3 ms·
I still think that AI shuttles and buses driving predetermined routes and schedules would be tremendously useful. Especially if they could operate continuously
by chrisco255 7y ago
I still think that AI shuttles and buses driving predetermined routes and schedules would be tremendously useful. Especially if they could operate continuously 24/7. And that should be possible, with maybe tele-operators dialing in to override the edge cases or sending dispatch crews to takeover for any issues that come up.
- stefan8r 7y agoThis is true, but essentially every transit system in the world (minus Hong Kong and Singapore's) operates at a loss. Maybe you can save money vis a vis unionized drivers, but I'm not wildly optimistic.
- shorts_theory 7y agoTo my knowledge, Singapore's SBS Transit loses money on their transportation business, but makes it up with their construction projects.
- delackner 7y agoThis is untrue. Tokyo Metro is one of the largest systems by ridership in the world, and operates at a profit. It does have sizable capital investments that take years to pay down. This also completely ignores the halo effects of these systems that vastly increase the economic output of the region. This is why it is often logical for the state to pay for the system, since the costs are centralized and the profits are distributed.
- chubot 7y agoHow's Lyft Shuttle doing? (genuine question, I don't know) https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2017/06/lyft-reinvents-the-bus.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2017/06/lyft-reinvents-the-b... The point is that we already have self-driving vehicles. You press a button on your phone and somebody drives you around. Whether it's a premium ride, a shared ride, or a bus is an orthogonal issue to whether the driver is human, which is a matter of cost. The fact that it's a cost issue makes it look even worse and further out for driverless. If there is demand for a shuttle along predetermined routes, it would already exist with a driver, and that's what Lyft Shuttle is if I understand correctly. I haven't seen it in SF or heard of anyone using it. It's definitely possible that they could figure out the product and it will become popular, but that has little to do with self-driving.
- golemiprague 7y agoThere are certain aspects of the technology which can reduce infrastructure cost, for example a train following two lines on the road rather than actual tracks, it is already happening in China and saves money. So there are technology aspects which could improve transportation by utilising certain "AI" solutions but yeah, not necessarily driver less.
- IanCal 7y ago> The fact that it's a cost issue makes it look even worse and further out for driverless. I see it the other way, they slot immediately and easily into already existing businesses and if the only difference is cost consumers are likely to swap over.
- FpUser 7y agoUnless they ride on purpose built/adapted roads I doubt it'll happen in any realistic time.