3 ms·
Perhaps your analogy with city buildings is unfortunate, given that only a few places in the world actually do have a regular, grid-like system for identifying
by Silhouette 16y ago
Perhaps your analogy with city buildings is unfortunate, given that only a few places in the world actually do have a regular, grid-like system for identifying buildings. The rest of us manage OK with other street/building layouts, and have done for as long as there have been streets and buildings. It might not be quite as efficient, but somehow we manage not to get lost all the time, and it's certainly a lot more interesting than, say, typical US-style city blocks.
- sgdesign 16y agoThat was part of my point, in a way. I'm from Paris, which doesn't follow a US-style grid at all. We get by without a grid because we're used to it, but the city is probably harder to navigate for newcomers. So sure, you can have a great grid-less, Paris-style site. But it's much easier to get it right if you follow a grid-like NYC-style layout. And newcomers (which happen to be most visitors) will thank you for it.
- wdewind 16y agoActually I think his analogy with city buildings is perfect: One of the main things design does for people is make things inherently familiar to them. Apple is the canonical example: who reads the instruction manual for an ipod? NYC's grid system makes it easy to decode the city, much in the way that a layout's grid system makes it easy for the eyes to quickly decode and separate the information.