6 ms·
But how much of the US’s growth is due to us finally having some (albeit not enough) testing?
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
But how much of the US’s growth is due to us finally having some (albeit not enough) testing?
- throwaway_pdp09 7y agoGood question, I don't know. If it helps, a quick search got this https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/testing-in-us.html?CDC_AA_refVal=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cdc.gov%2Fcoronavirus%2F2019-ncov%2Ftesting-in-us.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/test... See table at bottom.
- tyingq 7y agoThat's a very good point, and the lack of tests had a secondary effect. Nobody here took it very seriously at first, because the numbers were very low.
- simonh 7y agoThis is key. We really can't compare countries confirmed case numbers directly because they are operating very different testing programmes. Just look at Germany. More confirmed cases than the USA, but a quarter of the deaths. Germany also has 80% as many cases as Spain, but about 5% as many deaths. All that, without a severe lockdown. Clearly something completely different is going on there than in many other countries, and it seems they have an extremely effective and well organised testing system. They're testing about 160,000 people a week. In comparison, the UK to date has only tested around 50,000 people in total so no wonder our case numbers are far lower, even though we have double the number of deaths. So Germany is an outlier, but it just goes to show even for other countries you can't just compare the curves and draw any definitive conclusions without also looking at the testing regime. This is where the experts with their detailed population models and simulation tools come in.
- hallohallohallo 7y agoIt is the health care system like number of ICUs, training of doctors and stuff like not being able to get antibiotics simply over the counter like in Italy. If my memory serves me right e.g. in Italy 29% have a resistance to antibiotics, in Germany only 0.4%.
- simonh 7y agoPeople don't become resistant to antibiotics, bacteria do and resistant bacteria in Italy would just spread to Germany. Anyway Covid-19 is a virus, not a bacterium.
- guiriduro 7y agoWhile its true SARS-CoV-2 is a virus, opportunistic bacterial pneumonia is a secondary complication of Covid19 which increases its lethality. So you need decent antibiotics too.
- radicalbyte 7y ago..and it's nasty, my wife only just recovered from it a week ago after a total of 8 weeks in bed.
- vinniejames 7y agoWe could possibly clean up the numbers, assuming the death rate is predictable across regions. Take numbers from a region where testing is frequent, say the death rate is 2%. Then scale the numbers in a region with lack of testing to match the 2% death rate. Not perfect, as there are external factors like hospital capacity/quality and existing population health. However, it should give a closer approximation of total cases where politicians fail to provide adequate testing.
- qaq 7y agoWell unfortunately US has much higher rate of obesity, diabetes and other factors that will increase mortality so would be pretty hard.
- vinniejames 7y agoChina has a much higher rate of smokers, poor air quality, and existing respiratory disease. Do you have any statistics pointing to obesity as an increased risk factor for a respritory disease?
- qaq 7y agoHigh Blood pressure was a big factor from what I read. There is very strong correlation between obesity and hypertension.
- fragmede 7y agoEach country has it's own date for when "testing came online", and it seems like starting from then might make things more comparable, despite differences in testing capacity and strategy. Another approach might be to on start looking at the data after the number of cases is > 100.
- kire2345 7y agoI think what is going on is a combination of relatively good testing capacity from the beginning and mostly young people infected, which due to the testing were prevented from spreading it to older demographics. See https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/478220a4c454480e823b17327b2bf1d4 https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/478220a4c454480e823... Also there is the purely anecdotal hypothesis of a cultural difference between for example Italy, Spain and Germany. In the southern countries it seems like older people have quite an active social life compared to Germany.
- sveme 7y agoThere are also far more old people living with young people in Italy and Spain than in Germany.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rasz 7y agoStop repeating German propaganda :( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0M4kbPDHGR0&feature=youtu.be&t=1177 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0M4kbPDHGR0&feature=youtu.be... turn on google auto translate TLDR: Any comorbidities present at the time of death are reported as the main culprit. In other news https://www.thelancet.com/action/showPdf?pii=S0140-6736(20)30566-3 https://www.thelancet.com/action/showPdf?pii=S0140-6736(20)3... Table 2: Treatments and outcomes. Sepsis 100%, Respiratory failure 98%. There you go, nobody dies from the virus alone, problem solved, 20x less deaths than comparable Spain.
