3 ms·
Interestingly, one thing all these GUIs have in common is that buttons still look like buttons...
by userbinator 7y ago
Interestingly, one thing all these GUIs have in common is that buttons still look like buttons...
- Jaruzel 7y ago> buttons still look like buttons Ahh I miss those days. Why were raised buttons considered so offensive? Now we have to tap/click everywhere in the hope that something might happen.
- WWLink 7y agoNot sure. I thought raised buttons rock!
- Lio 7y agoRaised buttons fit better with the "affordance, visibility and feedback" paradigm. I'm used to flat UI now but I liked the ideas behind the 3D buttons. I guess one reason to go flat is that almost everything in a web page is now clickable so having it all 3D gets a bit "noisy". 3D is better for people that have never used a computer but I guess we're all trained to use GUIs and no one can remember the time before that any more.
- ferzul 7y ago> I guess one reason to go flat is that almost everything in a web page is now clickable so having it all 3D gets a bit "noisy". that isn't true tho. how many things in this hn comment page are clickable? certainly not your comment. and even when they are clickable how can i tell which are part of the same link and which are separate? (e.g. is your name and the date following one link or two? or only part is a link?)
- quietbritishjim 7y agoEven in a comment with no links there are at least 5 clickable elements: * Upvote button (and downvote if you have enough rep) * User name to take you to their profile page * Time, which zooms to the comment * [-] to collapse it (the square brackets here actually seem to be trying to simulate something a bit button-like) * Reply at the bottom Granted these are around the edge of the comment, but five separate buttons is potentially quite a bit of clutter. Also (now I'm digressing a bit...), most don't satisfy the convention from that era that the text on a button should be fixed while all variable "content" goes in edit boxes (and combo boxes etc.). "Reply" satisfies that but the user name, for example doesn't; in the older convention it would be split as User: [ferzul________] [ Show user page ]