3 ms·
Rule of thumb: Apparent exponential growth means you've zoomed in too far on the chart you're looking at. The important change was actually always-on Network a
by tialaramex 7y ago
Rule of thumb: Apparent exponential growth means you've zoomed in too far on the chart you're looking at.
The important change was actually always-on Network access, but that's often muddled up with the step to 512kbps or more commonly 1MBps DSL service labelled "broadband" - because for most users both happened together.
There wasn't then and isn't now a practical need for "10G at home in western cities for everyone". Getting to 10Mbps allowed almost all the applications you'd actually want, and 100Mbps makes that practical if several people in a household are doing different things - maybe you're in a a video conference while the kids watch movies. But continued exponential growth needs a compelling application, and no practical application was found.
Fibre (often muddled together with these higher bandwidth offerings) makes sense for new builds because it's cheaper to produce and has good reliability. But ripping out working copper networks to add fibre is like demolishing an otherwise perfectly good bridge to put in a nicer bridge. It's not impossible but it is a waste of resources.
- fulafel 7y agoWell, the mobile side is certainly betting on "if you build the bandwidth, the apps will come". In fixed broadband the same is still happening albeit more slowly, we have streaming tv, then hd/4k streaming movies, then games ala ps live/Stadia, enormous gb console/pc game downloads .. new apps are continuously enabled by improving bw & latency.
- filleokus 7y agoI moved from 100 Mbit/s to 1 Gbit/s (up/down both times) and haven't really noticed a difference. I'm still the only one using it in my household, mostly over wifi which caps me around ≈ 300 Mbits/s effectively. I think you have to consider the quite limited multi tasking for bandwidth consumption. Worst case scenario I'm downloading some big file and streaming video at the same time, but that happens very early. Most realistically I'm only using one service at a time. We also have to consider the asymmetrical nature of service consumption. Netflix et. al aren't event close to saturating a 100 mbit/s connection with video, nor are most places I download stuff so fast that I'm saturating my wifi-link. This will probably age bad, but I think "100 Mbit/s low-latency bandwidth per person ought to be enough for anyone".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jacques_chester 7y agoThe important number for videoconferencing is the uplink. That is typically set at an insultingly small fraction of the downlink, so in practice you need to buy the Ultra Hyper Globo Super Duper Speed Pro package to get anything better than a Mondrian painting slideshow.
- iptrans 7y agoIt’s not so simplistic. It may make perfectly good sense to pull out copper and push in fiber. It costs money to run and maintain a copper network. Fiber networks are less costly to operate and maintain. In a rational world copper would be replaced immediately with fiber when total cost of ownership over the lifetime of the asset is less for fiber than copper.
- fulafel 7y agoLet's not get hung on fiber vs copper, the same type of advances make radio and copper carry more BW. But we are not deploying faster signaling on copper fast enough either, due to lack of investment and resulting slowdown of copper speedups making it to the market.
- iptrans 7y agoNo they don’t. Technological advances make copper and radio carry more bandwidth OVER SHORTER DISTANCES. This is why WISP are deploying micro POPs and cellular carriers are deploying small cells. This is a huge difference compared to fiber where the same infrastructure will scale from 100M to 100G. Forklift upgrades and truck rolls are expensive. Copper and radio aren’t like fiber where swapping a $9 optic for a $19 optic makes you go from 1G to 10G. All this makes a massive difference in TCO in fiber’s favor over the lifetime of the assets. Providing fixed line service over copper or radio is silly in the long term as each upgrade requires you to build out fiber closer and closer to the end user bit by bit. Better to do it at once and reap the benefits, both in terms of service and costs. Not deploying faster signaling in copper networks is also a misstatement. Cable networks are busy splitting nodes, deploying more fiber and upgrading to faster versions of DOCSIS all the time. Most telcos have already transitioned to fiber and are not building out copper anymore. Here the US is an outlier, as the telcos here are just milking the existing copper assets for revenues until they exit the business.
- leetcrew 7y ago100Mbps probably is enough for a single family if they can actually get it. the fact that netflix streams are apparently saturating the network implies there is a practical use case for a less underprovisioned backhaul.