3 ms·
Testing leads to panic. The threat number one to the US economy is panic. Whatever happens next, panic is much much more damaging for the economy and for stabil
by ccktlmazeltov 7y ago
Testing leads to panic. The threat number one to the US economy is panic. Whatever happens next, panic is much much more damaging for the economy and for stability.
There's already a plan in place, and most people don't know it but there's already a timeline. At this point testing people is useless: hospitals already provide numbers to the government.
- jmull 7y agoIf we don’t test, that means doing nothing about it at all, letting it spread unrestricted. If everyone with serious symptoms got good care, we’re talking about 2 million dead. But, of course, a lot of Americans don’t have access to good care on a good day. Since the healthcare system will be massively overwhelmed, only a small percentage will get good care. So you’re talking about something like 5-10 million dead — in the course of months. I don’t think it would get quite that far, though, because once people start literally dying in the streets, people will be afraid and massively self-quarantine. So... maybe four million dead and the economy completely shuts down anyway. Really, the quicker and more aggressively we jump on this, the less the damage, both in terms of human life and economic impact. We’re too late to have a small impact. We’ll feel this for years. Let’s at least try to make something we’ll forget in a generation. Let’s especially make sure we don’t have something they’ll be talking about hundreds of years from now.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- standardUser 7y agoThe more testing, the more you can control the transmission rate. This is all about the transmission rate (you may have heard "flatten the curve" several hundred times recently). Quarantines are a sucky but effective way to reduce the transmission rate. But with testing, isolation can be reduced, which is necessary because quarantines will only be tolerated for so long in Western nations.
- rootusrootus 7y agoI don't agree. The lack of testing means everyone is looking at everyone else as if they are carrying the plague. We're awfully close to full panic as it is. If we could implement wide scale testing with aggressive containment, people who aren't infected could pretty quickly get back to a mostly normal lifestyle. It is much, much more comforting to have a plan than just hunkering down and waiting your turn to find out if you will live or die.