4 ms·
I said this last night to a friend: The United States (and all nations really) need to look at supply chains the way we look at AWS regions. You don't build any
by unethical_ban 7y ago
I said this last night to a friend: The United States (and all nations really) need to look at supply chains the way we look at AWS regions. You don't build anything in just one region when it's in production - you always have redundancy, in this case, geographical and political redundancy if possible.
We have strategic reserves of petroleum, foodstocks, and other necessities. It is time to think about the same with medicines, medical supplies, and common household goods.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIt's not stupidity that caused supply chain fragility. People involved understand the benefits of redundancy. It's the market that doesn't. It's fundamentally unable to protect itself against black swan events, because they're (by definition) outside of its optimization horizon. Redundancies and buffers that could protect us from once-in-couple-decades events are considered as "fat", and are cut off by competitive pressure. The conclusion from this is that, unless there is regulation directly addressing this, nothing will change, because the market forces are what they are.
- vibrolax 7y agoThe value of robust and redundant supply chains only becomes manifest when serious disruption actually occurs. In vast swaths of both the consumer and industrial economy, the supply chain bean counters have tolerated no argument for choosing anyone besides the low cost supplier. Cost optimizations were the only rewarded metrics.
- at-fates-hands 7y ago>> Redundancies and buffers that could protect us from once-in-couple-decades events are considered as "fat", and are cut off by competitive pressure. THIS. My brother-in-law owns a company and they put in place a ton of redundancies after the 08' crash. They're in a specialized manufacturing. After 6-7 years of stability and some of their markets recovering and stabilizing, he started getting pressure from his two partners to cut the safety nets and re-invest it in supply chain improvements. He was against it saying the same thing, "This isn't a five or six year plan, it's a permanent plan to protect the company." In short, he was outvoted. The redundancies were removed and the money was re-invested in other areas. . The last week basically saw their entire supply chain shut down, almost all of their customers shut down and yesterday they had to send everybody home and shut down themselves for the time being. My brother in law texted me saying, "This is the worst fucking "I told you so" in my life, I'm not sure we can survive this." He's meeting with his partners this week to assess the damage and how long they can survive before they'll need an influx of capital to keep the lights on. Had they kept all of their money tied up in their emergency plan, they would've been able to pivot to other suppliers and continue to serve their clients. Right now? They put all their eggs into one basket and it could very well kill the company.
- stormdennis 7y agoThis is good then. The company with the cheaper but vulnerable supply chain suffers and the companies who paid a premium for robustness in their chain benefit. That's how capitalism is supposed to work I think.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoExcept the market has very short memory. In the next couple of years, the more robust companies that survive this pandemic will get outcompeted by less robust companies, or forced to become less robust themselves.
- lutorm 7y agoExcept those companies have already folded because they couldn't compete during "normal" times.
- quanticle 7y agoIt's fundamentally unable to protect itself against black swan events, because they're (by definition) outside of its optimization horizon. I agree with your conclusion, but I want to push back on the assertion that COVID19 was a "black swan". Pandemics (especially pandemics such as this one) are not black swans. Numerous experts saw predicted them. There were examples of similar events in the recent past (for example, SARS, MERS, H5N1 influenza, etc). The reason markets are bad at dealing with pandemic preparation is the same reason that markets are bad at dealing with pollution. It's a collective action problem. The benefit of pandemic preparation is spread across society in a diffuse manner, whereas the costs are borne by the individual manufacturers and distributors who take on the increased transaction costs of dealing with three or four suppliers, when their competitors get away with only having one or two. It's analogous to dumping untreated sewage in a river. Even if the executives at a want to install scrubbers, as long as it has a competitor who can manufacture goods or provide services more cheaply by dumping untreated sewage, the company cannot do so, because the costs incurred will put it at a competitive disadvantage, and it will lose business to its competitor. In the same way, even if executives understand that having a supply chain dependent on a few key suppliers is a potential liability, they can't diversify as long as those suppliers are the lowest cost option, and moving away would result in them providing the same goods and services at a higher cost than their competition.
- danans 7y ago> Pandemics (especially pandemics such as this one) are not black swans. Numerous experts saw predicted them. Black swans aren't necessarily unpredicted. In fact they are usually predicted by a few people, but the predictions run so counter to the interests of established set of systems and models, that they are ignored. In the book, Taleb actually spins a story about an individual who spends his entire life predicting and preparing for an invasion by barbarians, but is ignored, and upon his deathbed, the invasion happens. People are constantly making predictions, many of which are very implausible, but it's never clear when one of those will turn into a black swan. The pandemics you listed were different from this one in that they were not nearly as transmissible, even though some were deadlier on an individual level. A lot of people got used to thinking: "that kind of stuff only happens in those kind of countries, not here".