8 ms·
> Chloroquine's safety profile isn't great, but the safety profile of COVID is way worse. If you look at Chemotherapy for example, one would never take any of t
by gumby 7y ago
> Chloroquine's safety profile isn't great, but the safety profile of COVID is way worse. If you look at Chemotherapy for example, one would never take any of those drugs unless you had cancer.
The FDA's Office of new drugs is split into divisions (dermatology, oncology etc) and the different divisions have different approval criteria as you mention. From my Onco friends' PoV, cancer patients are pretty much assumed to be dying anyway so the standard of risk is quite different from, say, Derm, whose patients don't really die of anything except cancers.
Note: I have presented to the FDA and have written clinical trial requests (e.g. IND) which have been approved, but I have never done a submission to OOD. However my friends who do really talk about the approval path in a different way than I used to.
Don't self-medicate with chloroquine. It's very hepatotoxic.
- stevespang 7y ago>"Chloroquine's safety profile isn't great, but the safety >profile of COVID is way worse. If you look at Chemotherapy >for example, one would never take any of those drugs unless >you had cancer". EXACTLY - - and chemotherapy has MUCH WORSE side effects than simple chloroquine, used for >70 years, never "recalled".
- cameldrv 7y agoI appreciate an expert opinion here. What do you think is the actual rate of adverse events from Chloloroquine, and of what severity?
- jennyyang 7y agoOne of the comments in the article: I prescribe Plaquenil extensively in patients with autoimmune conditions.The safety profile of this drug is excellent. It is also still used for malaria prophylaxis in healthy individuals .it is not a new drug. I don’t see the reason of labeling it as dangerous. The question is : does it work for Covid19 prevention and treatment? The answer is “the current limited evidence suggests that it does”. What i can tell you that I am aware of a number of doctors in the US who are currently infected or waiting for results who are taking the drug. And I cannot blame them.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- paulmd 7y agoThis whole incident hasn't done much to shake my impression that US doctors are interested first and foremost in making sure they get their "cut" on every prescription, even when the drug is relatively innocuous. Like fine, we can have this discussion about chloroquine. It's behind-the-counter in the UK, so on par with sudafed in terms of access control, and OTC in a lot of countries that actually have to deal with malaria directly. But the same argument gets applied to stuff like oral contraceptives, which are straight-up OTC in a lot of countries too, and can simply be discontinued if you notice symptoms. At the same time, we allow drugs with insanely narrow theraputic ranges like tylenol/acetaminophen/paracetamol (seriously, almost as bad as the chloroquine people are freaking out about, a normal dose is 1-4g and a lethal dose can be as low as 5g) to be sold OTC here with no questions whatsoever. We allow combination products despite obvious risks for multiple dosing, we allow combination products to "dissuade addicts" from abusing opiods (like any addict has ever been dissuaded by a risk bodily harm). And doctors don't make a peep about that, because they're not accustomed to getting their cut on that one. That's also why the AMA resists nurse practitioners so hard. The truth is, a lot of those drugs really should be "behind the counter", a pharmacist should simply have to give you a quick rundown of possible symptoms and what to do if you notice them (discontinue and see a doctor or go to a hospital depending on urgency, same as you would do with a doctor-prescribed drug), but doctors won't allow that because they wouldn't get their cut, so we just call them "nurse practitioners" instead. US doctors really like playing gatekeeper, to a much greater extent than other countries (where coincidentally, money doesn't come into the picture as much).
- pkaye 7y agoDo doctors "get a cut" when their patients buy from a neighborhood pharmacy?
- paulmd 7y agoThey get a couple hundred bucks for a 5 minute office visit to write the prescription, yeah. I'm fine if there's a serious reason for a physical examination, but a lot of stuff the doctor is effectively filling the role of a pharmacist: telling you side effects and if you have this set of serious side effects then to stop it and/or go to a hospital, here's your script, pay at the front desk. A lot of stuff is unnecessarily shoehorned into Rx-only, and despite a lot of talk about "reducing costs" there is no real drive to actually do so. A great example is oral contraceptives. You may have to try a couple different blends before you find the right mix for your body. Some of them will be uncomfortable. Some may cause dangerous bleeding and you need to go to a hospital. There is not zero risk here, or with any drug. But the doctor has no way of telling which might be which for your particular body, they are there to tell you the risks, sign the paper and let you try it out. And that's why oral contraceptives specifically are being looked at as something that could be moved out of Rx only and to either OTC or pharmacist-prescribable - but the problem is there are really a lot of drugs that don't belong there. A pharmacist can read the risks to you just as easily and not charge you $250 for a 15 minute office visit and another $250 for a one-month followup 15 minute office visit. I have lots of 6-month maintenance visits that are literally 5 minutes. Everything going well? "Yup!" "OK, we'll call in your prescription, pay up front". They're just using their gatekeeping power to extract a check.
