4 ms·
OK, so... how does that explain Taiwan or Korea, who had the same "living memory" we do and managed to get this under control without breaking their health care
by ajross 7y ago
OK, so... how does that explain Taiwan or Korea, who had the same "living memory" we do and managed to get this under control without breaking their health care systems?
I mean, your point is true, but the lack of action wasn't the fault of the average citizen or their living memory. The decision-makers should have had access to better info, and of course they did. Doctors from China and Italy told us long ago that PPE equipment was a bottleneck. Epidemiologists could see what was going to happen with the rate of spread. Local health officials in states knew at the outset that they needed more tests. Hell, the federal government has a whole departmental center dedicated specifically to the control of disease; they've spent decades modeling out how to respond to crises like this.
Yet... no decisions got made. That wasn't for a lack of "living memory of a pandemic".
- toasterlovin 7y agoTaiwan is ethnically Han, has lots of ties to mainland China, and is an island just if the Chinese coast. Korea is a peninsula attached to mainland China. They both had to deal with and care about SARS in a way that the west did not.
- klipt 7y ago> Taiwan or Korea, who had the same "living memory" we do They faced SARS, which never took off in the West.
- icedata 7y agoThere were 44 deaths in Canada https://globalnews.ca/news/6458609/looking-back-toronto-sars-outbreak/ https://globalnews.ca/news/6458609/looking-back-toronto-sars...
- throw0101a 7y agoAn interview with a team in Ontario, Canada that dealt with SARS, including the Minister of Health (Clement) at the time: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OPOkpIc2Z7U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OPOkpIc2Z7U
- tathougies 7y agoSo basically none. Not trying to be dismissive but this is going to kill way more than 44 in canada. Likely 100s if not thousands. Completely different order of magnitude.
- runawaybottle 7y agoAlso they are sitting near adjacent to the original epicenter. It was more real to them along with the previous outbreaks.
- baybal2 7y agoI would like to ask people to not to attach "Asianness" to having a working government. Even back just 2 decades ago, in every Asian country, a typical saying would've been "When will we live like in America?" The West was the envy of the world in its best years, and it can be again. If you can fix your societal problems, you will be, if you can not, you will not.
- jacquesm 7y agoThis is one of those uncomfortable truths that require introspection to be resolved and that's in very short supply.
- solidsnack9000 7y agoWestern commenters often see the strengths of Asian countries as stemming from their governments, but much of what goes well in Asia has to do with civil society.
- bnjms 7y agoI think much of what went well in America had much to do with civil society. I believe we collectively figured out there’s likely no god and mistakenly assumed everything that went along with the whole community & church system was to be thrown out. Not sure what to do about it because I think the weekly meetings with recognizable families was important but the Olstein style self help pastors isn’t.
- gindely 7y agoSport was originally a form of discipline and training - not just of the body, but also to be a good loser and a good winner. I think we need to abandon, for the most part, spectator sport, and create a social norm where people actually physically meet up weekly to play the sport of their choice at an incredibly amateur level. Imagine if every Sunday almost everyone in your community turned up to play - some people playing chess, some people playing football, some people swimming. Whatever their mind is interested in and their body can cope with. This would be completely different than the current system of sport, where those who want to do it fit it into their weekly schedule at a suitable time. One person goes to yoga on Thursday afternoon in an office building, another person rides their bike on Tuesday morning, a team meets to play netball on Wednesday. The would, of course, be permitted to do whatever they want. But there would also be an expectation. Unfortunately I don't know how to get there from here - for the time being, there's no support of anything amateur. We're basically told to be a pro or go home. Not just sport, anything and everything.
- nrp 7y agoOther commenters mentioned SARS, but specifically for Korea, they faced a MERS outbreak in 2015 that resulted in deliberate policy changes that made their response to COVID-19 rapid and effective.