6 ms·
That's an antibody test, not an RNA test. Quite a different thing. It will only detect an infection when you have an immune response already. It will not if yo
by baybal2 7y ago
That's an antibody test, not an RNA test. Quite a different thing.
It will only detect an infection when you have an immune response already. It will not if you don't.
RNA tests can detect the virus even if it doesn't turn a person diseased.
- gopalv 7y ago> That's an antibody test, not an RNA test. Yes, this is an exposure test - which works okay for a completely novel virus like this one. The real question is whether this has a drop-off factor for immunity for instance (i.e non-infectious herd immune) or if it can differentiate between exposure and carrier for the disease. It might be useful right now, but it will get less useful as the months go by. For instance, the QuantiFeron test for TB tests me as positive because my white blood cells take TB very seriously (or so it looks like).
- whateveracct 7y agoSurely still important progress & a big deal though, right?
- lisper 7y agoThis will make it easier to tell if a symptomatic person has COVID or something else. But it won't help with early detection, which is what is most urgently needed.
- noelsusman 7y agoWe needed early detection weeks ago. That ship has sailed. At this point a test like this is probably more urgent. The lead time on getting tests for patients showing up to the hospital (i.e. they have symptoms) will make a massive difference in how much PPE the hospital goes through.
- dogma1138 7y agoEarly detection is utterly irrelevant at this point it’s endemic at most places now.
- gridlockd 7y agoExhaustive testing and selective isolation would be better than lockdowns, even if the virus is endemic. Testing is the bottleneck.
- dogma1138 7y agoTesting is a bottleneck which is why you need as many testing venues as possible including mail-in at home tests for the more rural areas. The US isn’t South Korea it’s population density is drastically different as well as its geographical scale which makes viral protein and RNA tests much harder to conduct. At this point social distancing and a multi phase testing plan will be required which will undoubtedly include field AB testing to reduce the load on testing facilities. AB testing also provides additional valuable data points including a more accurate infection figures since it can come out positive as long as the antibodies remain in your system.
- mantas 7y agoBig chance of getting false-positive. People will think they're clear and won't distance themselves from vulnerable. While they may be carriers.
- JshWright 7y agoThat would not be the effect of a false positive. In any case, these tests would be used to confirm or rule out SARS-CoV-2 as the cause of someone's symptoms. They wouldn't be used for routine screening of asymptomatic people.
- Amygaz 7y agoI don't know why you are being down voted. The risk is for false-negative, but you are right that people might think this is going to clear them. Even the manufacturer/supplier warns that: "Negative results do not preclude SARS-CoV-2 infection and should not be used as the sole basis for patient management decisions. Negative results must be combined with clinical observations, patient history, and epidemiological information." They also indicate: "The sensitivity is 97.90 %, the specificity is 91.77%." But when you read the technical document you realize that this was for a subset of patient. The real numbers are 88.7% and 90.6% respectively, and again these are for severe cases.
- hackcasual 7y agoThis also requires a blood sample, as opposed to a swab.
- baybal2 7y agoThat's actually better, some competent people said, because the chance of contact with virus carrying bodily fluids is eliminated
- hackcasual 7y agoExcept people generally don't like needle sticks.
- dogma1138 7y agoTrust me they like swabs less they are by far more uncomfortable than a prick.
- 1996 7y agoIt will also detect recent infection after the virus has been wiped out but the antibodies remain. So this is much better than any RNA test to assess the progression of the disease through the population.
- KerrickStaley 7y agoFrom my understanding, this should still detect the virus in individuals with mild or no symptoms, correct? Because those individuals do have an immune response. But what you're saying is that RNA tests will have better recall during the initial stages of infection when the virus is multiplying in someone's body and that person doesn't yet have an immune response?
- Gibbon1 7y agoThat I understand is totally correct.
- adrr 7y agoIt's important to test the public to see the penetration into the population. People who test positive should get an RNA test to determine if infected. People who are not infected become valuable assets to keep logistics and supply chain up and work front line tasks as they have little risk of getting infected. This group people can return back to normal life and don't need to be lockdown.
