7 ms·
Fair, although I think we need to remember in difficult times like this that: - The plague killed 50-100% of people who got it depending on which kind of plagu
by arcticbull 7y ago
Fair, although I think we need to remember in difficult times like this that:
- The plague killed 50-100% of people who got it depending on which kind of plague you got (bubonic, pneumonic or septicemic) whereas while nCoV rates are still TBD we're probably looking at an upper bound closer to half a percent, or 3-4 order of magnitude lower.
- The average age of folks who've died of nCoV so far in Italy is 80 and in China the mid-high 70s.
- The plague took everyone whereas the young and healthy are effectively going to get a (sometimes very, very) bad cold out of nCoV. The younger they are, the less affected. I think out of the hundreds of thousands of cases we know about so far only a single child has died -- and they had serious medical conditions going in. Currently the CFR in Korea and in the USA for people under 30 is less than 0.1%.
Perspective matters. It's easy to get swept up in the panic going on right now. Don't panic. Do listen to authorities and generally keep away from other folks. This will all be over in a few months. We'll mostly all get it, we'll overwhelmingly recover, and become immune. Chances are this is going to become one of the endemic viruses that shows up every year from now on.
As panic sets in, if you've got some cash to invest in the markets and a long time horizon to draw on it, this may be the money making opportunity of a generation.
- jiggawatts 7y ago> This will all be over in a few weeks. Not likely. Many countries are still weeks away from the virus reaching the "oh-shit" numbers, effective lockdowns take weeks more, and then the whole thing is likely to reoccur at least once or twice in most places. This is going to make the entire year 2020 spicier than we would all like...
- arcticbull 7y agoEdited to reflect it'll probably be a few months. 2020 will be spicy.
- ConsiderCrying 7y agoWhich countries are closest to lifting the first lockdown? Italy is generating record death tolls every day but that could mean the pandemic will die down soon (pardon the phrasing.) I feel like that and Germany might see some improvement by the end of April, they've been taking things quite seriously.
- arcticbull 7y agoChina is in the process of lifting its lockdown right now. The total number of active cases is 5K out of a total of 81K. They are starting to let the healthy out of quarantine, re-opening tourist attractions and getting back to work.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoSo they claim. Anything out of China should be taken with a healthy pinch of skepticism.
- arcticbull 7y agoApple has re-opened Apple stores and factories there, while shutting down Apple stores everywhere else. No matter how you feel about the PRC there's no reason to doubt Tim Cook.
- microtherion 7y agoMy coworkers in China confirm that people are gradually getting back to work, and I have no reason to doubt them. The procedure seems quite interesting: Instead of lifting quarantine for everyone at once, the return to work is rolled out slowly (some %age of workers return the first day, some more the next day), so the situation can be monitored.
- agumonkey 7y agoI'm still hoping for a slight acceleration of medical research and production when they get potential symptoms easing and actual vaccine. Enough to dampen the secondary waves.
- jonstewart 7y agoThe article isn’t about literal similarities between the bubonic plague and the Coronavirus.
- arcticbull 7y agoSure, the book is most commonly attributed to being an allegory about Nazi occupied France. As there isn't a Nazi invasion going on I assumed people were taking it more literally than they were allegorically. And if you're going to take it literally, contextual information matters.
- ericmcer 7y agoHow much of the extremely old mean death age do you think is caused by burdened hospitals turning away certain age groups. If it gets bad enough hospitals here in the US will create rules to turn away people over a certain age.
- arcticbull 7y agoFigure 2 in the CDC write-up indicates they account for a much larger fraction of the hospital admissions, though a much lower fraction of them require ICU admission, and a much lower fraction of them die [1]. This aligns with Korea [2]. The funnel is much, much less forgiving to the aged. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6912e2.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6912e2.htm [2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1105088/south-korea-coronavirus-mortality-rate-by-age/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1105088/south-korea-coro...
