4 ms·
> Understanding and using a grid as well as the golden ratio are not tricks. If you think they are your just don't understand why designers, artists, photograph
by Silhouette 16y ago
> Understanding and using a grid as well as the golden ratio are not tricks. If you think they are your just don't understand why designers, artists, photographers, etc. use such techniques.
Perhaps, then, you would be kind enough to share the compelling arguments with the mere mortals among us? Apparently I don't understand either, and I've been exploring this field for about two decades now.
I could understand an argument that a lot of people find content areas that are a bit wider than they are high aesthetically pleasing. I'm not sure I've ever seen any serious data on the subject, but given where our two eyes sit in our heads, it's at least plausible. But why should that mean the width should be 1.618 times the height?
As another example, why should the left column in my two-column layout be 1.618 times the width of my right column (this being the last advice I remember seeing that involved using the golden ratio in design)?
Why not a 3:2 ratio in each case? Why not 16:9? Why not 1.414:1? At least the last one has some neat recursive properties, as anyone who works with A4 paper probably knows.
> On simple pages you may not benefit from a grid, but complex designs with tons of elements, and irregular blocks will always be easier to obtain more precise results with block placement and typography with a grid system.
What does that even mean? If I put a block at a certain place on a web page with CSS positioning, will it somehow not be where I wanted it if my styles aren't based on some regular grid system?
Why are "precise results" even desirable as a general rule? Some design styles suggest a formal, regular layout. Others do not.
- sgdesign 16y agoThis discussion is forcing me to reexamine the reason behind basic design principles, which is good! Precise results and grid-like structures are not inherently better than anything else. But the important point is that they're easier to get right. By "right", I mean, "supporting your site's message". If two blocks of texts are not aligned properly, people will notice it (even subconsciously). Does that misalignment help the message you want to convey through the site? Maybe it does, but in most cases it was just an oversight, and not a conscious decision on the part of the designer. (a counter-example: you want to promote a kid's toy, so you use misalignment to convey the idea of unstructured, chaotic fun). Same thing with the golden ration (which, by the way, I don't use myself). Maybe a 3:2 or 16:9 or whatever ratio will work better in some specific cases, but the golden ratio is generally considered pleasing to the eye, and is safer in most situations. Call it laziness, but I know that when I'm designing a new site, using a grid takes care of a lot of decisions for me. Sure it constrains the design. But in many cases, creativity is born out of contraint.
- Silhouette 16y agoI don't have a problem with the idea that some of these principles make useful rules of thumb, as long as it's understood that the goal is to make your site effective and any of the other stuff is just a means to that end. I do have a problem with defroost's position, which seems to be that using things like grids and golden ratios are somehow inherently "right" and if any of us don't agree then we just don't understand.
- sgdesign 16y agoI agree. For example Hipmunk's (http://himpunk.com http://himpunk.com) UI doesn't follow a conventional fixed grid, because it wouldn't make sense. As for defroost, I don't think that's what he meant, but I'll let him speak for himself.
- defroost 16y ago>I do have a problem with defroost's position, which seems to be that using things like grids and golden ratios are somehow inherently "right" and if any of us don't agree then we just don't understand. That's not my position, and again, I was responding to the guy above who called the OP's use of grids "rubbish". There is no right or wrong in design. Grids and golden ratios are just a couple of many techniques that web designers use. I'm not sure why you are arguing against such devices, because that's all they are. The are aids, compositional tools and saying they suck is a little like saying a hammer sucks for driving in nails.
- Silhouette 16y agoMy apologies if I misunderstood your position. From this more recent post, it sounds like we agree on the important points. I'm certainly not trying to "argue against" things like grids and ratios, just trying not to elevate them from rules of thumb that sometimes help to some sort of objectively superior choice.
- neutronicus 16y agoIf your left column is 1.618 times the width of the right column, the width of the two columns together is then 1.618 times the width of the left column. It means that you decrease the size of elements by the same ratio each time you go down a level of importance: e.g. title-bar / main-content == main-content / subsidiary-content Not sure why one would want to do that, but as a math guy I feel it's my duty to chime in.
- jamesbritt 16y ago"Not sure why one would want to do that, but as a math guy I feel it's my duty to chime in." It's sort of like trying to explain why one would use a I IV V chord progression, or why a major triad sounds good. There are interesting ratios in there, though few people are explicitly calculating them in their heads.
- defroost 16y ago> It's sort of like trying to explain why one would use a I IV V chord progression, or why a major triad sounds good. That's exactly the point. When people hear a chord progression or see a painting where the subject is placed according to certain rules of composition, it evokes a feeling of harmony. Conversely, a photograph with the subject bulls-eyed dead center feels motion-less. It's not wrong, but it can be less interesting, more stagnant.
- Silhouette 16y agoI'm a math guy too, so I appreciate the implications. Of course, those implications break as soon as your carefully proportioned columns start having margins/padding. :-)
- defroost 16y agoI don't have the energy now to debate the merits of grid based designs. I was just responding to the guy above who called the OP's use of grid "rubbish" and "tricks". No a grid is not right for every design. > Why not a 3:2 ratio in each case? Why not 16:9? Why not 1.414:1? At least the last one has some neat recursive properties, as anyone who works with A4 paper probably knows. The Golden Ratio goes back to the Ancient Greeks as they discovered that it appeared frequently in geometry, nature, etc. In classical composition, dividing a rectangle (canvas) in thirds vertically and horizontally, the "power points", that is, the place where a subject derives strong interest and "movement" exist at the intersections of these divisions. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_ratio http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_ratio has some good info. As I said, I'm too tired to debate you, but if you don't see the point in using a grid, by all means, don't use it. > What does that even mean? If I put a block at a certain place on a web page with CSS positioning, will it somehow not be where I wanted it if my styles aren't based on some regular grid system? Of course not. It is just a tool to help the designer, a guide. You still have to write just as many styles if not more. Grids are just tools that can help make your designs more consistent. A fantastic resource is here: http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2007/04/14/designing-with-grid-based-approach/ http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2007/04/14/designing-with-gr... > Why are "precise results" even desirable as a general rule? Some design styles suggest a formal, regular layout. Others do not. Now you're just being a contrarian. Of course nothing is a rule that cannot be broken, but unless you are doing a free, "avant garde" layout, you probably want some precision, some sense of form.