4 ms·
> The new policy bans tweets denying expert guidance on the virus, encouraging “fake or ineffective treatments, preventions and diagnostic techniques” as well a
by gnicholas 7y ago
> The new policy bans tweets denying expert guidance on the virus, encouraging “fake or ineffective treatments, preventions and diagnostic techniques” as well as tweets that mislead users by pretending to be from health authorities or experts.
What happens when two experts disagree with each other? This rule seems to assume that experts are all in agreement on everything.
- hirsin 7y agoThere's nothing there that indicates they'd take down two experts with conflicting views. It simply assumes that non-experts (specifically those pretending to be experts) shouldn't be listened to.
- gnicholas 7y agoSo if someone tweets something said by one expert, but which another expert disagrees with, then what? Do you have to cite the expert who agrees with you in order to not get yanked? Twitter doesn't have thousands of fact checkers/researchers on staff, last I checked, so presumably they're not in a great position to determine whether a tweet is backed by any experts, assuming just one is enough.
- busterarm 7y agoThis app/website needs to go.
- happytoexplain 7y agoAn interesting position for somebody with an apparently absolutist interpretation on the topic of censorship.
- busterarm 7y agoYes, because they absolutely cannot be trusted to be in the position that they've put themselves in. They're bad stewards. They're made themselves into censors.
- microcolonel 7y agoWHO themselves have several tweets still up suggesting that the virus is incapable of human-to-human spread. Suppressing "unofficial" or "inexpert" advice is extremely dangerous, I know people who would not have supplies by now if I hadn't convinced them two months ago that, because China is willing to shut down their economy to stop the spread of it, it is probably going to be extremely serious. I hope they do not crack down on genuine, proactive communications: saying that the pathogen is more transmissible than it is yet officially recognized to be, or genuine arguments for more proactive isolation.
- sb057 7y ago"Preliminary investigations conducted by the Chinese authorities have found no clear evidence of human-to-human transmission of the novel #coronavirus (2019-nCoV) identified in #Wuhan, #China" - WHO https://twitter.com/WHO/status/1217043229427761152 https://twitter.com/WHO/status/1217043229427761152
- systemvoltage 7y agoI am not an expert at epidemiology but I found WHO's leadership sorely lacking, profoundly confused and generally weak in every way.
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoI don’t know if WHO was just incompetent with that statement or was protecting / taking direction from the Chinese, but it’s pretty fascinating to be THAT wrong.
- Medicalidiot 7y agoThis is an interesting paradigm, but I'd assume that anything going against CDC/WHO guidelines will be removed. I had a physics professor in undergrad that still wasn't sold on the entire dark matter/dark energy phenomena and was proudly in the <1% of physicists who shared his beliefs.
- happytoexplain 7y ago>This rule seems to assume that experts are all in agreement on everything. I don't see this implied anywhere. Are you reading something I'm not?
- alkonaut 7y ago> What happens when two experts disagree with each other? This rule seems to assume that experts are all in agreement on everything. Nothing! That happens all the time. If twitter can just cull the most dangerous disinformation that's a huge improvement. What remains doesn't need to be consensus, just not disinformation.
- dilap 7y agoImplicit in this is that we should trust Twitter's judgement to be better than our own. Let me see all opinions and make up my own mind. This should not be a radical idea in a free society.
- wilde 7y agoIt’s not feasible for you to see all opinions given the amount of content on Twitter. Twitter hides content from you all the time through ranking (if enabled) and follower graphs. They’re choosing to hide more content now than they normally would, which is their right as a private publisher.
- dilap 7y agoThis isn't about adjusting content filters, it's actually banning tweets. Users are forced to remove them. (And fwiw, I use the unfiltered timeline view, combined w/ lists. I hate algorithmic timelines.)