- detaro 7y agoThen why are basically all Corona deaths in Germany reported as having other illnesses too? If this claim were true, none of these deaths of sick old people would have been reported as being due to Corona. Do you have any evidence this is more than speculation (at least the english translation also makes it sound like it is worded speculation, not a claim of fact), and that someone who was known to be infected and died was not reported? I keep asking people about this because I'd for sure would like to know if it were happening, but the only two sources I've seen sounded like speculation by Italian officials that at least as absolute as it is reported in other languages does not match the actual reporting here as far as I can tell.
- emmelaich 7y agoRelated, there's also the distinct possibility that many had Covid-19 well before it was in public consciousness. Look for ILI (Influenza-like Illness) stats which were appreciably higher in January. The obvious inference is that many had Covid-19 before it was recognised as such. This might be a good thing.
- simonh 7y agoIf that were true, we should see a much higher proportion of tested people showing positive. Also we shouldn't see the proportion of people tested being positive shooting up, but we do. Those ILI stats were probably just Flu.
- mrfusion 7y agoI believe that most of the current testing only shows active infections?
- simonh 7y agoYes, and it has shown initially small numbers of active infections, growing rapidly, as a proportion of those tested. If the virus was already widely distributed, we would expect it to be much closer to equilibrium.
- nemo44x 7y agoI think this is underrated. This thing must have been spreading since November here. I know a person who back in January acquired something like pneumonia and a bad fever, went to the hospital for awhile and tests were negative for flu, etc. doctors just didn’t know what it was. The person has COPD however. But anecdotally I’ve noticed quite a few more colleagues over the last few months out sick “with the flu or something”. No idea. They’re still only testing people with symptoms. We need a randomizes test and a test for antibodies to have any idea how much it has already spread. If it’s as contagious as they say and spreads in asymptotic people then why wouldn’t there be a significant population that has acquired and recovered from this? Many probably with very mild symptoms. I could just be in denial right now as well.
- xienze 7y agoYeah I’m not sure what people are expecting to happen here. This virus has been circulating in the US for months and testing was limited. There’s surely many multiples of infected people than currently reported, and that’s true for any country that isn’t doing blanket testing of entire population.
- mynegation 7y agoEven if that (EDIT: ‘that’ being an idea that virus has been circulating for months) were true (which almost certainly it is not), so what? The only logical explanation for this is that percentage of severe cases relative to totally susceptible and infected is orders of magnitude lower, and now the total number of infected is so large that number of severe cases is starting to get noticeable. But that is not the picture we are getting from South Korea that had much more comprehensive testinG.
- xienze 7y ago> Even if that were true (which almost certainly it is not) What are you referring to? You don’t think the virus is already much more widespread in the US than currently reported numbers? I’m just making the observation that perhaps the large increases in US cases are more indicative of confirmation of already existing cases rather than necessarily being _new_ cases.
- mynegation 7y agoI am not arguing that virus is more widespread than the reported numbers, that much is obvious. I was replying to the idea that virus has been circulating “for months” undetected. With a doubling time of 5 days or so, with “for months” circulation we would be in a totally different territory right now.
- xienze 7y ago> I was replying to the idea that virus has been circulating “for months” undetected. I don’t think that’s crazy at all. We had our first case sometime in January, and only until very very recently have we had any significant travel restrictions. It’s very contagious and for a significant number of people there are no real symptoms, or if there are, nothing life threatening. I don’t think it’s crazy at all that it’s been working it’s way around the US population for months. Maybe to put it another way, if we could instantly test al 300+M Americans right this instant, would you be surprised if say 20M or so tested positive or had had it?