5 ms·
I've never understood this fetish with discarded body parts. In the US, after you've used a cadaver or cadaver part for research you're supposed to return it t
by gumby 7y ago
I've never understood this fetish with discarded body parts. In the US, after you've used a cadaver or cadaver part for research you're supposed to return it to the family. How absurd! And that's even before the modern fetish with "IP value" and residuals.
These kinds of rules (and many others) make it very difficult for small pharma and other medical startups to get human anatomical specimens for product development. I know this from experience.
I really couldn't care less what is done with my non-functional corpse once I'm gone.
PS: In the US the collagen that gets injected into lips to puff them up all comes from a single cell line harvested from a discarded foreskin sliced off about 20 odd years ago. No residual "rights" there -- Allergan gets to keep all the money.
- armada651 7y agoThe family may want to organize a closed casket burial or a cremation ceremony. Is it so absurd that they would want the body for that? As the article states the emotional grief over losing a limb may be on the same level as losing a spouse for amputees. I wouldn't say it's absurd that someone would want to keep the ashes in that case.
- lonelappde 7y agoWhat do you need a body for a closed casket?
- t0astbread 7y agoWell, death is a large constant for humans so it's understandable that we're gonna have a lot of feelings about it. And there's this general understanding that at least some human emotions are more important than economic interests. Addendum: I'm kinda shocked though. Is this a widespread sentiment towards ethics and individual rights in the pharma industry? If so then I'd say that skepticism is pretty justified.
- gumby 7y ago> Is this a widespread sentiment towards ethics and individual rights in the pharma industry? If so then I'd say that skepticism is pretty justified I don’t understand what “this” refers to, or which skepticism.
- lonelappde 7y ago"this" is the flagrant disregard for mellenia-old deeply held human values about life and death. "Skepticism" is distrust of the pharma industry who sees humanity merely as a source of money to extract.
- gumby 7y agoThere is of course a cohort in Pharma who tries to game the system, sure, but by and large people seem to be into the whole "saving people" mission and care about IRBs and the like. Not at all like like it is portrayed in the press or movies. "flagrant disregard" seems a bit much. I never suggested that such rules should be flouted nor that they are. I was specifically saying I don't understand it. Sure I have relatives who won't eat meat on religious grounds and know why they think so but the worship of an inert piece of meat makes zero sense to me. As far as my dead friends and relatives go: the memories, good and bad, are how they live on for me; but the flesh, meh. Dispose of properly on hygienic grounds is all that matters as far as I'm concerned. It's not the person. It's especially unfair if the person donated their body: if you believe that they have some right to its fate that donation should be their business and not that of the survivors.
- 7y ago
- koolba 7y ago> PS: In the US the collagen that gets injected into lips to puff them up all comes from a single cell line harvested from a discarded foreskin sliced off about 20 odd years ago. No residual "rights" there -- Allergan gets to keep all the money. Wtf? Is there more info on this?
- gumby 7y agoIt's in Allergan's filings on the FDA web site (warning: they ahve a lot of products). Figure out when it was introduced, start around then and work backwards. Back when I learned about htis the boy would have been about 14 years old which was even funnier.
- at_a_remove 7y agoYou could not care less, but evidently other people differ in that regard. Is it difficult to understand and respect that? Just from a practical viewpoint, "gimme the parts, you ain't usin' 'em!" is not going to win you a lot of adherents.
- Someone 7y ago”I really couldn't care less what is done with my non-functional corpse once I'm gone.” This article isn’t about that case; it’s about what is done with amputated limbs of still living persons.
- gumby 7y agoI know, this just made me think of the parallel issue
- sushid 7y agoBut the article specifically mentions those that care about how their limbs are disposed of? You’re drawing a parallel where there’s none to be had. It seems like impersonal limb disposal mentally affects some amputees and it seems like a reasonable concern that could and should be addressed.