4 ms·
Does the UK also have price gouging laws in this crisis? Those are what produce the empty shelves.
by BurningFrog 7y ago
Does the UK also have price gouging laws in this crisis?
Those are what produce the empty shelves.
- smnrchrds 7y agoDo you have any evidence for this? I don't meant referring to economics textbooks. I mean concrete evidence that empty shelves right now due to this epidemic are the results of price gouging laws. For example, showing that states with price gouging laws have empty shelves and states without do not, when controlling for other factors.
- megous 7y agoYou can't control for other factors in an economy. Every economic textbook will have a demand and supply graph, it's not hard to see what happens when you fix a price arbitrarily and shift the demand curve in that graph to simulate a higher demand. Demand and supply no longer meet -> shortage.
- BurningFrog 7y ago> I don't meant referring to economics textbooks. If you don't allow referring to the vast empirical literature on price controls, you've already decided what you want to believe.
- smnrchrds 7y agoFlu can cause fever. Every fever is not caused by flu. Every flu does not cause fever. I am like a patient asking the doctor is they have evidence this fever is caused by flu, not for example COVID-19. I wouldn't want to be referred to medical textbooks telling flu causes fever as your only evidence.
- epistasis 7y agoEconomics textbooks takes on price controls are very different from price gouging controls, as they operate on different time scales. Price gouging controls are much more likely to prevent shortages than cause them, as they prevent market manipulation, which is another topic that economics textbooks have some good takes on.
- ForHackernews 7y agoyeah, much better to have £100/dozen eggs. That way, at least they'll be on the shelves so rich people can still have them.
- Consultant32452 7y agoI saw one ad for hand sanitizer where 1 bottle was regular price, 2 bottles was 100x price. I support that kind of "price gouging."
- BurningFrog 7y agoMarket prices keep items on the shelf, and also incentivizes increased production, and redirecting supplies to where demand is highest. Price fixing incentivizes hoarding and empty shelves.
- _jal 7y ago> redirecting supplies to where demand is highest Which is what the gp said. > they'll be on the shelves so rich people can still have them Complaining about word choice is a tradition around here, I know.
- gridlockd 7y ago> Which is what the gp said. They didn't say that at all, they said something completely different, thereby proving that they don't understand the point. Not raising prices at all evidently leads to empty shelves. Nobody can buy any eggs, except for the first lucky person that can get all the eggs at a bargain and then waste them without significant financial loss. In the case of toilet paper, there isn't even a loss - you were going to buy it anyway. As prices rise, demand goes down. The hoarders buy less, or at least pay handsomely for the privilege, which is more fair. Nobody will raise prices until there is no demand whatsoever ($100 eggs), just for the sake of stocked shelves. This system works strictly better, it's just that people don't understand it. That's why supermarkets don't raise prices. They can blame empty shelves on "a few idiots" (who aren't really idiots) and avoid complaints for price gouging, which could cause severe regulatory fallout.
- captainbland 7y agoPrice gouging seems like a good way to incentivise the five-finger discount if anything.