3 ms·

On the other hand, this is quite sensitive data, which is why a respected nonprofit organization would be much more trustworthy, and which is why I understand t

On the other hand, this is quite sensitive data, which is why a respected nonprofit organization would be much more trustworthy, and which is why I understand the decision of the referees.

jacquesm 7y ago
People install apps voluntarily, they should be able to make these sort of decisions for themselves. It's one thing to protect users from malware, quite another to treat them like legal incompetents.
- decebalus1 7y ago
  Just like they made the decisions for themselves when faced with the Cambridge Analytica quizes, right? Regulations are there for a reason.
  - DoreenMichele 7y ago
    You know, my HIPAA training is out of date and it's possible that new legislation applies. One of the more aggravating parts of my insurance job was dealing with people who thought I wanted them to sign an authorization because the insurance company was a meanie face trying to screw them out of their money and I would explain "No, ma'am, we need this to comply with federal law. Please and thank you." and they would be all chagrined and get me the auth, at long last. But I only see App Store guidelines cited, not federal legislation. So the odds are good that someone in the company has the power to overrule that. Given the circumstances, it seems to me this would be an appropriate time for an executive to say "Yea, verily, fuck them there guidelines. Let this person do this thing." And if they don't want to or can't do that, it would be a good time for someone to hand walk it through the process and get it hooked up post haste with whatever doohickey would make everyone all happy.
  - graeme 7y ago
    It’s a crisis. This kind of thinking is what led the FDA to delay coronavirus testing authorization in the US by a couple months. Any set of regulations needs a crisis mode.
- bestnameever 7y ago
  There is nothing wrong with Apple having some standards for the app store.
DoreenMichele 7y ago
I have had HIPAA training. TLDR: "Certain other people, like doctors and insurance companies, need to comply with strict rules surrounding your privacy when handling your health data. You, on the other hand, can do any fucking thing you want with your personal health data. Sign here in triplicate to assign this right to others. Have a nice day." (I might be making up the triplicate thing for dramatic effect. It might only be duplicate. shrug)

On the other hand, this is quite sensitive data, which is why a respected nonprofit organization would be much more trustworthy, and which is why I understand the decision of the referees.

jacquesm 7y ago

People install apps voluntarily, they should be able to make these sort of decisions for themselves. It's one thing to protect users from malware, quite another to treat them like legal incompetents.

decebalus1 7y ago
Just like they made the decisions for themselves when faced with the Cambridge Analytica quizes, right? Regulations are there for a reason.
- DoreenMichele 7y ago
  You know, my HIPAA training is out of date and it's possible that new legislation applies. One of the more aggravating parts of my insurance job was dealing with people who thought I wanted them to sign an authorization because the insurance company was a meanie face trying to screw them out of their money and I would explain "No, ma'am, we need this to comply with federal law. Please and thank you." and they would be all chagrined and get me the auth, at long last. But I only see App Store guidelines cited, not federal legislation. So the odds are good that someone in the company has the power to overrule that. Given the circumstances, it seems to me this would be an appropriate time for an executive to say "Yea, verily, fuck them there guidelines. Let this person do this thing." And if they don't want to or can't do that, it would be a good time for someone to hand walk it through the process and get it hooked up post haste with whatever doohickey would make everyone all happy.
- graeme 7y ago
  It’s a crisis. This kind of thinking is what led the FDA to delay coronavirus testing authorization in the US by a couple months. Any set of regulations needs a crisis mode.
bestnameever 7y ago
There is nothing wrong with Apple having some standards for the app store.

DoreenMichele 7y ago

I have had HIPAA training. TLDR: "Certain other people, like doctors and insurance companies, need to comply with strict rules surrounding your privacy when handling your health data. You, on the other hand, can do any fucking thing you want with your personal health data. Sign here in triplicate to assign this right to others. Have a nice day." (I might be making up the triplicate thing for dramatic effect. It might only be duplicate. shrug)