3 ms·
> We can all wish for the culture, test availability, and competent government that South Korea and Singapore and Taiwan apparently have, but we don’t have thos
by baybal2 7y ago
> We can all wish for the culture, test availability, and competent government that South Korea and Singapore and Taiwan apparently have, but we don’t have those. So their “plan” is effectively a plan to just let millions of people 60+ or with pre-existing conditions die without much effort to save them. It’s not only unconscionable, it’s incredibly stupid.
Why we had to wait until a crisis like this for this to be rendered bare for the wider population?
As I've said countless times before, the West has been on the downward trajectory for a very long time, both as a society, and as state entities.
What I call an "ultrapopulism" has been an ever growing trend in the West since around mid-nineties.
The Western nations are not just weak as societies, and nations, they are diseased (sorry for having to use this word now.)
The reasons for me moving from comfy life in the West to China is not because I so much enjoyed it, but for me having a realisation that this accelerating downward trend will have very real consequences in my lifetime, and that even money alone no longer favours the West.
- OCASM 7y agoWell, lets not forget that this whole mess started in China. It was the chinese government which decided to hide information and pretend everything was under control while allowing it to spread all over the world.
- joubert 7y agoTrump COVID-19 timeline: https://www.politifact.com/article/2020/mar/20/how-donald-trump-responded-coronavirus-pandemic/ https://www.politifact.com/article/2020/mar/20/how-donald-tr... Elon Musk COVID-19 timeline: https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/3/19/21185417/elon-musk-coronavirus-tweets-panic-ventilators-chloroquine-tesla-factory https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/3/19/21185417/elon-musk-coro... Both reckless, uniformed, self-absorbed in their arrogance.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into flamewar.
- joubert 7y agoApologies; my thinking was: * demonstrate failure by business and political leadership in the US to be science-based, humanitarian * counter the emerging anti-Asian sentiment Agree that my last statement could have been more productive.
- baybal2 7y ago> Well, lets not forget that this whole mess started in China. Yes, China is a patently dysfunctional society. This is what I can say as person whose life and career depends on it, and who actually lived there. I'd say the "good" performance of Chinese state looks like that only in comparison to catastrophically bad showing from Western nations. 20 year ago, I would've said that what China did after the monumental screw up at the start, would've been an expected level of response from an upstanding Western nation. Now, the West can not do the same what it could've done 20 years ago easily. That's the only message for that particular point. Is Chinese society a healthy, functioning society? No, but at least critical parts are still coasting on inertia from the time China had half sane political leadership. Is the West a healthy, functioning society? Some things there work, but the most important, critical parts are failing in broad daylight, and people don't damn care.
- OCASM 7y agoThe response to this from the western world has indeed been disgraceful. China's was too. They managed to contain due to their authoritarian policies but the real examples of good responses from asian nations are SK, Japan, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan. They've managed to contain it much better than anyone else without the need of massive government overreach.
- baybal2 7y agoThis crisis was a very good slap to the face to Chinese establishment. It was very much needed for a long time. I heard even most hardcore communists starting to question Xi's mandate to rule now, and how much such a weak leader is costing them. What I heard myself was pretty much a question "What if it was a war?" Were Xi to hide in a bunker when the military can't do anything without his explicit approval, they would've been screwed.