3 ms·
There were stories earlier about Alexa employees and contractors hearing all kinds of unintended conversations. https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-tn-amazo
by fulafel 7y ago
There were stories earlier about Alexa employees and contractors hearing all kinds of unintended conversations.
https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-tn-amazon-alexa-echo-privacy-listening-20190411-story.html https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-tn-amazon-alexa-echo-...
- masklinn 7y agoIt should be noted that the device is not intended to record conversations absent the trigger word, however there can be false positives: > According to Amazon’s website, no audio is stored unless Echo detects the wake word or is activated by pressing a button. But sometimes Alexa appears to begin recording without any prompt at all, and the audio files start with a blaring television or unintelligible noise.
- fulafel 7y agoWell, from a suspicious mindset that could be more or less sincere...
- MereInterest 7y agoIt doesn't even matter how sincere they are. False negatives hurt the perception of the product, because then people need to repeat the key word. False positives do not hurt the perception of the product, because the recording occurs silently. Their incentives are aligned against privacy, and so privacy will suffer.
- vidarh 7y agoFalse positives does hurt the perception, because the device will usually do something or utter a response unless it fails to detect something intelligible or writes the request off as not intended for it (having two devices at opposite ends of a large open space living area can sometimes get frustrating, but looking at the history, you see how often they correctly determine which device should respond) An occasional false positive is funny, but it gets old pretty quickly.
- jackpirate 7y agoThat's not true. Amazon can have a significantly more accurate classifier running on their backend that processes the transmitted audio. And this classifier can be more accurate due to both more computation and it would have access to the entire data stream, not just the initialization words. You would never know that your data was sent to Amazon and then ignored.
- vidarh 7y agoThey can, and they do. You can see that in your history because you can listen to the audio of things it decided subsequently was not intended for it. But unless you have multiple devices, those make up a relatively small proportion of requests, and hence most of the time false positives is something they have a strong incentive to stop because it causes negative user experiences. [If you have multiple devices it will happen "all the time" when a request is genuinely meant for a Alexa device but more than one device hears the request, but then it has no UI effect - one device will usually answer, and the other(s) will stand down; this is by no means perfect, but it works reasonably well]
- masklinn 7y agoObviously, any device which is mic'd and connected is a risk. And devices like the echo or whatever google and apple sell have a permanent hot mic' since they keep trying to match the keyword so a "live" indicator would be of very limited use. Unless the trigger-matching was performed by some sort of tamper-resistant secure module which would also trigger the indicator and not feed any data to the rest of the system, but then you'd have to trust that that is properly implemented as well. I guess a suspicious mind could be able to check that by looking whether there is traffic between the device and the cloud servers. And the paranoid mind (who wasn't paranoid enough to not have such a device, oddly enough) could only allow the device 'net access when desiring to use its capabilities (though obviously there's no guarantee said device wouldn't have been buffering hours of conversation while offline).
- Yhippa 7y agoWhat's funny is nowadays Alexa or Google Assistant will fail to wake when called but tend to trigger randomly during conversations.
- sib 7y agoKind of like sometimes you fail to hear when someone calls your name and other times you think someone was speaking to you when they weren't? It's not like people are perfect at doing this task either.