).