4 ms·
You guys are so fast I didn't have time to write anything about it. The purpose is to let users over a certain karma threshold flag spam and troll submissions.
by pg 18y ago
You guys are so fast I didn't have time to write anything about it. The purpose is to let users over a certain karma threshold flag spam and troll submissions.
It should only be used for spams and really egregious trolling, not for stuff that's merely vapid or mistaken or off-topic.
Please don't click on it just to try it out. Flags are really being recorded, so flagging something randomly could damage the reputation of the flagger and/or the submitter of the thing that got flagged.
- run4yourlives 18y agowhoops... excuse my first few flags then... I gave them to some that were merely off topic.
- icey 18y agoIs there some sort of cost associated with flagging? I'm not sure I understand what you mean by "could damage the reputation of the flagger".
- pmjordan 18y agoPresumably, you're wasting moderator time, for which you will burn in hell eternally! By which I mean, you might lose navbar colour and flagging privileges.
- wensing 18y agoNavbar colour? I have 143 karma but I don't see that yet (although I do see 'flag'). Hmm.
- pmjordan 18y agoEr, I didn't say nothing about the navbar secret. >_> Seriously, you get to change the colour of the orange bar at the top when you're at or above 250 karma. Either then or if you can be bothered to set up some user CSS or javascript. :) No idea if there are further perks beyond that.
- mechanical_fish 18y agoWhen you hit 2001 karma you become the Star-Child. Okay, not really. In fact, I'm not sure there are any perks beyond that, either. :)
- icey 18y agoThat brings up a pretty valid point - has anyone broken down what happens with what level of karma? I know at 5 you can downvote comments, and at 250 you can change your bar color. Somewhere in there, you can create polls, but I don't know how that works, so I don't know what level karma is needed.
- pmjordan 18y agoI'm pretty sure I could downvote from 25. Maybe it was originally 5. (seeing as I joined much later than you) I'm at 408, and I can't see a way to start polls, so I'm guessing that's at 500.
- alabut 18y agoYou're probably right about the 25 - I'm still pretty new and my karma is at 17, so I don't see downvoting. I hope the minimum number doesn't keep moving up on me as I approach it :)
- icey 18y agoIt's possible that it has always been 25... I've been wrong before, and I'll be wrong again ;)
- Oompa 18y agoIt's 21 to down vote. I recently got that ability.
- rokhayakebe 18y agoThose who know won't tell. And those who tell don't know.
- 18y ago
- pg 18y agoIf someone flags stuff that turns out to be good (as measured by e.g. not later being killed), it would be reasonable to ignore their flags in future. The sw doesn't do that yet, but when and if that feature appears, it will be based on all flags ever made by an account.
- kirubakaran 18y ago'flag' is now where 'parent' used to be (last link). Until the users get accustomed to this, there might be some unintentional flagging.
- pg 18y agoYou can now unflag.
- kirubakaran 18y agoThanks.
- nadim 18y agoHow about an unflag toggle or an undo? http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=226414 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=226414
- jrockway 18y agoHN appears to be all about not being able to undo things. Is there any operation that's undo-able, other than deleting your own posts?
- pg 18y agoIs there anything that's not undoable, except voting?
- eru 18y agoDoing anything and waiting for some time. But I guess that's by design.
- alabut 18y agoVoting's a pretty big one. I'll own up to the fact that I often use votes as more of a bookmarking tool, to follow up on promising links later when I have more time. As a result, I get the urge to unvote something every once in a long while when I realize that it doesn't deserve good karma. Although if the intent is to discourage that usage pattern and make people more careful about voting in the first place, then it works, at least in my case. I use votes as bookmarks much more extensively on digg, where I know I can undo them.
- icey 18y agoI agree with the voting thing. Although with me, I'm just more likely to accidentally vote something up or down from not being precise enough when clicking. I pay a lot more attention to the precise location of my cursor now, but it used to be bad.
- 18y ago
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- huhtenberg 18y agoCan you make it so that user's first click on the 'flag' link would bring up a short explanation of what the 'flag' does ? I'm sure a lot of people are going to be clicking on it just because it is there. I know I would've if I hadn't ran into this thread first :) (edit) Would it make sense to display current flag count ? Perhaps if it's over certain threshold. It is after all an interesting metric.
- technoguyrob 18y agoCan you add an option for disabling flagging? I probably won't use the option that often (maybe once every few days if not more), so I'd like to hide it until I need it. Too much clutter.
- icey 18y agoHere's a random idea... Display a text box that requires a reason for flagging the post or comment. That would cut down on flagging for the sake of flagging.
- Hexstream 18y agoIsn't that premature? And if some really use it inappropriately then they could just lose their right to flag. No need to bother the vast majority who will use it when it's deserved.
- icey 18y agoWhether it's premature or not, I'm just putting the idea out there. The question is, what does that take away? If the item is truly flagworthy, then it shouldn't be any problem filling in a box. The added benefit is that you have much less accidental flagging.
- bootload 18y ago"... Here's a random idea... Display a text box that requires a reason for flagging the post or comment. ..." It's not a bad idea but it has the same problem as trying to describe why you like something instead of agreeing. I know there's a talk by Barry Schwartz on decision theory ~ http://www.google.com/search?q=paradox+of+choice http://www.google.com/search?q=paradox+of+choice that argues against explaining instead of just choosing. A flag is enough. People around here are pretty smart. The reasons why will mostly be obvious. The only thing I don't like is it ius close to the "delete","parent" tag. My clumsy mouse-hands might hit it by mistake.
- Xichekolas 18y agoThe flag link is appearing on [deleted] posts. Just thought you'd want to know. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=226682 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=226682
- ii 18y agoWhat threshold? I hate to think about karma... I think it's bad for our community.
- ii 18y agoI have it but I still think it is an anti-future, please, remove it
- rms 18y agoDupes?
- bayareaguy 18y agoIt appears both comments and posts have the "flag". I can understand flagging spam posts but comments already have the upvote/downvote mechanism. Does it really make sense to "flag" comments?
- xlnt 18y agoyes, so spam comments can be deleted and the account banned.
- aswanson 18y agoI hit it by accident yesterday, hoping something like "Do you really want to flag this?" would pop up, as does in other features here. To avoid spurious clicks, I would suggest adding a two-phase commit.