3 ms·
Lots of comments in here getting it exactly right. Asking Netflix to change will have almost no effect. Netflix already adjusts stream quality based on "inter
by jedberg 7y ago
Lots of comments in here getting it exactly right. Asking Netflix to change will have almost no effect. Netflix already adjusts stream quality based on "internet weather" and already has most of the stream sources really close to the user. And has for years and is pretty good at it now. (Source: I worked there and worked on a lot of this stuff).
But it also makes sense for the CEO to make the political gesture and appease the EU commissioner.
- lxgr 7y agoCould it not have a significant impact on the last mile of providers (which is often a shared medium)? Deprioritizing Netflix would also solve that, but given that this is illegal in several countries, providers there are likely lacking the infrastructure or know how to implement such a policy on short notice, even if these laws were temporarily suspended.
- jedberg 7y agoUnlikely, because Netflix accounts for traffic on the entire segment and aggregates data. It would be possible that you are the only one on your segment watching Netflix and everyone else is using Zoom or something, but if that were the case then your one stream wouldn't make a difference if it was at lower quality. In other words, this would only help if a lot of people on your segment are watching Netflix, and if a lot of people on your segment are watching Netflix, then Netflix has a whole bunch of data on exactly how full that segment is and will adjust accordingly.
- lxgr 7y agoThat makes sense! I didn't consider that Netflix would actively scale down quality in that way (i.e., backing off to achieve less than 1/n proportional bandwidth share), but ISPs probably ask for something like that quite regularly.