- vasco 7y agoI'm 28, fit, physically active (bouldering / running / gym), no pre-conditions whatsoever, take vitamin D supplementation, I don't take any medication. I'm going through a nasty pneumonia that hurts my lungs just breathing and I've never had something like this before. I get tired just walking around, whereas 2 weeks ago I did a 40 minute 10k. Take that anecdata as you will, but if you can protect yourself, do. So when you say it's just a "bad cold", I chuckle a bit. What's going to happen to the millions of overweight, high blood pressure / diabetic Americans? Sure don't panic, but be safe.
- arcticbull 7y agoOh yeah, it'll be a bad cold. You may well have it now. By no means am I suggesting people run out there and hug the nearest stranger they see, but what I am suggesting, is they not panic. The numbers are in their favor. This could have been much, much worse.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoTo be clear, the evidence seems to be that your outcome is still in the minority of cases. Some unknown but double digit percentage experience no symptoms at all despite testing positive, another large proportion only experience upper respiratory symptoms and never get a lower respiratory infection or pneumonia, finally there are so called "mild" cases which I believe are "a bad flu." What these proportions are exactly is unclear, but it is clear that the vast vast majority people are not at risk of death. The data is unreliable and all over the place, but it's trending in this direction: in otherwise healthy people, this isn't particularly lethal. I am not a doctor but you should probably get tested.
- vasco 7y agoI cannot get tested. I live in the Netherlands and unless your case is serious enough that you either have very high fever or a great difficulty breathing, the official instructions are to not even call the health line, much less go to a hospital. I have friends in Portugal, Spain and Italy that have similar symptoms to mine and are home and doing the same because those are the official guidelines. I agree with these guidelines, the phone lines and hospitals should be open for people who are at risk of dying. But that means that the numbers you're looking at are barely the tip of the iceberg for a lot of these european countries.
- watwut 7y agoIs it possible to guess past plagues asymptomatic carriers? The death rate might be actually lower if there were asymptomatic spreaders too.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- baxtr 7y agoGood, refreshing perspective! How do you think we will get out of the lock downs? That’s my biggest concern right now. The restrictions are getting worse and worse and we are suffocating many businesses. I fear the repercussions are greater than the effect on the curve flattness.
- temac 7y agoFor some young people, it might ressemble to a "bad cold", and some people might even be completely asymptomatic, HOWEVER: - in France 50% of ICU patients are under 60 - this is really the wrong message to pass - for some people around 30 this more closely resemble to a very bad flu, with extra bonus symptoms - you are not getting very accurate numbers from Italy right now: only people dying in an hospital are counted, but some are dying at home (the symptoms are very fast evolving at the end, and the medical system is surcharged) Now I don't discuss that for probably at least 98% of contaminated, (and maybe even more), they will live. But this is certainly not a bad cold, by any fucking standard. For anybody. We don't halt the world for "bad colds". > As panic sets in, if you've got some cash to invest in the markets and a long time horizon to draw on it, this may be the money making opportunity of a generation. Most people have other preoccupations; but if you want to be seen as are seen the people who made a fortune during 9/11, by all means focus on that.
- whatshisface 7y ago>if you want to be seen as are seen the people who made a fortune during 9/11, by all means focus on that. Hopefully nobody looks poorly on the people who bought stock after 9/11, if it wasn't for them the market would never have gone back up.
- temac 7y agoI said "during", and "focus". Right out stating to the world "oh my god the world is overreacting, this is not such a big deal, and the best opportunity in your life to get rich for completely abstract reasons" during the greatest pandemic people in huge parts of the world have every lived, while literally a billion people are more or less locked down, and in the thread commenting "The Plague", is, I don't know how to put it precisely, but lets say at least: "weird". Some people are focusing on designing quickly mass-productible respirators, etc...
