6 ms·
I find the title biased against Amazon to begin with. As if having assistants from other companies listening in was any safer. Why namedrop Amazon's own?
by snvzz 7y ago
I find the title biased against Amazon to begin with.
As if having assistants from other companies listening in was any safer. Why namedrop Amazon's own?
- throwaway122378 7y agoAlexa has been caught numerous times in the past
- snvzz 7y agoAt least they were transparent about having a mic that's always listening. Google sneaked a microphone in some speaker device trojan-horse style, enabling it only when lots of such speakers were already deployed. Sneaky.
- throwaway122378 7y agoAgreed Google’s is as much to blame. But listening to you and being kind enough to tell us doesn’t make Amazon innocent
- snvzz 7y agoIt doesn't. They're just not the only evil ones, and thus I find it's wrong to use such a title. Either call them all out or none. "Always-listening voice assistant" would have worked well in place of Alexa.
- jrockway 7y agoThey mention Google in the first sentence. I think it's important to not overly freak out about these home assistants. Your phone company or video conferencing company is already listening to your confidential client calls. Your email provider is reading your email. Your internal applications run on Amazon's servers. Your upstairs neighbor has their ear to the floor. I think lawyers are used to thinking "as long as it's not in writing, we're okay", but with speech recognition getting better and better, your phone calls / VCs are going to show up in court someday.
- take_a_breath 7y agoYour phone or video conference company is providing the platform that allows you to have the conversation in the first place. Same with your email provider, same with applications running on the cloud. Those are the infrastructure We pay monthly to support business and communication. If my neighbor was listening to my conversations AND running the third largest ad platform on the internet, it would alarm me. These aren’t apples-to-apples comparisons.
- jrockway 7y agoI think in all cases the service provider has a pretty strong incentive to not violate your trust. You'll cancel your Zoom subscription if they start feeding your meetings to the person that sues. You'll stop buying from Amazon if Alexa starts feeding your meetings to the entity you're engaged in litigation with. In both cases, the incentive exists to keep your confidential meetings confidential. But, incentives are not crypto. There is probably nothing nefarious going on, but if you use open-source software with strong cryptography, a service provider that wants to be nefarious is simply unable to do so. That is what lawyers should be aiming for; freaking out about Alexa is a feel-good stopgap at best.
- take_a_breath 7y agoIs this really an example of “freaking out”? ==“Perhaps we’re being slightly paranoid but we need to have a lot of trust in these organizations and these devices,” Hancock said. “We’d rather not take those risks.”== Seems like a pretty reasonable measure and advice. The baseline assumption you make is that you know the who, what, where and when of Amazon sharing data. Does Amazon actually have an incentive not to violate your trust? You could make the same argument about Facebook and they have routinely violated users trust. It seems the real lesson is that without legal protection for consumers, companies will continue operating in the gray area.
- mtsr 7y agoIt wasn’t always the case that teleconferencing providers could listen in. At least Skype was peer-to-peer originally. And only corporate firewalls and some bad providers would prevent it from working today. My email provider surely isn’t reading my mail, but then again, I seem to be in a minority that doesn’t use gmail. The threat of real-time speech-to-text is real, but police all over the world have made the mistake of spying on lawyers now and then.
- S_A_P 7y agoThe snarky answer is that Jeff Bezos looks like he is morphing into a Bond villain. The correct answer is that yep you should consider what is in the room if you need a private conversation because devices are listening. The title is also incredibly niche and alarmist. Only locked down lawyers need to worry about Alexa??