3 ms·
The von Neumann architecture became possible because Church and Turing wrote their highly theoretical, mathematical works. Lasers became possible because peopl
by nine_k 7y ago
The von Neumann architecture became possible because Church and Turing wrote their highly theoretical, mathematical works.
Lasers became possible because people like Fresnel studied the properties of a highly impractical phenomenon, coherent light, while other people discovered another short-lived curiosity, inverse energy levels population.
Many such works had to be done decades before any engineering applications, or a prospect thereof.
Science is when you study the literally unknown, including no known practical applications.
When you study small pockets of unknown in a generally understood and practically fertile field, it's engineering.
- mjfl 7y ago> The von Neumann architecture became possible because Church and Turing wrote their highly theoretical, mathematical works. I don't know about others but Von Neumann architecture is much more described by Church and Turings work than derived from it, like steam engines are described by thermodynamics. Neither invention was actually dependent on the theory. Science often derives from engineering, not the other way around. Get over it.
- marmaduke 7y agoScience and engineering are a cycle on a spectrum, you don't get one without the other.
- Karrot_Kream 7y ago> I don't know about others but Von Neumann architecture is much more described by Church and Turings work than derived from it, like steam engines are described by thermodynamics. Neither invention was actually dependent on the theory. Huh? Turing's paper on the halting problem and Universal Turing Machines was released in 1936. Von Neumann, Eckert, and Mauchly's memo was not released until Jan 1944. There is no way that Von Neumann's architecture is described by Turing's work, given the 8 year difference between them! > I don't know about others I'm puzzled by how you can make such a strong claim about the nature of innovation without precisely drilling down into the evidence backing your theory.
- catalogia 7y agoNot saying I agree with it, but I don't think 'describes' in the sense it's being used above is meant to imply causality.
- marmaduke 7y agoI think your comment is excellent but doomed to be undervalued by those outside science. I'd guess this is in part because science textbooks and pop sci always present science as a fait accompli. To put it differently, it's as if you listen to a wonderful jazz improvisation and ignore the thousands of hours of 'doodling' on the scales the musician might have done.
- freemint 7y agoAre you trying to suggest that Zuse's computer didn't work because the NVA was not out yet? That Babbage would machine (also NVA) wouldn't have worked bc Neumann wasn't born yet?
- nine_k 7y agoThe Babbage's machine would have worked! But it'd be more limited that it needed to be. It was a specialized calculator by design, not a general-purpose computer, partly because of the lack of the theoretical framework.
- haihaibye 7y agoI think Shannon's 1937 masters thesis linking boolean algebra and electronics was the most important theoretical paper for computers: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Symbolic_Analysis_of_Relay_and_Switching_Circuits https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Symbolic_Analysis_of_Relay...