2 ms·
You're asking society to solve two problems: 1. Convince people that a certain action is morally wrong 2. Once 1 is accomplished, convince those same people n
by ryandrake 7y ago
You're asking society to solve two problems:
1. Convince people that a certain action is morally wrong
2. Once 1 is accomplished, convince those same people not to do the action
We typically use law and consistent enforcement to solve these problems, because it's basically impossible otherwise.
What do you expect this would look like in reality, without laws and fines? Someone is seen buying 50 cases of toilet paper and loading into their truck. His friends or family, or a bunch of strangers at the supermarket, then shame him, telling him what he's doing is wrong. Then, he sees the error in his ways and decides to return the items? There's no way that this is a workable, scalable solution given the culture in the USA.
Generalization time: 1. People here are timid and avoid confrontation, and tend to not call others out on bad behavior, particularly family members. 2. Even if you do confront them, it is extremely difficult to convince people that what they feel justified in doing is actually wrong. 3. Even if you've convinced them that they're wrong, people don't respond to shame (either public shaming or private).
What people do respond to is consistent incentives and consequences. If there's a good chance you'll lose money or go to jail for doing something, then people will think twice before trying it.