6 ms·
Forward and backward compatibility around the transition to color television was one of the most amazing innovations ever. Hiding the color subcarrier in-band
by phkahler 7y ago
Forward and backward compatibility around the transition to color television was one of the most amazing innovations ever.
Hiding the color subcarrier in-band but largely invisible on black and white sets was a work of collective engineering genious.
- pishpash 7y agoAnalog backward compatibility seems more complicated now.
- dylan604 7y agoAfter dealing with video, anything audio related seems way less complicated.
- FranOntanaya 7y agoAnd a curse long after frame modes lost any real world purpose. The workflows ended surviving much longer than the technology that justified them.
- jschwartzi 7y agoYeah I vividly recall encountering the same front/back porch and horizontal and vertical synchronization pulses in an LVDS output to a touchscreen as would be seen in analog television. Simply because you would need that data to work with monitors that have backward compatibility. This was on the TI AM335X so a fairly recent microcontroller.
- Taniwha 7y agoWell let's talk about gamma correction - originally created because B/W Tv tubes were not linear, rather than doing the linear->tube conversion in each TV (which typically had ~10 tubes in them - think 10 transistors) they did the conversion in the Tv studio for ALL the TV receivers and just standardized the non-linearity of the TV screen tube's response. We kept that same gamma when we switched to digital color spaces (and MPEG compression) - it's why noiry dark movies (think of Blade Runner with people in dark spaces smoking) - because of gamma correction there are few digital codes available at the dark corner of the digital color cubes and the result tends to be blocky simply because the color space simply can't represent those colors .... all because of a technical choice made in the late 30s to reduce the cost of Tvs
- buckminster 7y agoSome related engineering genius: the artefacts created in the black and white picture by the colour signal are hardly noticeable, but they are enough to recover the colour from a black and white recording! https://colour-recovery.fandom.com/wiki/The_Unofficial_Colour_Recovery_Wiki https://colour-recovery.fandom.com/wiki/The_Unofficial_Colou...
- jacobush 7y agoThat's amazing! I wonder if there are still photographs floating around which could be colour decoded too.
- amiga 7y agoMaybe a recorded broadcast of a photo?
- jacobush 7y agoOnly if the photo itself was in colour and broadcast in colour. It's the other way around I was thinking of - a still shot (in black and white) of a PAL or NTSC signal would still contain enough information to decode the colour now, in retrospect. For instance, a high resolution (still) film photo of a large high resolution TV from back in the day.
- fenwick67 7y agoThey even shimmed in closed caption data and widescreen signalling to that same signal they've been using since the 40s. It's honestly beautiful.
- dylan604 7y agoNot to mention timecode, Macrovision, and a slew of other proprietary information was stored in the vertical blanking part of the signal. I really miss the hackable nature of analog signals.
- hazeii 7y agoThough there was a time when presenters knew not to wear anything with narrow vertical or fine chequerboard patterns, because the resulting high-frequency luminance signal would bleed through into the colour signal causing phantom colour effects. Interestingly the effect occasionaly occurs today, here in the UK where people use old Sky boxes to provide an RF output to a TV in another room.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Taniwha 7y agoWasn't that long ago - it changed fashion - all those hounds-tooth jackets, paisley ties etc etc stopped being seen in public (on TV) and were replaced by solid colors.
- JdeBP 7y agoBack in the 1980s, D-MAC was touted as the system that was going to eliminate that problem. Separation of analogue chrominance and luminance was specifically called out as a feature in popular science explanations.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoDo you mean like when a moire pattern may sometimes appear to have a ghostly coloured after-image? I've seen this in old black-and-white films shown on colour TV. I've been trying to describe that to people to learn more about what it is but I always fail to. I feared there might be something wrong with my eyes. Is there a name for this effect?
- hazeii 7y agoFor Tv's the colour is caused because the colour signal is hidden as a high frequecy component that older B&W Tv's would ignore. Conversely, a high frequency signal caused by closely spaced light and dark patterns fools colour TV's into thinking there's a colour signal present (as the filters in TV's improved the magnitude of the effect reduced, but it's there to this day in analogue TV). What you're seeing is probably Fechner Color [0]. I've seen the effect myself, as I recall there was a bit of a craze for demoing it some years back. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fechner_color https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fechner_color
- dbcurtis 7y agoYour comment made me think of a personal anecdote. File it under "Why I love living in Silicon Valley". Our neighborhood blocked off the street for a Fourth of July picnic a few years ago. Sitting in a lawn chair talking to a long-retired neighbor over a beer, we got to talking about old analog TV standards. (We are both hams, so conversation tended to turn to radio-ish things.) I remarked about how clever I thought it was mixing the video carrier and audio subcarrier to get the audio IF. And he says: "Oh, it wasn't always like that. When I was a kid, there was a TV station in Philadelphia that transmitted 2 1/2 hours two nights a week. They taped up the schematics for a receiver inside a big picture window at their station, and we would all go down with notebooks and copy down the latest changes so that we could update our receivers. The audio subcarrier went through a lot of changes. AM, FM, and they moved the frequency around." So... I realized that here was a guy who was watching television back when the way you got a TV receiver was to build it from scratch yourself. Wow number 1. I said: "I suppose when the war came along you were sent to radar school like almost everybody else that worked on television?" Answer: "No. Did you ever hear of Eckert and Mauchly?" Me: stunned.
- jacobush 7y agoSo, let me get this straight - he worked on the design or construction of the ENIAC? :)
- dbcurtis 7y agoI believe so. Or the war-time version they did for the Army. I don't remember all the history of those machines exactly.
- dylan604 7y agoWhile not in Silicon Valley, but the other Valley down in Burbank, I had a similar conversation. I was introduced to this person as we had a common interest in the proper methods of 24fps->29.97fps->23.976 video conversions. He told me of the summer he and his brother created a new method to replace the old school flying spot scanning technique that was common at the time. The new process included the ability of one of the first video noise removal capabilities. The coolest part of the story to me was that the first TV broadcast from the moon was sent through the bit of equipment he had built before being broadcast to the public.
- dylan604 7y agoI too hold this 30fps->29.97 solution to be quite ingenious. I wonder if they had any insight into the future of broadcast formats if they might have chosen a different path? I have no idea if anything else was possible, but looking back monday morning blah blah blah This backwards compatibility has been the bane of my career. The 29.97 or 30000/1001 frequency, the interlacing, and the effects it had on 24fps film transfer has given me a niche career path, but one so frustrating when dealing with media content butchered by people that had zero understanding of the history of why film/video content was formatted the way it was.
- jacquesm 7y agoThere are two other tricks like that: stereo radio transmission and stereo gramophone records.
- LocalH 7y agoThey didn't do it without slightly modifying the existing standard (luckily still within tolerance). Thus the source of that infernal 1000/1001 factor that pushed field rates from 60Hz to approximately 59.94Hz