- arcticbull 7y agoMy dude, in a market, if there's no buyers, the price of equities becomes zero. If you want to help people preserve their net worth, what you want is more buyers. For the sellers, maybe they require the liquidity to pay for essentials? It doesn't matter. What matters is that if nobody is buying their shares are worthless. The people focusing on mass-producing ventilators are likely in China where the quarantine is in the process of being lifted as they have resolved the situation.
- endorphone 7y ago"while nCoV rates are still TBD we're probably looking at an upper bound closer to half a percent, or 3-4 order of magnitude lower" This is incredible. Not only do you start with an "upper bound" less than one-half the accepted value, you then toss in a "3-4 order of magnitude" reduction, which is so fantastically impossible that there has clearly been zero actual thought. Just rhetoric. Elon Musk, is that you? Actual medial professionals are seeing that even tiny spread in a community the healthcare system becomes absolutely overwhelmed. Hence all of the emergency declarations. The Internet intelligentsia would like us all to believe that millions are walking around with it, and the fact that you can trace individual branches and the horrifying results is just a remarkable coincidence happening throughout the globe. No, this isn't the plague. At the same time anyone who seriously compares this virus to the cold has started in a completely broken, intellectually dishonest and dangerous place. Add that to the silly claims about death rates... As to investment opportunities, this is an incredibly lazy, zero-value observation -- yes, in the future the market will grow. Nobody thinks otherwise. But right now the market has lost some 35% off a frothy, already-in-danger high, and ahead of us are heroic government responses and a lot of economic disruption. But yeah, at some point it's going to hit bottom, and if someone is willing to churn on limited returns for a while it'll eventually pay off. You could say that in every downturn throughout history.
- arcticbull 7y ago> This is incredible. Not only do you start with an "upper bound" less than one-half the accepted value, you then toss in a "3-4 order of magnitude" reduction, which is so fantastically impossible that there has clearly been zero actual thought. Just rhetoric. Elon Musk, is that you? 3-4 orders of magnitude lower than the plague which has an upper bound fatality of 100%. That's not controversial. 3-4 order of magnitude lower than 100% is 0.01 to 0.9%, a range very much in line with your suggestion and that of health officials.
- endorphone 7y agoMy mistake. I misinterpreted the wording as being a modifier of the range on SARS-CoV-2. The rest of my comment stands. Though 0.5% is 2 order of magnitude less than 50%. Not to mention that the plague had a mortality rate between 1 - 15%...
- cycrutchfield 7y agoSwing and a miss. What’s this got to do with Camus?
- esturk 7y agoTo not downplay the severity of the virus, even if a young person were to recover from Covid-19, s/he may experience reduced lung capacity for several years. There are many sources online based on SARS and here's one: https://thorax.bmj.com/content/60/5/401 https://thorax.bmj.com/content/60/5/401
- arcticbull 7y agobased on SARS is not useful. Until we get COVID-19 specific data that means nothing. 15% of the common cold is attributable to coronoaviridae and that very much doesn't cause these problems. Just because you see something in SARS-COV-1 doesn't mean you'll see it in SARS-COV-2. SARS-COV-1 has a fatality rate of 15% overall and 50% in over-65s [1] and MERS have death rates approaching 35% [2]. Until we see actual reports of this in the wild directly attributable to SARS-COV-2 we shouldn't really extrapolate. Otherwise it's as useful as saying "based on the fact 15% of the common cold is attributable to coronaviridae, get out there and have fun" or "based on the fact MERS and SARS-COV-2 are both coronaviridae 35% of people are going to die." [1] http://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2003/05/estimates-sars-death-rates-revised-upward http://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2003/05/estimates... [2] https://www.who.int/emergencies/mers-cov/en/ https://www.who.int/emergencies/mers-cov/en/
- seppel 7y agoIf this is true, then things like FlattenTheCurve are the wrong approach. We would need StopThatShit asap.
- arcticbull 7y ago> if this is true No evidence at all yet. > then things like FlattenTheCurve are the wrong approach... #FlattenTheCurve is an acquiescence that everyone's going to get it, they just want to slow it down. > We would need StopThatShit asap. If that were possible at this point that would be plan of record, it's not.
