3 ms·
My grandmother born around 1900 said what happens when you don't have some government market coordination is damaging boom bust cycles in agriculture. Farmers c
by Gibbon1 7y ago
My grandmother born around 1900 said what happens when you don't have some government market coordination is damaging boom bust cycles in agriculture. Farmers chasing last years profits tend to over produce, prices crash and farmers go bankrupt. And if you don't keep your poor urban workers fed really bad things happen politically.
I think there can be a lot of debate about the mix of subsidies and price controls. But the need I think is there. Food is a critical need as we are about to note. And it's really not the end of the world if things aren't perfectly optimal.
- ethbro 7y agoWhile corporate farming gets trotted out as the Boogeyman anytime subsidies are discussed, and is indeed an issue, there's still a lot of non-corporate farming. And it's a hard life. You go into debt to buy machinery and raw materials (seed, fertilizer, pesticide) you need to generate competitive yields... Then it doesn't rain. Or it rains too much. Or the weather is too good in Asia, depressing the global price. And all it takes is a few years of the above, and the bank is foreclosing on property that may have been handed down to you through generations of family, How does that make you feel as a person? And even if everything goes right, what does worrying about that constantly do to you? Farm subsidies are a messy business, fraught with peril, but farmers can't just up and move like most of us. So I'm not unsympathetic to the underlying compassionate goal (even if the realization may be perverted). I guess the closest analogy for many would be being a web dev, if browsers decided to randomize their compatibility with all standards every year. And you needed to take out a loan for a laptop and tooling.