- CreepGin 7y agoI can't help but ask... How much risk is "little risk" here? Can they still contribute to the spread? And what percentage of population can fall into this group?
- maxerickson 7y agoWe don't know. The period of immunity following infections varies, and this virus is not well understood.
- codyb 7y agoI think if you test positive with an antibody test but not an rna test it means your immune system has the ability to fight it off from a previous infection but the virus isn’t currently multiplying inside you.
- devonbleak 7y agoIf you're testing positive for antibodies and negative for the virus RNA itself it means your immune system has been exposed and recovered. This is also what you'd expect to see in someone that has been vaccinated. They would not be contagious at that point because the virus is not present. This is not the same as someone that gets infected but is asymptomatic - they would still test positive for RNA. The percentage of the population that would naturally fall into this group would likely be very small given this is a novel virus so pretty much nobody's immune system had been exposed prior to a few months ago, and we're seeing pretty massive infection rates globally.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI think it's likely useful for mild cases and for detecting people previously infected. People that recovered can be put to work in hazardous places. And can donate plasma to make serum[1] for treating sick people. [1] Antivirals are a crap shoot but serum works hands down.
- frandroid 7y agoHow about a source for that [1]
- hackcasual 7y agohttps://www.jci.org/articles/view/138003 https://www.jci.org/articles/view/138003 It's far to early to call it a slam dunk for nCov-2, but it is a treatment already used for rabies and hepatitis.
- Gibbon1 7y agoOne of my teachers in the 70's came down with HepA. Health department required all of us to get a immune globulin shot before returning to school.
- product50 7y agoAre you a doctor? If not, why are you commenting on things you have no expertise on?
- seamyb88 7y agoAre you a HN mod? Am I an irony dealer?
- erentz 7y agoOne reason people seem to be missing for why antibody tests are very useful is it will allow us to confirm those that are now immune. We can’t get this from the RNA testing because it’s primarily being used on only symptomatic people at the time they have symptoms (and then only if they can get the test which typically means severe symptoms) But if we start to test widely for antibodies we can start to clear people from this effective quarantine/lock down situation we are going through. Those people can then start to go back to regular life (what’s left of it), moving around as normal, doing work helping others, so on, and that will help all of us (and of course the economy). I don’t know if this is something that anyone official is talking about yet, but it seems like it should be.
- throwaway2048 7y agoThere is evidence that people can become re-infected, so antibodies aren't enough.
- erentz 7y agoThere’s not good evidence of that. There have been cases of people testing negative then positive again but that doesn’t mean they had cleared the virus and got reinfected. It more likely means they had a false negative. (E.g. I have a friend in hospital right now with COVID-19 that has had four tests, one positive, two negative, then one positive again, all tests within the space of four days.) It also can be the case if you are immune compromised that you may clear the virus through good luck, drugs, and your innate immune response. But you never developed a good adaptive immune response and so don’t show a strong antibody response. Immunity to this virus may not last 10+ years, but it’s seeming unlikely that is lasts less than 6 months.
- nroets 7y agoWouldn't it then make sense to have camps where young, healthy adults can go to get immunity by intentionally getting infected and recover ? Then they can go back to having normal lives. The epidemiology version of a controlled burn. If someone take the gamble of intentionally getting the virus, his/her life expectancy is reduced by 3 months (a ballpark figure). If someone stay in isolation until a vaccine arrives, he/she may consider it a greater loss.
- cactus2093 7y agoI don't know how much precedent there is for this type of testing (have we used similar things for Ebola or SARS or measles or anything else?). I've read that this will be useful in broad studies to track how widely the disease might have spread without being diagnosed. But will this type of antibody test eventually be available for any doctor to order for a patient? I'm just getting over a fairly mild but persistent chest cold which also had me with a slight fever last week, and would really like to know if it is/was covid-19 or not. Last week when I still had the worst of the symptoms, my doctor said I didn't meet enough of the criteria to be tested.
- pkaye 7y agoThey are called serology tests and widely available for other viruses and bacteria. Its just that Covid-19 is such a new thing that the tests are just being developed.