5 ms·
A lot of wars these days are asymmetric. It's very rare to have fully equipped armies+navies+airforce on both sides. Usually people do the math upfront and one
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
A lot of wars these days are asymmetric. It's very rare to have fully equipped armies+navies+airforce on both sides. Usually people do the math upfront and one side concludes it probably is better to not get destroyed completely.
In most wars in recent history you have one side with lots of relatively high tech weaponry going against guerrilla forces fighting with relatively unsophisticated stuff but hiding among civilians, thus making the use of all that high tech weaponry a bit controversial. E.g. Syria is a good example of that.
WW II was probably the last conflict where all sides basically removed the gloves and fought with everything they had where everything on both sides included some very scary options. I live in what got rebuilt after WW II destroyed Berlin. There wasn't much left here. Other cities got it worse.
Tanks still have a role because in most conflicts, the other side would lack the means to defend against them. But they'd be relatively useless against someone with rockets & an airforce. But they are awesome for dominating a chaotic battlefield without that. Basically, in the Gulf wars, the US took out the iraqi airforce in no time and after that basically tanks rolled in pretty much without opposition. I don't think any US tanks were lost at all. Much of the conventional troops ended up surrendering.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zipwitch 7y ago>WW II was probably the last conflict where all sides basically removed the gloves and fought with everything they had where everything on both sides included some very scary options. I think that would actually be the Iran-Iraq War: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War Tank combat, air combat involving a wide range of aircraft, bombing raids, ballistic missile strikes, naval combat, trench warfare and chemical weapon use all took place during the war from 1980 to 1988.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoYes, you are correct; I forgot about how brutal that conflict was.
- Der_Einzige 7y agoOnly known case of a helicopter killing a jet in that war iirc!
- adolph 7y ago> in the Gulf wars, the US took out the iraqi airforce in no time and after that basically tanks rolled in pretty much without opposition I acknowledge the hedge of "pretty much" and use this moment to commemorate the Battle of 73 Easting, Toujours Pret. "G Troop lost one M3 Bradley to Iraqi IFV fire and one soldier, Sergeant Nels A. Moller, the gunner of the Bradley, was killed. The Bradley's TOW launcher was inoperative, and the 25mm Bushmaster Cannon had jammed. While the crew was attempting to get the cannon back in action, an Iraqi BMP-1 which was thought to be disabled with a tank shell punched through its armor, fired and hit the vehicle's turret with 73 mm cannon fire. Moller died instantly and the remainder of the crew evacuated the damaged vehicle." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_73_Easting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_73_Easting
- redis_mlc 7y agoA Bradley is not a tank. Also, the real story is that a squad of Apaches in the air was ambushed and destroyed early in the Iraq war from ground fire. Half crashed and half made it back, but with too much damage to fly again.
- AtlasBarfed 7y agoThe Bradley, as I've read, is a hallmark of the deficiencies of DOD committee planning. Well, until the F-35.
- winterchil 7y agoThere's a dated but entertaining dramatization of this failure from the movie Pentagon Wars: https://youtu.be/aXQ2lO3ieBA https://youtu.be/aXQ2lO3ieBA.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoI ve seen some write ups and basically the Allies go caught out by the Iraqis and almost got completely overrun. As Wellington said ” It has been a damned serious business. It has been a damned nice thing – the nearest run thing you ever saw in your life.”
- blaser-waffle 7y agoEthiopia vs Eritrea, or some of the other African wars come to mind as peer-vs-peer competitions. Maybe India vs China in the 60s.
- AtlasBarfed 7y agoDrones will change the equation I think for small state actors. You just need minimally capable drones to win economic exchanges (I lose 1000 $1000 drones to destroy your $25,000,000 plane/tank, I win). The US will probably develop some countermeasures, but so much of the military complex is invested in impressive looking tanks/aircraft/ships and will have substantial political inertia. The surface Navy is practically obsolete. They are deploying laser point defense that allegedly doesn't suck, but that won't stop a fleet of 1000 drone subs that just need one or two torpedos to hit, or a barrage of antiship missles. If the US doesn't sell, other NATO countries and Russia/China will. Radio jamming won't stop laser mesh network communication. They can lie in wait in bushes and activate right under forces. At least if modern warfare (conventional) devolves into starcraft-esque massive drone vs drone flotilla conflicts, it might cut down on human troop life loss, and maybe even "collateral damage". But that never seems to happen.
- johntiger1 7y agoAgree that we should have a serious discussion about our navy. Really have doubts about the utility, other than being huge (symbolic) symbols of power. But perhaps due to their size they will be able to mount significant countermeasures.
- onetimemanytime 7y ago>>Basically, in the Gulf wars, the US took out the iraqi airforce in no time and after that basically tanks rolled in pretty much without opposition. I don't think any US tanks were lost at all. Much of the conventional troops ended up surrendering. Smart men. No doubt US psy-opps played a part, they must've understood weeks ahead and talked among themselves that it is over, and no worth dying for Saddam (who is not even in our tribe :)) . No doubt top Generals were probably contacted offered X and Y if they surrendered. Giving a General a suitcase of cash is much cheaper than the bullets spent, without adding equipment and lives lost.