4 ms·
Online, without personalization it's the other way around Local and niche businesses can only advertise on Facebook/Google Ads because their clientele can be d
by helsinkiandrew 7y ago
Online, without personalization it's the other way around
Local and niche businesses can only advertise on Facebook/Google Ads because their clientele can be defined and targeted.
Without targeting we'll be watching ads for Coca-Cola and McDonalds and other brands that have 'mass' appeal.
- vthriller 7y agoWhy can't they target content instead of visitors? i.e. articles and videos about X instead of people that showed even minimal interest in X in the past month or so.
- stoev 7y agoExactly. Which is what drives the biggest advertising machine anyway (Google Search). That model could be replicated for the open internet.
- haste410 7y agoHow would that work for site like Facebook or Instagram or other sites where there is no clear relevant content to target?
- cercatrova 7y agoNatural language processing for posts and video analysis via machine learning could work.
- Tarq0n 7y agoThere's been a lot of work in this area over the last few years, clustering and tagging text and video. Facebook even has an open source library for it called Starspace.
- helsinkiandrew 7y agoBut the point is that Facebook is showing you ads based on your surfing behaviour outside Facebook - not the content you view on Facebook. If you use facebook purely for posting and viewing family baby photos, but view websites about tractors, you'll probably see ads on facebook from tractor related companies. Starspace is used by FB to tag the sites that report that you've visited them to facebook. So they can target ads
- Quanttek 7y agoI think the point is that FB could change to a contextual model. E.g. after seeing a post of a news article by Tractor Daily you would see an ad for a new John Deere.
- dwild 7y agoCan you be more precise to what you means? That sounds like targetting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- earthboundkid 7y agoYou can assert that, but where is the evidence? Tracking exists today and I never see ads relevant to my large American city. I see the same gross out earwax scams as everyone in the world.
- jariel 7y ago"You can assert that, but where is the evidence?" It's not a remotely controversial statement. If you take a minute to actually run a marketing campaign for your company you'll learn all sorts of things. Including how targeting works. There are other options such as restricting the type and degree of targetting. The 'big outdoor ads' thing is not related to targeted ads, it's not part of this discussion. I'm fine with banning all outdoor ads but not targetted ads. There we need regulation.
- earthboundkid 7y agoHere is what I know. I know if I open a newspaper, I see ads for businesses, both local and national. If I go to the newspaper’s website, I see ads for one weird trick, the same ads on every site and in every city, and essentially no meaningful local content. Yes, things on Facebook are different, but Facebook is not a publisher, it’s a parasite, so who cares?
- jariel 7y ago1) Banner ads on websites are often targeted via networks, often Google. 2) Those 'stupid ads' are often targeted, and they make money, sadly. 3) You're probably not accounting for the majority of ads you see. If you literally tracked/recorded every ad, you might see a different picture. 4) Many ads are not very well targeted, yes, and that's why you see irrelevance. Well-targeted ads are generally more relevant (sometimes not obvious) and this is 100% validated by returns to advertisers. This is not a joke. 5) Facebook and Google represent most of the ad market, so, the people that 'care' are basically everyone who wants to place an ad online.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]