- teddyvangogh 7y ago1. it's prescription only. 2. it's already available for compassionate use. The FDA is allowing chloroquine and remdesivir to be used for 'compassionate use' to treat the coronavirus. https://www.businessinsider.com/chloroquine-remdesivir-compassionate-use-coronavirus-what-it-means-2020-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/chloroquine-remdesivir-compa...
- cameldrv 7y agoYou don't need compassionate use for Chloroquine. It's FDA approved, so it's just off-label, which doesn't require any hoops, just a prescription from a doctor.
- teddyvangogh 7y agoGreat. I hope it becomes available to everyone. "Novartis, Mylan and Teva to supply tens of millions of chloroquine tablets to fight COVID-19" https://www.fiercepharma.com/pharma/new-commitments-mylan-and-teva-move-to-supply-tens-millions-hydroxychloroquine-tablets-to https://www.fiercepharma.com/pharma/new-commitments-mylan-an...
- pkaye 7y agoMight need to check for G6PD genetic deficiency before taking it though. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glucose-6-phosphate_dehydrogenase_deficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glucose-6-phosphate_dehydrogen...
- teddyvangogh 7y agoright. we need to wait for FDA approval. and since it's prescription only, you need to check with your doctor.
- paulmd 7y agoDoctors: "you need to wait for FDA approval!" also doctors: https://twitter.com/ml_barnett/status/1241172371404357633 https://twitter.com/ml_barnett/status/1241172371404357633 https://twitter.com/JeffreyLowMD/status/1241172812762468353 https://twitter.com/JeffreyLowMD/status/1241172812762468353 https://twitter.com/amberwvzz/status/1241196003425992704 https://twitter.com/amberwvzz/status/1241196003425992704
- barbs 7y agoHeptatoxic: relating to or causing injury to the liver For those not understanding the jargon (like myself).
- robocat 7y agoHepatotoxic is the correct word. Same root with the meaning liver for the words hepatitis and hepatology.
- stevespang 7y agoThe WHO Model List of Essential Medicines (EML), published by the World Health Organization (WHO), contains the medications considered to be most effective and safe to meet the most important needs in a health system.[1] Chloroquine is on that list Case Closed.
- webmobdev 7y ago> Don't self-medicate with chloroquine. It's very hepatotoxic. Also, for those considering to use the Cinchona bark itself as a prophylactic measure, as a natural / herbal / ayurvedic remedy, note that it also has potentially risky side-effects like slowing the heart, constipation and impact on the nervous system. In large quantity cinchona is UNSAFE and can be deadly. Symptoms of overdose include ringing of the ears, headache, nausea, diarrhea, and vision disturbances. Cinchona can also cause bleeding and allergic reactions, including hives and fever. It also interacts with a lot of other medicines like anti-coagulants, heart medicines, antacids etc. Be sure to check your medication list first. Source: https://www.rxlist.com/cinchona/supplements.htm https://www.rxlist.com/cinchona/supplements.htm
- anonuser123456 7y agoCOVID-19 is also hepatotoxic?
- cogntive_elite 7y agoPlease qualify the "very" in "very hepatotoxic." I hear beer and wine are hepatotoxic too. That's why I take milk thistle (silymarin). I assume the Koreans are all taking silymarin with their chloroquine, which is why they aren't dying en masse from liver failure, right?
- pombrand 7y agoNo it's not very hepatotoxic, on the contrary. "Hydroxychloroquine has not been associated with significant serum enzyme elevations during therapy of rheumatologic diseases. Furthermore, clinically apparent liver injury from hydroxychloroquine is rare. " https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK548738/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK548738/ "Despite use for more than 50 years, chloroquine has rarely been linked to serum aminotransferase elevations or to clinically apparent acute liver injury."https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK548224/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK548224/