- imgabe 7y agoDo we know for sure that people are immune after getting it once? A lot of the downplaying rests on that assumption but I haven't seen anything that says we know that's the case.
- ekanes 7y agoDo we know of any viruses that we don't develop immunity to? (I don't know either way). I'm guessing that if we've never encountered a virus like that, then the occasional person we've heard that "got it again" might be just a false positive, one of the two testing times.
- markdown 7y agoThey know for sure, but they don't know for sure how long the immunity lasts. For some people at least, it doesn't last very long.
- seppel 7y agoAnd the virus is mutating.
- arcticbull 7y ago[citation needed]. I'm not saying it can't I'm just saying it hasn't yet.
- baron_harkonnen 7y ago> if you've got some cash to invest in the markets and a long time horizon to draw on it, this may be the money making opportunity of a generation. If you think prices are dropping strictly because of covid-19 you're wildly misunderstanding the situation. If you buy now thinking it's low I am quite certain you will lose quite a lot of money. ~20% of the work force is unemployed or at reduced time right now. Goldman Sachs estimates we might see ~2 million people file for unemployment Monday. These are the most vulnerable parts of the population. They're going to lose health insurance, struggle to pay rent, struggle to eat... and we haven't even seen the pandemic warm up in the US yet. Next will be people at companies whose stock just completely crashed losing their jobs. It will take a month, but when shares drop companies must act by increasing share holder value, which will mean letting people go. All of this will have severe consequences for the national and global economy, consequences that will just start to be felt once people stop being sick. If this thing magically disappeared tonight you would probably still see a few of your favorite local restaurants disappear forever. And again, this is literally just the beginning. This isn't happening just because of an unfortunate natural disaster but because the US (and many other countries) have systematic vulnerabilities that make them unable to deal with a situation like this. The world after covid-19 dies down will be wildly different than today. This could very well be the end of US hegemony as we see countries like China, that can deal with these problems, start to rise to become the new global super power. The best case is looking bad and the worst case is unimaginable. The idea that you can simply "buy at the bottom" and make it rich very wrong.
- arcticbull 7y agoDepends, as always, on how much your worst case is priced in. Over the last month or two, Lyft is down 70%. The company is not intrinsically worth 70% less than it was the Friday before last. Does that mean it's a good company? Who knows, maybe not. Can it fall more? Sure. Does it have a big cash position to weather this storm? Yeah I mean it's got $3.3B-ish on hand and doesn't have to pay drivers when nobody's taking rides because they're contractors. Just like Uber [1] and their $6B bank account [2]. And Square with their $2B bank account [3]. At this point Square is trading at 7X cash on hand. UBER at 6X cash on hand. That makes them better capitalized than your Wells Fargo savings account with a fractional reserve rate of 10:1. Plenty of very solid companies are now trading at 30% of what they were a month ago with massive warchests. To say that hasn't priced in a few quarters of negative growth is a bit of a stretch isn't it? As for indices, well, not all companies stand to get burnt by this downturn. Have you seen the lines at Target and Walmart? As some S&P components go down others go up. That's the raison d'etre of ETFs. Plenty of companies do well as others do poorly. > The idea that you can simply "buy at the bottom" and make it rich very wrong. Of course picking the bottom is the hard part but even if you're off by a bit on either side, with a sufficient time horizon, these prices are mouth-watering. Or should I just wait and buy at the next top? ;) I'd argue the idea that you can wait for it to recover before investing in hopes you become rich to be very wrong. [1] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/uber-gets-an-upgrade-at-wells-fargo-on-post-coronavirus-growth-potential-2020-03-20 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/uber-gets-an-upgrade-at-we... [2] https://www.pymnts.com/news/ridesharing/2020/uber-sees-cash-position-as-downturn-defense/ https://www.pymnts.com/news/ridesharing/2020/uber-sees-cash-...