4 ms·
> We use sophisticated tools, including machine learning, to combat them, and we are making it increasingly difficult for bad actors to hide. So sophisticated
by sneak 7y ago
> We use sophisticated tools, including machine learning, to combat them, and we are making it increasingly difficult for bad actors to hide.
So sophisticated that some reporter for wired could find them in the top few hundred bestsellers in a few minutes with a quick visual scan.
Let’s be clear: Amazon should not be censoring legal items on their platform. However, their efforts at stopping it are purely a PR matter, not a real effort.
- kdnvk 7y ago> a quick visual scan Yeah a quick visual scan from a human is super easy to automate.
- sneak 7y agoAmazon is one of the largest employers in the world. It’s lip service, as further evidenced by the tons of fakes on their website. https://www.racked.com/2018/1/8/16849298/amazon-counterfeits-global-entry-customs https://www.racked.com/2018/1/8/16849298/amazon-counterfeits... Anyone who wishes, Amazon staff included, can go and see the $10 “1TB” usb flash drives that are just 16GB drives with hacked firmware to report a different size. It takes about 2 minutes to find them. They don’t bother. The evidence is there if you want it.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoYes: you can give a human the tools and instructions and they'll sit there for ~8hrs a day doing it autonomously.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- anamexis 7y agoAmazon literally has a tool for this (Mechanical Turk)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kube-system 7y agoOr just a plain old text search. One of the examples in the article has "50 pcs disposable surgical mask" in the product name. I just searched that myself on Amazon and got 178 results, and most are at inflated prices.
- maxerickson 7y agoWhat's the difference between a platform that censors and a platform that sorts in a useful way?
- liability 7y agoAsk Amazon; they're the ones who said they'd remove these listings, not derank them. I assume that means they understand the difference.
- maxerickson 7y agoThat's not the question. The question is if you object to a platform having a listing standard, can you at the same time not object to them having a ranking standard. Because sophistry aside, being ranked 15,000 for "column 298" reasons is the same thing as being removed. And then being ranked by "column 298" is the same thing as being ranked by orangeness or whatever, it's a subjective score.
- theamk 7y ago"sort in a useful way" benefits consumer of information "censoring" benefits someone else The easy indicator is an ability to control: you can do "Sort by price" to disable sorting, but there is never a "do not censor" checkbox
- TrumpMyGuns 7y agoThey love PR speak and buzzwords. I'm still waiting on my "Amazon Executive Support" person to explain how I was sent previously opened and seemingly washed socks. How about all the other opened products I get listed as new? The fake reviews that are oh-so obvious and have been around for years without a dent? They are top tier BS. I take advantage of them as much as I can ;) After all the stuff they've made me return or sold me as new, I don't feel bad at all.
- gentleman11 7y agoIt seems to be that a single intern whose only job was to search for prohibited items and unlist them could do better Really, just use Mechanical Turk. Their inability to handle this is obviously showing they intend to not fix it
- FireBeyond 7y agoFor exactly the same reason as you can't report an item as counterfeit on return. They have no intention of fixing.
- toasterlovin 7y agoFWIW, the real reason is that sellers abusing mechanisms like this to create issues for their competitors is a huge problem on Amazon's platform.
- j-c-hewitt 7y agoYou can create hundreds of thousands of listings almost instantly through the API or by uploading a spreadsheet to Amazon. It's not possible for manual review for all of them because of this. That is why they lean so heavily on both automation and armies of cheap contractors.
- Symbiote 7y agoSuspend/delete accounts (and all listings) for anyone with a single violation. Problem solved.
- matharmin 7y agoAnd then you'll get the "My account has been banned by Amazon after misclassifying a single listing" posts. There are two sides to the problem, and changing criteria for suspension just shifts it to the other side.
- birdyrooster 7y ago
- Reedx 7y agoThey remove massive numbers of products, though. Millions have been removed related to Coronavirus alone: https://www.wsj.com/articles/amazon-battles-counterfeit-masks-400-hand-sanitizer-amid-virus-panic-11583880384 https://www.wsj.com/articles/amazon-battles-counterfeit-mask...
- nitwit005 7y ago> Amazon should not be censoring legal items on their platform. Price gouging during a disaster or emergency is often illegal. And I suspect they're violating laws exporting them in the first place as most countries don't want medical supplies leaving just so people can make a quick buck.
- homero 7y agoThey're not legal if they're fakes, most of those look like fakes
- slezyr 7y ago> We use sophisticated tools, including machine learning We do nothing, but to dodge any possible legal liability related to the price gouging. We'll say that we use "machine learning" so we could respond to any critique with "oops, algo is bad, but we do our best efforts" while doing nothing.