6 ms·
The argument for massive Pigouvian taxes on advertising seems much clearer. Advertising imposes massive costs on society and the viewers. These costs aren't
by bryanlarsen 7y ago
The argument for massive Pigouvian taxes on advertising seems much clearer. Advertising imposes massive costs on society and the viewers. These costs aren't borne by the advertiser, so they should be captured through massive taxes and put to good use.
And many brands wouldn't feel much of an impact: what matters to Coke is that it spends more than Pepsi. If their $6B on advertising only buys 1/10th as many ads as it used to it still has the same impact because they still have twice as many ads as Pepsi does.
- growlist 7y agoAnd it's a shame really - I find most budget colas have a far richer cola flavour than either Coke or Pepsi. Coke especially is very bland.
- clarry 7y agoIdk about budget colas but Fentimans Curiosity Cola is pretty nice, and you don't need billboards on streets to get me to buy some. (I don't think I've ever seen an ad for Fentimans'.)
- avalys 7y agoWhat’s the cost that advertising imposes exactly?
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoPeople have finite attention tokens to spend per day. Attention tokens are consumed when you make a conscious and deliberate decision to invest time in something, but they are also consumed when someone approaches you and talks to you. Of course, people close to us usually are mindful of not consuming too many of our attention tokens. And some interruptions are useful to you, so they are welcome. Advertisements, on the other hand, consume the attention tokens of everyone who views them, and because they are optimizing for the revenue to the company, and not the benefit to the person, the expected benefit of each advertisement to the person is extremely low, if not downright negative.
- avalys 7y agoOk. So we ban advertising. Now you have to spend your “attention tokens” earning money to purchase the content you were previously getting for free. Is that better? How about we let people make this choice themselves, just as we do now?
- danaris 7y agoPeople don't get to make the choice themselves now. They are forced to see the advertising, whether they want to or not. Removing the advertising would, in fact, give them back choice they currently lack.
- thu2111 7y agoPeople aren't forced to do anything. They don't have to use content supported by ads, plenty of it isn't. And the biggest/best online ad networks offer controls, which nobody uses because vanishingly few people care. Banning targeted advertising would be ridiculous. I'll say it: I love targeted ads. I'd much rather have usefully targeted ads than go back to the days of DoubleClick punch the monkey garbage, or "these beautiful twins" generic garbage. No targeted ads doesn't look like a blissful utopia of clean web pages, it looks like the existing web but all the ads are 10x more distracting and manipulative. We've been there, we know how it is. If you want a reminder just go to a news website in incognito mode and see what lowest common denominator dreck gets presented. When I look around trying to find people supposedly harmed by targeted ads, I come up blank. I've never heard of this being a problem and I resent the constant efforts of "privacy justice warriors" to screw up the internet for everyone else. My internet experience is made far worse by invasive cookie banners than by ad cookies, if I had to pick which one to disappear with a wand there'd be no hesitation.
- danaris 7y ago> People aren't forced to do anything. You're not listening. Or, apparently, thinking critically about the issue. Two things: First, they—we—are forced to see it. That, in itself, is already a cost to us all. It taxes our brains, in ways that have been measured. And yes, I know that banning the targeting isn't the same as banning the advertising, but we should definitely be doing that in more of our spaces, too. Now, second: People do not have the choice to opt out of the data collection. Oh, sure, you can check the box on website X that says "don't sell my data," you can choose not to do business with Facebook, but you can't actually avoid the tracking and actually participate in the modern world. (Heck, in some places, you'll be tracked and profiled just from what you do in the physical world, too, through cameras and such.) The point isn't that people are (by and large) being actively harmed by the targeting in the ads. We're being harmed by the invasion of privacy required to implement the targeting, and we're being harmed by the inability to avoid seeing the ads.
- adamisom 7y agoExactly seems like a pretty tough thing to answer. What's the exact effect on the climate of X or Y company?
- bregma 7y agoWell, for one, I pay for my internet bandwidth. Somewhere around 80% of all my bandwidth is used up with either advertising or all the infrastructure associated with tracking everything I do in order to sell my eyeballs. From my point of view it's a fairly straightforward costing: 0.8 times what I pay for the internet, plus maybe 0.2 times my hourly rate to account for the waiting time I have to donate out of my billable hours.
- PaulRobinson 7y agoGo to a drug store. Find a generic no-brand ibuprofen. Check the price. Find a branded ibuprofen that is advertised on TV. In the UK, Nurofen is popular. Check the price. The difference is advertising. Same goes for detergent, breakfast cereal, AA batteries, etc., etc.
- avalys 7y agoThat's not a cost imposed on you - you're free to buy the generic off-brand.
- PaulRobinson 7y agoEnough competitors will eventually realise that the only way to sell any units at all is to advertise, and so will start to ramp up their own efforts. Eventually the advertising cost is in all products, and there is no cheap generic off-brand. This is already the case in cars, houses (you're paying the brokers whether directly or indirectly), jobs (the recruiter fees comes out of your salary and training budgets), etc., etc. Getting rid of "advertising" in a sector is possibly the biggest economic disruptor you could ever apply to it.
- Mirioron 7y agoOn the flip-side, businesses that rely on ad revenue would disappear. That means most of the commonly used websites. No more Google, Facebook, YouTube, Reddit, Twitch, almost all news sites etc. This also means that everything goes back to essentially subscription only and this without a credit card don't get much access to stuff (like it used to be).
- mantas 7y agoHow did TV and paper press existed? Non-targeted advertising brings €€€ too.
- Mirioron 7y agoPaper press has been disappearing for quite a while even with subscription fees. They're often bankrolled by rich people or companies and likely aren't impartial. I'm not sure TV is a good example either. The number of TV channels isn't that great. At the same time TV channels have a ridiculous amount of ads and they engage in all kinds of shady practices to sell you on something you don't want. Or in the cases of things like the BBC they extort the taxpayer.
- mantas 7y agoPaper press and TV did really well for decades. Sure, once targeted advertising came around, everyone jumped onto it and non-targeted advertising started to fall. But if targeted advertising would be outlawed, most of that budget would just return to other advertising channels. Other advertising channels as in not-targeted ads in websites/youtube/etc. Classic paper and tv are gone for good IMO. > TV channels have a ridiculous amount of ads and they engage in all kinds of shady practices to sell you on something you don't want Not much worse than interwebs if you disable AdBlock&friends...
- Mirioron 7y agoI think TV ads are much worse than ads on the internet. Imagine YouTube, where you have to watch an ad that's a fifth of the length of the video for every video. 10 minute video? 2 minutes of unskippable ads. Right now we tend to have skippable ads that are much shorter.