4 ms·
The last thing you or I need is another configuration file clogging up our home directories. This is why the XDG spec exists. Use XDG_CONFIG_HOME, not HOME. I
by nerdponx 7y ago
The last thing you or I need is another configuration file clogging up our home directories.
This is why the XDG spec exists. Use XDG_CONFIG_HOME, not HOME.
I don't feel strongly about config file vs env var for just 2 settings, but seems worth noting. Dropping a dotfile right into your home directory is old school and needs to go away.
- swidi 7y agoI'm a Windows user, which means dotfiles are even uglier for me. For an app that just needs two tiny variables, environs are the much cleaner solution.
- jamesgeck0 7y agoIf you use much *nix style software on Windows, you may already have a XDG_CONFIG_HOME directory. It defaults to ~/.config Even on my relatively clean Windows system, that directory contains config files generated by NPM and Scoop.
- omaranto 7y agoTo me filling HOME with dotfiles doesn't feel much tidier than filling XDG_CONFIG_HOME with stuff, but I'll take everyone's word for it (even though most people can't seem to explain why they prefer it, can you?).
- yepguy 7y agoI'm assuming that you accidentally got that statement backwards, because otherwise it doesn't make sense to me. Would you still feel like dropping things in HOME was tidy if hidden files weren't a thing? You can also back up XDG_CONFIG_HOME without grabbing garbage like cache data.
- omaranto 7y agoYes, sorry I got it backwards. I don't look at my HOME directory often, I usually start from a subdirectory of HOME that has what I'm looking for. Is that why people prefer XDG_CONFIG_HOME, because they look at HOME a lot? I guess I can understand that.
- yepguy 7y agoYes, I usually start my shell sessions in $HOME. I also have shell aliases set up so I always see hidden files, and it would drive me crazy if I weren't able to tuck most config files into another directory.
- omaranto 7y agoI think Emacs has been shielding me from dotfiles. I usually start a shell in the directory of the file I'm looking at. I hardly ever see $HOME. I also have dired (Emacs' built-in file explorer) show me hidden files by default, but there aren't that many (basically just .git and .gitignore) outside of $HOME.
- jlarocco 7y ago"If hidden files didn't exist" doesn't matter because they do exist... I actually also prefer putting config files in HOME. I don't feel strongly enough to argue about it, I just prefer it.
- yepguy 7y agoI don't really like hidden files myself, but my point was more to get you to see the lack of clean hierarchy in just dumping things in $HOME.